Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

G1 Winter Cup Preview

The Field

#1 Indeed Baaeed (Universal Racing Club) 20/1 : Only reason this one is the second longest shot on the board is because he is facing older for the first time. He dominated his competition in the last two with wins in the G3 Prix De Loot and a 7 length victory in the G1 Japanese Saint Legend. Will cut back a couple of furlongs for this and likes to come from way back, so hopefully won’t hinder his chances. Will need to improve the speed figure and always a battle facing older, but don’t think his chances are as long as his odds.

#2 Carja’s Bane (GR Simsters) 15/1 : Rewind to the summer and he had just won 3 straight graded stakes including the G1 Derby de English and G1 French Grand Prix. Has faced older in 2 of this last 3 since then, and though the results aren’t as glamorous they aren’t necessarily disappointing either. Comes off a 4th in the G1 Japan Classic. The problem is he hasn’t liked to pass horses lately and hasn’t found it as easy to be on or near the pace early. Will have to get out of the gate fast and be on the front end or I worry he will be the one getting passed late. 

#3 You Have No Choice (GR Simsters) 6/1 : One of the 3 co-favourites in here, and the elder of the field. Has faced G1 company in 15 of his last 16 starts, so class wise he is used to this type of company. Won the G1 King Geoff and Queen Beth’s Emerald Stakes 3 back and has been on the podium in his last 4 races. The 13 furlongs will be the longest he has gone in his 25th start, but I don’t think the added furlong will hurt him at all. In fact, it could help give some extra room as he likes to kick late. Not sure he will win, but I feel he won’t be far off.

#4 Star Joy (Empire State Racing) 8/1 : Made the jump into G1 company after being patient through the allowance ranks and shows he definitely belongs with these. A string of 2nd place finishes (G1 GP Von Baden, G1 Jockey’s Weapon and G1 Japan Classic) only leaves us wondering when he will get over that hump. His defeats have come against top competitors like  #1 ranked Parrish Hall and #4 ranked Franks Star Forty, so he has been keeping good company. Another one where we will see if the extra furlong helps as he really comes charging late. A real contender in this group now.

#5 Path of Time (All-Stars Racing) 19/1 : 3 year old who has been ridiculously consistent throughout his career with all 11 starts ending up on the podium. It isn’t like he has been facing nobodies either, as he has faced graded company in his last 5. That included a victory in the G1 Owner’s Stakes, and perhaps even more impressive was his second-place finish in the G1 Breeders’ Bowl Turf, where he was as a 34-1 shot in a competitive field of 14. Needless to say the odds are much too high on this one and with another strong showing can introduce himself as a top threat in the division.

#6 Megaforma (Empire State Racing) 10/1 : Seemed to have peaked in the summer with the second in the G1 Tattersalls Gold and win in the G1 Man of War Stakes. The last 3 have been disappointing with runs that didn’t put him in contention at all. The 12th last out in the G1 Breeders’ Bowl Turf is concerning as some in here finished much higher than him there. Seems to be trending the wrong way as others are trending up. Will be the 22nd start of his career, so I have to wonder if these are just too much of a challenge at this point. Like others better.

#7 Tallion (Empire State Racing) 14/1 : Since he was gelded last summer, has only missed the podium once in 11 starts. Now, he was patiently handled and worked his way through the allowance ranks, but has faced graded company in his last two. Came second in the G3 Sick No More and took down the G1 Euro Marathon Final by 3 ½ lengths. One that really wants to be on the lead, but did show he doesn’t necessarily need to be there in his last. If he learned to sit off the pace a bit early, might just be a threat if he is able to get first run down the stretch.

#8 Street Skills (GR Simsters) 6/1 : One of the 3 co-favourites and the clear #1 ranked in my “Field In Numbers”. Now, I’d like him a bit better if this race was run in the summer off his 3 victories in a row, which included the G1 Grand Brazilian. However, the two recent “lackluster” performances were the G1 $6 million Ark De ComicDog and the G1 Breeders’ Bowl Turf. Not sure you can race against tougher and he got back to feeling good with the G1 LA Turf Cup second last out. Have to think the class relief works in his favour and I’d be surprised if he wasn’t in the mix late.

#9 Vapeur (MIDAS) 11/1 : The only filly in the field, but did face the boys the last time out in the G1 Millwood Cup. That was a 4th place finish going much longer, and will shorten up by 3 furlongs here. Her resume against the girls is stellar, with wins in the G1 Equinics – The Fifinella and G2 Brake Hill Stakes earlier this season. Does like to come from off the pace as many do here, so have to worry if she will get the jump on them as she really doesn’t go this short. Like the addition as it adds to the field, and doesn’t seem out of place with all these.

#10 Wave of Thunder (Down Under Racing) 28/1 : The longest shot on the board and it probably makes sense. Facing older for the first time and his resume against 3 year olds while solid, isn’t spectacular. Actually started his career in a 60K claimer, so can’t knock the training job since that point. Has had a string of 2nd place finishes in the G1 Irish Derby, G1 Owner’s Stakes and G1 Vicky Derby, so quality is there. He will need to improve his speed figure, but faces better here, and older, so find that always isn’t a recipe for success. Prefer others to win.

#11 Star Radius (GR Simsters) 7/1 : Hasn’t been running as far as others here, but is an interesting addition to the field. Comes off back-to-back wins in the Red Polish Turf Route and G1 Singapore Cup. Will go a couple furlongs longer than he has ever gone in his career, but looking at that pedigree it shouldn’t really bother him. I’d scratch away that run in the G1 Judgemont as he clearly didn’t take to the off-turf. Winner of 50% of his races and one that I think fits in well with the field here. Think his odds are fair and wouldn’t surprise me if he makes it to the podium.

#12 Combined Effort (Only Stayers) 6/1 : The last of the 3 co-favourites in the field. Unfortunately, hasn’t won since taking down the G1 Ark De ComicDog back in October 2023. Must like that race as that has been his best showing recently with a 2nd place finish. Has raced in some big races since that time, so fits right at home against these. Trouble is the results just haven’t been there. I feel he is a fringe performer in this group with an outside chance to get onto the podium. Highest T/L rank in the field.

#13 Kymarg Bilagi (Down Under Racing) 10/1 : Definitely didn’t take to the 16 furlong races he has run in the last year, losing by a combined 32 ½ lengths in them. If you cross those off, his resume isn’t that terrible. Would be 6 straight podium finishes, including seconds in both the G1 King Geoff and Queen Beth’s Emerald Stakes and G1 Expensive Jalopy. That puts him in the mix here, but we do need to go back to March to get a win. That is something he has never done against graded company.

#14 All In A Dream (Empire State Racing) 10/1 : The two before the 9 furlong allowance win saw this one lose by a combined 31 ½ lengths. Might be tough to get behind in this field as it isn’t like he has always been bad at that 16 furlong distance. We go back all the way to December of last year before we see another win. Think he might be trending in the wrong direction and with start 26 against this company, he just might be out of his element at this point in his career. 

Field In Numbers

HorseSpeed – L3CPU ValueT/L RankTotal Points
Street Skills112.91362737
Star Radius112.513411532
Star Joy114.713302631
Path of Time111.41217130
Vapeur111.81244629
Combined Effort112.913316026
You Have No Choice110.612791622
Carja’s Bane108.61169220
Indeed Baaed110.71175720
Tallion111.912093618
Wave of Thunder107.71097515
Kymarg Bilagi111.212073315
Megaforma108.512153214
All In A Dream103.81145278

One thought on “G1 Winter Cup Preview”

Leave a Reply