Sire Chat 3/21/2018
This weekend was a slow one in the wide world. Some good races won by horses sired by well-known sires and some that seem like the best their sires have to offer. There was one race in particular that I wanted to mention, an allowance at Santa Anita won by a filly named Spectator, a daughter of Jimmy Creed. But certain sim events have also suggested that a discussion of how to find value in the game may also be worth undertaking. Heretofore stallions who have been profiled are generally less well known to players in the United States and that is still the general focus going forward. But sometimes there is value available and it is worth paying attention to.
Jimmy Creed is absolutely a playable stallion. He seems to bottom out at 113 for both credits and bps. I am certain that at this time last year he bottomed much lower. Spectator was the first graded stakes winner for her sire when she won the G2 Sorrento last year as a two year old. Another member of his first foal crop, Kanthaka won the G2 San Vicente earlier this year and was recently third in the San Felipe behind Bolt D’oro and McKinzie. He also has a G3 winning offspring in Puerto Rico.
His first crop consisted of only 80 named foals but of those 43 made it to the races as two year olds and a full twenty won at least one race. That was good enough to rank him #6 on the first crop sires list. The five sires ranked higher than him all had more than 100 named foals but of those only Animal Kingdom (ranked #5) had a graded stakes winning two year old last year. Notably Jimmy Creed retired to stud with an announced fee of $12,500 which dropped to $5,000 at the low end but has rebounded to $15,000.
Jimmy Creed is a son of super sire Distorted Humor out of the G1 winning mare Hookedonthefeelin. He is one of two grade one winning offspring for the mare, the other is the Real Quiet mare Pussycat Doll who has gone on to be a stakes producer. Interestingly Hookedonthefeelin’s full sister Citiview was bred to recent subject stallion Midnight Lute and produced one of his early G1 winners, Midnight Lucky. That breeding was likely done based on the success of Pussycat Doll (Real Quiet was also the sire of Midnight Lucky). Jimmy Creed was purchased for $900,000 as a yearling and retired to his owner’s Spendthrift Farm.
Spendthrift has done well promoting some young sires with what it calls the “Share the Upside” program. Share the Upside offers breeders who support their young stallions in their early years a lifetime breeding right to the sire. One of the first Share the Upside stallions was named Into Mischief. You may have heard of him. A breeder who bred a mare to Into Mischief in his first year and paid the full $12,500 stud fee and also bred a mare to him in his second year at $10,000 fee earned a free lifetime breeding right to the stallion who is booked full in 2018 for a fee of $100,000 (LFSN). Breeders were given a similar offer to Jimmy Creed although in order to get the lifetime breeding breeders had to pay $1,000 higher than the listed stud fee.
Jimmy Creed has not been particularly successful in the game. He’s produced 236 runners, five of which have won stakes races and one of those won in a grade. Young mid-range KY stallions are the hardest to figure value in the game. In my Beginner’s Guide to Breeding I wrote about why breeding to cheap stallions in KY is a losing proposition in the game. Sires that don’t have runners on the ground are always going to be a crapshoot but when they fall into that high-cheap to mid-range price bracket it becomes very difficult to recoup your investment. Even at 113 I’m not really sold on breeding a KY foal by Jimmy Creed this year. Jimmy Creed has two very good things going for him though. He shuttles to Australia and, barring death, will be available to breed next year. Earning back 226 credits/bps with an Australia breeding tag is doable for a halfway decent horse but saving the breeding share for next year is even more enticing. Sometimes long-range planning in the game can produce a lot of value.
Which brings us to our second topic for this week. How much would you pay for a sire from a major breeding location who led his country’s sire list last year by breaking the single season earnings record in that country? What if he currently led his country’s sire list and had already broken his own record for single season earnings? How about a sire who has been in the top 5 sires in his country’s ranking for the past four years and leads the list for the current year? How much would you pay for a sire who IRL has sired 26 G1 winners and almost 150 overall black type winners? Said sire has also led his country’s sire list several times throughout his career.
Those three sires have accounted for 117 graded winners in the game over the years. I purchased all three sires for a total of 1,085 within the past week. That’s an average of 362 bps for three of the top sires in the world. Actual prices were 344, 401 and 340 in order. Had I paid the advertised stud fees for those stallions IRL it would have cost me about $279,000. So what’s up sim players? I know it is fun going deep on unproven young stallions but that is some serious value being left on the table.
I’m not going to spoil the fun. The first one who correctly identifies the three mystery sires gets a new 2yo bred by me.
My first guess is only if you didn’t convert pounds to dollars.
Snitzel (pretty sure of this one)
Acclamation
Pivotal
Well I’m off on the sim graded wins
Snitzel
Candy ride
Pivotal
All works expect sire fee maybe
You are correct. The sire fees were estimated based on conversion to dollars so the total as mentioned was not exact. New 2yo coming your way.
[URL=http://www.derbyfever.com/onehorse_inline.asp?horse=11900019975]http://www.derbyfever.com/onehorse_inline.asp?horse=11900019975[/URL]
[URL]http://www.derbyfever.com/onehorse_inline.asp?horse=11900019975[/URL]
Well can’t seem to link but hopefully he’s a runner for you anyways.
Thank you.
I have seen Pivotal around 300 lately, and he has great DS stats as well. I’m just scared off because I have no luck at all with him. He’s worth another try though
Candy ride I make 3+ a year, he’s my favorite sire IRL. Yet I can’t get them to run.
Snitzel I had no idea was doing that well IRL
Candy Ride in the game seems to get a lot of late developers. In Dec. he had a first time graded stakes winner take down a big G1 at age 5 (he’s 6 now and I think had a layoff after the G1 win and just returned recently). Then in Jan. another 5yo won the sim-Pegasus and I believe that was also his first graded victory of any kind. I am sitting on like 3 4yos by Candy Ride that I think are going to explode this year….or maybe next. My view of him is that his offspring need patience but also at 401 bps (and he is routinely open for credits although not quite that low) you can also sit on him and either breed a late 2yo or see what happens to him next year. He was given an announced boost by Mike several years ago and the comment Mike gave him was something like coming close to elite level. I would not be surprised if he was bumped again either for last year or this. He did have a G1 2yo last year. Sires are constantly being adjusted and based on his RL production there is no doubt that any adjustments he gets are going to be up.
You’re welcome for Candy Ride 🙂
Candy ride I knew had the 4 straight years qualification. I however messed up his sim stakes wins. Your mention did make me look again once I figured out where I went wrong. So thanks
Like the name. I have a 5 yr old war emblem that won.her 1sts listed earlier this year.
Snitzel and Candy Ride are two for sure. Both fall to the 300s BP in the SIM and both add up stud fee wise. It’s not Deep Impact from Japan as he doesn’t fall that low. Iffraaj gets beat by Dubawi in ENG so that takes him out. Has to be a NZ sire then. Savabeel (I believe he leads over Tavistock and Darci Brahma).
Ah, not all led list. OK, I’m taking Darci Brahma then so…
Snitzel
Candy Ride
Darci Brahma
I’d say us SIM breeders are pretty smart on all three of these sires though. Candy Ride is bad in the SIM. I wouldn’t pay 300 for him. He is worth maybe 175. You could buy shares to speculate for next year, but he didn’t get an upgrade this year after Gun Runner (and a lengthy thread about him) so I wouldn’t hold my breath. He simply isn’t worth a 600 BP mare breeding. Snitzel I have given a real shot at and he too is rather average compared to his real life data. He may be worth speculation though since he is an OZ sire and bound to get an upgrade soon. Right now he seems worth his 300ish price point. I don’t have an opinion on Pivotal, I don’t use him because there are so many good turf sires available in the price point that I prefer.
How is Jimmy Creed over 100? That’s really surprising to me. I bred one a couple years ago for 20ish. I guess he had a streak of SIM popularity. I don’t like any sons of Distorted Humor – by and large they are all flops at stud IRL. Like his entire line might rest on Maclean’s Music.
I would guess the reason for Jimmy Creed’s increase from 20 to 113 is probably similar to the reason his actual stud fee went from $5k to $15k.
How Do you know that Candy Ride was not adjusted this year or last year for that matter?
Based on performance and no published upgrade. I would imagine a sire as big as Candy Ride (IRL) would get not get a stealth upgrade it would be a published one. Now I don’t believe he should be an elite sire (he isn’t a six figure stallion) but he should be a very good sire. In 2016 he had 2 SW out of 143 runners which is awful. In 2017, SIM breeders reacting to his general awfulness only bred him 100 times. He got 5 SW from that crop (so far) including 1 GW who is a Derby Trail horse. Not bad right? Sure, but his win % dropped to 51%. So half the Candy Rides bred last year haven’t even won a MSW yet. Again, that is awful. No freaking way am I spending 600+ BPs for a sire who has a 50% chance of not even giving me a Maiden winner by Easter of its 3yo year. My 3yo Candy Ride x Unbridled’s Song is a stellar 0-5 running mid-70s so no chance to win outside of claims.
We of course won’t know how his 2018 class plays out for quite some time yet. In very early returns Gun Runner at 3/9 is already better than Candy Ride at 2/16. Twirling Candy is 1/9, Mastery 1/7, Unified 0/5, and Sidney’s Candy 0/5. So Candy Ride and all his major sons (aside from Gun Runner who I do believe got a favorable SIM ranking, maybe a B?) are 4/42 so far in 2018. That is terrible and is a red flag buyers beware – or at least don’t expect to win right now.
Twirling candy has been a really good sire in real life.
In the sim I use him more than I should maybe, but I do have his only two stakes winners (both 2 listed wins) in the last 4 years. Have a few other solid horses by him. There are some other really solid ones that are close to stakes wins.
I have zero luck with candy ride nor twirling candy x unbridled’s song. Tired it several times, not going back. Wonder if it’s the 2x fap that is hurting the breeding. No idea.
Twirling candy has been a really good sire in real life.
In the sim I use him more than I should maybe, but I do have his only two stakes winners (both 2 listed wins) in the last 4 years. Have a few other solid horses by him. There are some other really solid ones that are close to stakes wins.
I have zero luck with candy ride nor twirling candy x unbridled’s song. Tired it several times, not going back. Wonder if it’s the 2x fap that is hurting the breeding. No idea.