Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Bluegrass Derby Viability of 20-30K Sires

One of the breeding sweet spots in real life is stallions priced $20,000 – $30,000. Within this zone, the breeder will often find good value, either new stallions priced to fill books, or traditional stallions that will produce good runners but might not always get the flashy sales numbers. Currently, in America, there are 27 stallions within this price point. I’ve taken a look at them in the SIM to see if they are viable choices in getting a horse to the Bluegrass Derby. I’m only looking at American stallions as these are what people will be primarily breeding to get a dirt horse. Further, I’ve only looked at progeny from 2023 and 2022 since the goal is to get on the Derby trail, for our purposes here we don’t care what their older offspring do. We are trying to see if we can get a horse that can run on the Derby trail from this group.

StallionFee22 Win %23 Win %SWGWOffspring
Audible25,00070.325.262160
Blame25,00049.529.410142
Connect25,00079.230.321172
Corniche30,000N/A22.00041
Cyberknife30,000N/A25.40059
Daredevil20,00064.125.921132
Early Voting25,000N/A28.60056
Game Winner30,00070.940.320151
Girvin25,00074.134.510116
Golden Pal30,000N/A33.91062
Improbable25,00064.529.220158
Kantharos20,00073.228.621113
Mandaloun25,000N/A23.91046
McKinzie30,00072.524.642163
Mendelssohn25,00064.740.020162
Midshipman20,00063.820.02092
Mo Donegal20,000N/A32.70055
Omaha Beach30,00070.135.572203
Oscar Performance20,00053.528.900109
Practical Joke25,00076.936.190195
Silver State20,00070.132.132120
Speaker’s Corner20,000N/A22.20027
Tiz the Law30,00064.724.620163
Union Rags30,00069.125.032173
Upstart30,00066.733.900101
War of Will25,00065.729.121154
Yaupon30,00070.140.000127
SIM Stallion Stats 2022-23

Offspring is total horses 2yos and 3yos. SW and GW are the number of horses, in some cases, a horse may have won multiple graded races. New stallions do not have a 2022 ranking.

Graded Runners

I’ll now take a look at the graded runners from each of the stallions in our group. Audible has two, Abortive who won the G2 Princess Cup 10f dirt in July, and Vocal Two Sky winner of the G1 Clerk of Scales who made it to the Travers. Neither made it to the Derby trail but an argument can made they had the talent to do so. Connect has Perolon El Grande who won the G1 Florida Derby making it to the Bluegrass. Daredevil has So Daring a G2 The Girl Upfront winner, a filly sprint. Kantharos has Fat Faced Rick a 2yo winner of the G3 Baby Tree so it’s unclear how far this horse will go in the future. McKinzie had two fillies the sprinter Bitcoin Girl who won the G2 Stoker Handicap and Littlemarysunshine winner of the G3 Meadow Oaks at 8.5f. Omaha Beach has the G1 New Yorker winner Beach Toy, who also won the G3 9f Chief Snow, and Lorne Copper a filly sprinter that won the G3 Sorgento sprint. Silver State has Scared State who won the G3 Cornstalk and then technically made it on the Derby trail although ran very distant in preps and the sprinter State of Chrome winner of the G2 Everything’s Legal. Union Rags produced two sprinters the filly Rags and Emperors winner of the G2 Golden Red and Vindictive Union who won the G1 Dell Computer and the G2 Saint Vincent. Finally, War of Will has Metallnut’s War who won G2 Closest Friend as 2yo and won the URC Residency Risen Star, Haskell, and Belmont.

Analysis

Our group of 27 stallions produced 14 graded winners out of 3,252 horses. That’s a rate of .0043%. A total of 54 open stakes wins were captured for a rate of 1.66%. These are rather dismal numbers, although a classic winner did emerge from here with Beach Toy and one horse made it into the starting gate of the Bluegrass in Perolon El Grande. All total, we can say giving the Audibles the benefit of the doubt, and including others on the periphery of the Derby trail if a different training path were taken and in Littlemarysunshine’s case she was a he, we have 7 derby trail runners. Out of 3,252 breedings. And mind you, these stallions aren’t exactly cheap. Most of these you are going to pay 200-500 for a share.

Some stallions here we can completely cross off if we are trying to get on the Derby trail, Blame for instance. He just doesn’t throw precocious horses with a sub-50 % 3yo win rate. Oscar Performance is a turf horse who doesn’t throw early runners either and Midshipman has a 20% 2yo win rate, very tough to get on the Derby trail that way.

More promising are Connect and Practical Joke both over 75% 3yo winners with McKinzie pushing his way there. Audible, Practical Joke, and Omaha Beach all had over 5 open stakes winners. Look at the stats of Daredevil, Tiz the Law, Improbable, and War of Will; they all look to have about the same SIM rating. Omaha Beach has the most runners at 203 and Speaker’s Corner the least with 27. As a first-year sire with a $20,000 fee SIM breeders have all but ignored Speaker’s Corner perhaps believing he doesn’t have much of a rating. His 22.2% 2yo win rate either confirms this or has become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Where is the value here? Well, as we have seen, the odds of getting a horse onto the Derby trail from this group are extremely small. Practical Joke is probably on the upside and even though he didn’t get a graded winner his 9 SW leads one to believe that he could. Both Connect and Omaha Beach can get a big horse. McKinzie and Silver State are worth watching, they clearly have talent. It looks like the Connect, Omaha Beach, McKinzie, and Silver State group are all better rated than the Daredevil, Tiz the Law, Improbable, and War of Will group. Yaupon has good winning numbers hitting 70/40 but where are the stakes winners? He and Game Winner are similar.

From the freshman sires, you probably aren’t happy (or going to be) with Corniche, Cyberknife, and Early Voting. They all likely have the same rating. Golden Pal and Mo Donegal look to be a cut above. Mandaloun is unclear. Speaker isn’t getting a chance.

Conclusion

Using horses in the $20,000-$30,000 range isn’t going to get you on the Derby trail very often. It is possible, and as we have seen, you can get a classic winner, but the odds are long. Getting on the Derby trail from this class was a 20% of 1% proposition, and I know for one that when breeding a dirt horse I at least want the illusion I can get on it and run 4th in the Fountain of Ute. There are some horses worth using here provided you can get them at the right price. A 400 credit or BP breeding to a broodmare band mare for 800 investment isn’t a smart use of resources here. If you can cut that in half then maybe you’re working with something. Horses like Yaupon, Game Winner and likely Golden Pal and Mo Donegal at the start of next year will be even cheaper.

7 thoughts on “Bluegrass Derby Viability of 20-30K Sires”

  • kashbarn

    Well done! Thanks for the insight. I’ve used some of these in the past year, still waiting for a stake winner to surface.

  • kyogle

    Thanks Todd – A very interesting read.

    It inspired me to take a look at recent Bluegrass Derbies from the other direction, and look at what sires have had an impact.

    I’ve gone back over the last 3 Derbies, 60 runners, and without considering results in the big one, done a bit of analysis on the sires of those 60 horses (which all needed a lot of talent to make the fields)

    In total, there have been 41 different sires make it to the start through the most recent 3 runnings of the Bluegrass Debry

    More than 2 runners: Tapit (6), Medaglia D’Oro (4), Justify (3), Quality Road (3), Distorted Humor (3).

    2 runners each: American Pharoah, Ghostzapper, Curlin.

    One starter: Soldier Hollow, Mineshaft, Practical Joke, Gun Runner, Maxfield, Connect, Global Campaign, Yaupon, American Guru, Top Hit, Gunnevera, Creator, Nyquist, Broken Vow, Fastnet Rock, Into Mischief, Atreides, Big Brown, Hard Aces, Exaggerator, Empire Maker, Bernardini, More than Ready, Good Magic, Bricks and Mortar, Street Sense, Golden Horn, Flatter, California Chrome, Arrogate, Royal Mo, Midnight Storm.

    My musings:

    Tapit is no surprise, but it doesn’t answer the ‘catch 22’ question. Is Tapit the best because he’s overused, or is he overused because he’s the best?

    What to make of the three sires (5%) who are clearly more inclined to turf? Should we be experimenting on dirt with more of the likes of Soldier Hollow, Fastnet Rock and Golden Horn?

    Into Mischief and Gun Runner have been underwhelming.

    Bargain sires aren’t out of the mix. 9 sires (15%) are in the range which sees them at half price in December. 4 (6%) are under 100 points at full price. The bargains, with their prices as I was writing this are – Yaupon (152), Top Hit (118), Creator (155), Broken Vow (148), Midnight Storm, (140), American Guru (56), Atreides (65), Hard Aces (70) and Royal Mo (58)

    Don’t know whether this is of any use to anyone, but it was an interesting exercise from my end, and thanks again Todd, for the inspiration

    • waremblem5Post author

      Thanks for your thoughts! You can be sure I grabbed a 60 credit share of Yaupon when I was researching the article. I honestly think that dirt breeders didn’t know what to do when so many established dirt stallions died. Think about it, none of the Storm Cats turned into anything on the dirt as stallions, as a sire line it’s a turf line now. A.P. Indy sons? Mostly through Tapit. So, since there were so few stallions (Curlin, MdO and… Into Mischief?) people felt were “worth” 1000+ they just went to Tapit. Scarcity of top dirt sires drove up prices on horses like Ghostzapper and Justify and if you are going to spend 800 for Ghostzapper, why not just spend 1000 for Tapit? Now that Tapit has been given a 25% “BP tax”, that equation isn’t quite as certain. Now, if you’re looking at having to spend 1200 for Tapit, a horse for 700 might be more, if not attractive, then at least palatable.

      Flashy expensive young stallions like American Pharaoh and Justify are always a risk. Part of the breeding to Tapit is, well if the horse sucks, at least I might end up with a Tapit broodmare. And Tapit broodmares are going to be good for 15 years. It’s arguably a solid investment in your stables despite the cost. We have no idea if Pharaoh and Justify are good investments, and with the Pharaoh nerf it turns out he wasn’t a good investment as none of those American Pharaoh mares look all that great going forward. Justify will probably get nerfed as well putting him in the same boat.

      Of course, all that is down the road and not a huge concern if we are just trying to get a horse adjacent to the Derby trail. Sometimes, it could be a lot of fate, right? Losing a maiden by a nose vs winning it in your first start might be a huge difference in a horse’s career. Certainly in terms of making it to the Derby trail. For most breeders, you were only getting a handful of Tapit, Medaglia D’Oro, Justify, Quality Road Distorted Humor, American Pharoah, Ghostzapper, and Curlin each year so the goal always has sort of been trying to find that stallion from the one each group. Flightline has joined the elite group with 3 graded winners already and his price is already soaring so if you want a 1000 Flightline you probably better get him now. Incidently he already has 288 runners. Part of that I put on the published sire upgrades though. You can’t come out and say Flightline is super duper elite amazing and everything he touches turns to gold. Why does that even need to be said? It simply drives up the demand to unrealstic levels.

      One of the things I discovered while researching this article is that players are trying to make stallions featured in this group work. But we don’t have that true situation in real life where young stallions have massive books. No one here has over 62 covers. Even if we broaden it, there is Flightline with his soon to be 300+ and Life is Good likely will top 100 but no one else is getting there. Why are freshman sires relatively unpopular in the SIM? Are they priced too high?

Leave a Reply