Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

30 for 30: My list of the 30 “Greatest” American horses of the last 30 years

My earliest memories truly following the sport of horse racing are of following the career of the legendary Cigar, 30 years ago. When I say follow I mean having my grandfather read articles from the newspaper exclaiming that Cigar had “won again”, you see I was still too young to read a newspaper, or anything for that matter, besides a racing form. That was easy for me, especially seeing all of those 1’s on the past performance line. Perhaps that near invincibility is what drew me to him, or maybe its that his name reminded me of my grandfather who introduced me to “the game” and who could always be found puffing on a Cigar while at the track. Anyway, thinking of Cigar today has me thinking of all the other ratings greats I have witnessed in my 30 years watching and following horse racing and I thought what better way to combine two of my favorite things ( horse racing and ranking lists) than offering my top 30 greatest american race horses of the last 30 years for us all to debate. The list is not “best” or “top” , it is great which in my definition is the combination of raw ability, peak performance, and achievement. So here is the list

  1. ​American Pharoah — Ended a grueling 37-year Triple Crown drought in 2015 and punctuated his historic season by dominating the Breeders’ Cup Classic to secure the first-ever “Grand Slam.”
  2. ​Flightline — An untouchable, undefeated modern freak of nature whose jaw-dropping 19¼-length romp in the 2022 Pacific Classic and elite speed figures place him at the pinnacle of raw ability.
  3. ​Cigar — The charismatic icon of the 1990s who put together a legendary 16-race win streak, capturing the inaugural Dubai World Cup and earning back-to-back Horse of the Year titles.
  4. ​Zenyatta — A beloved, undefeated queen who won her first 19 starts, famously dropping back to last before flying past the boys to capture the 2009 Breeders’ Cup Classic.
  5. ​Curlin — A two-time Horse of the Year and global dirt dominator who captured the Preakness, Breeders’ Cup Classic, and Dubai World Cup with relentless, iron-willed brilliance.
  6. ​Ghostzapper — A brilliant combination of blazing speed and tactical dominance, capped by a 2004 Horse of the Year campaign that included a tour-de-force victory in the Breeders’ Cup Classic.
  7. ​Arrogate — Enjoyed one of the most explosive peaks in racing history, stunningly sweeping the Travers Stakes, Breeders’ Cup Classic, Pegasus World Cup, and Dubai World Cup in succession.
  8. ​Gun Runner — A powerhouse multi-year champion who dominated older male dirt racing in 2017, culminating in a brilliant, emotional victory in the Breeders’ Cup Classic.
  9. ​Tiznow — The ultimate fierce competitor and the only two-time winner of the Breeders’ Cup Classic, famously “winning one ” for America in 2001.
  10. ​Justify — Joined the immortals in 2018 by sweeping the Triple Crown while remaining completely undefeated through all six starts of his brief, explosive career.
  11. ​Skip Away — A legendary, hard-knocking iron horse who raced against top-tier competition year after year, racking up multiple Eclipse Awards and historic earnings.
  12. ​Rachel Alexandra — A trailblazing filly in 2009 who boldly took on and defeated the boys in the Preakness Stakes, Haskell Invitational, and Woodward Stakes.
  13. ​Wise Dan — A back-to-back Horse of the Year turf titan who combined fierce consistency, versatility, and unmatched acceleration across multiple seasons.
  14. ​Beholder — A fierce, multi-division distaff legend who won Eclipse Awards across multiple ages and famously defeated the boys in a thrilling 2016 Pacific Classic.
  15. ​California Chrome — A wildly popular fan-favorite dual-classic winner who proved his enduring class by returning at age 5 to dominate top-flight international competition.
  16. ​Invasor — Champion imported from Uruguay who proved his absolute dominance by sweeping both the Breeders’ Cup Classic and the Dubai World Cup.
  17. ​Point Given — A towering, monstrous physical specimen who would avenge his poor performance in the Kentucky Derby by winning 4 consecutive million dollar Grade One races.
  18. ​Silver Charm — A gritty, courageous warrior of the late 90s who won the Kentucky Derby and Preakness and narrowly missed the Triple Crown in a heart-pounding Belmont. Would win the Dubai World Cup among other graded stakes as a 4 and 5 year old
  19. ​Azeri — A dominant, brilliant distaff queen who captured the Horse of the Year title in 2002 amidst an incredible streak of top-tier stakes victories against fillies and mares.
  20. ​Smarty Jones — Captured the heart of the entire nation in 2004 with an undefeated run through the Derby and Preakness, sparking a massive surge in mainstream racing popularity.
  21. ​Awesome Again — The older champion of 1998 who capped his perfect season by defeating arguably the deepest field in Breeders’ Cup Classic history before becoming a elite sire.
  22. ​Bricks and Mortar — Recorded a flawless, historic 6-for-6 campaign in 2019—including five Grade 1s—to capture the Horse of the Year title as a pure turf champion.
  23. ​Afleet Alex — Remembered for one of the most astonishing moments in racing history, clipping heels and nearly falling in the Preakness before recovering to win, followed by a runaway Belmont romp.
  24. ​Tepin — The undisputed queen of the turf mile, traveling internationally to conquer Royal Ascot and dominating male rivals against the odds.
  25. ​Monomoy Girl — A model of consistency and grit, securing multiple Eclipse Awards as a dominant, multi-year champion in the distaff division.
  26. ​Mineshaft — A brilliant older dirt male who put together a stellar 2003 campaign, stringing together multiple Grade 1 victories to secure Horse of the Year honors.
  27. ​English Channel — A turf router of immense quality and stamina, racking up multiple Grade 1 triumphs and a stellar Breeders’ Cup Turf victory in 2007.
  28. ​Royal Delta — A majestic, back-to-back Breeders’ Cup Ladies’ Classic winner who reigned supreme over the distaff division with powerful, sweeping strides.
  29. ​Songbird — A brilliant, nearly flawless champion who dominated her generation race after race, suffering only a single heartbreaking defeat in a legendary Breeders’ Cup duel.
  30. ​Shared Belief — An undefeated, fiercely talented 2 year old champion whose electrifying acceleration made him one of the most feared and exciting racehorses of his era.

Honorable Mentions

  • ​Real Quiet — The gritty, long-striding champion of 1998 who swept the Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes under trainer Bob Baffert. He came agonizingly close to securing the Triple Crown, missing by just a nose to Victory Gallop in a heart-pounding finish at the Belmont Stakes.
  • ​Havre de Grace — The brilliant 2011 Horse of the Year. A fierce distaff superstar, she famously took the fight directly to the boys and defeated them in a thrilling edition of the historic Woodward Stakes, cementing her legacy as one of the toughest fillies of the modern era.
  • ​Blame — A powerhouse classic-distance runner best remembered for his unforgettable 2010 Breeders’ Cup Classic victory. In doing so, he delivered the only defeat of the legendary Zenyatta‘s career in a heart-stopping stretch duel that decided the Horse of the Year title.
  • ​Lava Man — The ultimate claim-to-fame “everyman” hero who transformed from a modest $50,000 claimer into a multi-million dollar superstar. He thrilled California racing fans by capturing back-to-back Santa Anita Handicaps and sweeping the prestigious Hollywood Gold Cup, Santa Anita Handicap, and Pacific Classic in the same year (2006). He is the only horse to win a Grade One races on Dirt ,Turf, and Synthetic
  • ​Accelerate — A dominant older dirt male who enjoyed a monstrous 2018 campaign. Trained by John Sadler, he swept major West Coast preps like the Santa Anita Handicap and Gold Cup before securing his championship credentials with a resounding victory in the Breeders’ Cup Classic at Churchill Downs.
  • ​Barbaro — The brilliant, undefeated winner of the 2006 Kentucky Derby who captured the public’s imagination with his breathtaking, 6½-length romp at Churchill Downs. Widely considered one of the most naturally gifted talents of his generation, he was a classic what if in racing but his heart showed both on the track and in his valiant effort during his attempted recovery.

What do you think? Who did I miss or who did I rank incorrectly. Please share your opinions or your list!

5 thoughts on “30 for 30: My list of the 30 “Greatest” American horses of the last 30 years”

  • nextbonus

    No problem with your list. I would have put Flightline first but cannot argue against Pharaoh. Thanks for the memories!

  • dixiedotco

    Agreed with nextbonus, but it all depends on how you determine the rankings. Flightline was subjectively the superior animal talent wise, but American Pharoah definitely “accomplished” more, given the circumstances.

    • oakridgePost author

      Agree with you both that Flightline was the “best” horse but I went with “greatest” so Pharoah got the nod based on accomplishments

    • oakridgePost author

      Zenyatta is my favorite horse on the list. I ultimately valued Cigar’s 16 race win streak higher than her 19 race streak. I actually think her perfect record hurt her legacy in the sense that her connections kept mostly against fillies and mares I believe to find better spots to keep the streak alive. I believe if she lost one earlier in her career we would have seen her against the boys in the Big Cap, Hollywood Gold Cup etc during the year which would enhance her legacy more than a win streak in my opinion. The majority of her career and her Breeder’s Cup victories being on synthetic also knocked her down a peg for me which is unfortunate because I actually believe her best races were on dirt the Apple Blossom beating Ginger Punch and her loss to Blame in the Classic. The synthetic may have also played against her in registering any eye popping speed figures which is also a knock against her.

Leave a Reply