Reading the Tea Leaves – Sire Upgrades North America Edition
So it’s that time of year when players are wondering which sires are getting upgraded (and downgraded). I’m going to prognosticate on those worthy of upgrades and which may have caught Mike & Frank’s eyes. So here goes, North American edition:
Gun Runner. Okay this one is not a secret, the dynamic duo confirmed in the Twitch stream last night that this guy is getting an upgrade. He’s already good but obviously going to get better. He is very deserving of it, as he is currently the second leading sire in North America. He’s standing for $250,000 for 2025 so no brainer.
The sire above Gun Runner on the sires list is Into Mischief. Alright some of you are saying he’s one of the best sires in the game already. But consider this: Into Mischief is so dominant that he is ahead of Gun Runner on the sires list by almost twelve million dollars. He leads in black type runners, black type winners, graded stakes winners and grade one winners. This will be the sixth year in a row that Into Mischief has lead the sires list. So why do I have him on my list? In a stream earlier in the year Frank seemed to not know just HOW dominant Into Mischief has been compared to say, Tapit who has lead the sires list three times in his longer stud career. Not saying he’s getting a huge bump but a push may be necessary.
Speaking of Frank’s opinions it is no secret that he has advocated for Twirling Candy. Looking at his stats he’s a solid sire already. But he is currently the leading sire of turf runners for North American sires. In the game he gets nearly 70% of his earnings from dirt runners. I wouldn’t be surprised if his propensity for siring turf runners gets bumped (and maybe an overall bump is warranted as well).
Another sire who might need a surface propensity adjustment is Justify. He gets nearly 80% of his earnings from dirt races but his best runners in real life have been turfers. Tops among these is European Horse of the Year City of Troy. He’s standing for $250,000 for 2025 but he’s already quite good in the game so not sure about an overall bump.
Standing alongside Justify at Ashford Stud is Practical Joke. He’s having a great year on the track and his stud fee is going from $45,000 to $75,000, a significant bump. He’s also doing well in the sales ring. Aside from his very strong form is that he may be a favorite of a certain industry insider who advises our devs on sire ratings.
Then there are the flying freshmen. I have to add a caveat here that sires rarely get changed based solely on their first two year old runners but this crop of freshmen are really looking strong. There’s less than $100,000 separating the top three stallions on the sire list and they each lead in significant interior stats. Current leading sire Mckinzie had an unusually good day on Breeders’ Cup preview day at Aqueduct when his son Chancer MckPatrick won the Champagne and his daughter Scottish Lassie won the Frizette, both of which are grade one stakes. In addition to those two he has two grade one placed runners. Leading sire by black type horses is Vekoma who is currently second on the sires list. He has the lowest percentage of stakes winners of the three sires in the sim so he is definitely outperforming what his seeming sim record would indicate. The last of the three in this group is Tiz the Law. He leads the sires list by black type winners and matches Mckinzie by graded stakes winners. He looks like he is the best rated of these three in the game currently so I would say he’s the least likely to get a boost but you never know.
So who do you like to get a bump? And any you think need a downgrade? Comment below.
One European sire currently producing decent 2yo sprinters is Sands of Mali (usually available in game for minimum creds/BPs). As this is his first crop, he could be one to watch but buyer beware, his progeny tend towards All-Weather tracks (poly) and his stakes performers are running against equally undistinguished youngsters.
Mckinzie needs a bump up for sure…i hear he was bumped recently but has not produced a graded winner this season in game…
nice write up – thanks!
Nyquist has 9 Grade 1 winners from 5 crops, 4 of them in 2024…his stud fee went from 85k to 17k…nuff said
Oscar performance has produced 5 graded stakes winner’s this tear and his stud fee has moved from 25k to 45k
Thousand Words, sire of The Queens MG, is a top five first-crop sire in NA….his stud fee has moved from 5k to 12.5k
I’ll place my focus on those three…as for Practical Joke, I have always been a fan…getting a Gun Runner or Into Mischief, well I should live so long
im sitting on a Thousand Words share hoping for his bump as well
That should read 175k for Nyquist
ahhh breath a sigh of relief, as there still are hidden gems avail. I guess practical joke will be higher priced and more demand now.. But still a fun read SPIN.
Anecdotally, I’ve been using Into Mischief for several years. I did get a G-1 winner from him early on but other than that one outlier, I never got ANYTHING that could beat a fat man to the dinner table. Furthermore, the females not only sucked on the track, they have produced ABSOLUTLY NOTHING.
The mares have at least decent back ends.
INTO MISCHIEF x UNBRIDLED x PRIVATE ACCOUNT (auction purchase as broodmare – big mistake)
INTO MISCHIEF x STREET CRY x GIANT’S CAUSEWAY (dam stakes placed and won $327,000)
INTO MISCHIEF x QUALITY ROAD x DEPUTY MINISTER (scratch bred)
Go figure.
Same. There are probably some great Into Mischiefs out there, but for a sire who is far and away the most productive sire in NA in real life, he sure seems like a giant underachiever in the sim. Have used him somewhat regularly for years, and while I might have gotten a few decent ones, for the most part they have all been claiming or low allowance level, and all of them either have very expensive DS/DDS from scratch, or are out of elitely bred and/or elite racemares.
It’s gotten to the point where I just won’t use him anymore unless it’s clear there is some significant bump given how much he costs.
Nice, well done article Spin!!!
The thing with Into Mischief is his number of runners he has had 461 this year. In terms of actual conversion of runners into grade stakes runners the results are not as impressive as many other stallions.
Stallions today are really up against it and the US is the worst around half of all mares are bred to first or second crop sires. When you consider that over 95% of stallions retired to stud are useless this means a lot of bad horses are being bred.
It is hard for decent stallions to attract mares which suppresses quality. It is no surprise stallions are sold in their fourth season as a “new dud” will generate a lot more income and studs are running a business.
Oscar Performance was mentioned and his statistic spectrum looks very good, easily the most visually eye catch of stallions in North America outside of Gun Runner. City of Light and Collected also have decent profiles in terms of results verses expectations.
Justify is in a tricky situation Coolmore who sent him lots of mares have gone down the Wotton Basset route and his 2yo results have been spectacular we know where the mares will be going which is going to have a big impact on Justify. the mare quality has carried him and overall his result spectrum is below expectations.
I know it’s rare for deceased sires to get a bump, but I think with Thorpedo Anna’s amazing season and competing for Horse Of The Year, Fast Anna deserves a bump. He was a $5,000 stallion starting out, and was never sent a full quality book of mares. He would be the hottest sire this upcoming breeding season and would finally get a quality book. I hope he gets a bump as a DS.
He’s also out of my favorite horse of all time – Dreaming of Anna. So I may be a little biased.
Spin, as usual it is always good to hear your thoughts. The comments made about Into Mischief were spot on. Into Mischief has improved over the years with offspring proving that they can get 10F if crossed with the right mare. Another sire that got a bad rap for not producing 10F horses was Storm Cat whose influence was huge with Juveniles but struggled when stretched to classic distances.
The game has always favored the classic type stallion whether dirt or turf. The game also leans heavily towards turf with top sires Irish and English scoring a dirt classic from time to time. This is very unusual in that most great turf sires have that larger dish foot better suited for traveling on the grass. Quality Road is another sire that is spectacular but breeders are starting to dislike the unpredictability of what kind of horse they are going to get. He is capable of throwing monsters but I’ve noticed that the sim leans a little more to the sprint dirt side. Sorry the comment was so long winded but I do love to talk pony’s.