2023 Offical Sire Upgrades/Downgrades
Every year the 6,000+ sires in the game get a look by Mike. How does their rating stack up against their real life results? Perhaps all do not get adjusted but most of them get tinkered with. In years past major movers and shakers have been tipped on the message board. By popular demand these are the notable movements for 2023. The commentary is all my own opinion.
Increases:
CURLIN
Always rated highly, the two time American Horse of the Year has proven to be a powerhouse sire. In 2021 and 2022 he sired more grade one winners than any other stallion in North America. His 2022 highlights are just staggering – he sired three champions – Malathaat, Nest and Elite Power. But consider this – minus Malathaat in the division another daughter Clariere would have been crowned and minus Elite Power another son, Cody’s Wish would likely have won. He is easily in the top five sires of dirt runners in the world and his success earned him a bump.
MUNNINGS
Munnings has always been a sneaky good sire. In 2022 he sired 15 stakes winners (2nd only to Into Mischief among North American sires). His best son was the three year old Jack Christopher who won two grade ones in addition to a grade one taken as a two year old. Overall Munnings has sired five grade one winners compared to just one in game. His stud fee increased to $100,000 for 2023 and it was past time for him to get a boost.
NOT THIS TIME
Another sire who has produced more grade one winners in real life than in the game is Not This Time. Easily his best runner to date is 2022 Champion Three Year Old Epicenter. But that Travers winner is just one of three grade one winners that Not This Time had produced in his first three crops at the end of 2022. Just this year alone he’s added two more to that list. He entered stud with modest expectations but for 2023 his stud fee shot up to $135,000. It’s worth noting that the mares he’s bred in recent years have been light years better than the ones who produced his early crops – in other words the best is yet to come.
ART COLLECTOR
This one is a bit strange. His upgrade came after his impressive win in February’s Pegasus. But off of that impressive score his connections elected to keep him in training for 2023. There is precedent for horses to be available in game prior to actually breeding mares in real life and of course sires who prove to be infertile will sire two year olds before failing in real life. It’s hard to say where Art Collector was initially rated so any upgrade may not have been on a strong initial rating.
WRITTEN TYCOON
Written Tycoon’s ascension to the top level of sires is well earned. The winner of only two races from eleven starts, including a grade two, he retired to stud for an advertised fee of AU $13,750. After early and sustained success that fee would rise to a high of AU $165,000 although this season he is advertised for a private fee. He was the leading sire in Australia for the 2020/2021 season and he is consistently in the top ten. He’s sired a dozen grade one winners in his career but only four in the game so this upgrade is long past due.
CAPITALIST
Perhaps the best son of Written Tycoon is Capitalist. He was named Australia’s Champion Two Year off of wins in two group ones topped by that country’s premier race for two year olds the Golden Slipper (G1). His oldest foals are only four years old but already he has a group one winner to his credit as well as a bevvy of other group and listed stakes winners. He’s been at the top of his crop class as both a freshman and sophomore sire and currently stands for a fee of AU $77,000. In the game he has sired one grade one winner but only five stakes winners overall. A bump here will likely put him in the good category out of what has previously been mediocrity.
RUSSIAN REVOLUTION
Russian Revolution is advertised as Snitzel’s fastest son at stud. While there are a few others who might argue for that claim he certainly was a very strong racehorse winning seven of eleven starts including two group ones. He’s been even better at stud as he lead the freshman sire standings in 2021/2022 and the sophomore sire standings in 2022/2023. His progeny include four group winners including one at the group one level. His current fee of AU$88,000 certainly puts him on the radar for better stallion candidates. That is a far cry from his in game record of just four listed winners so far.
EXTREME CHOICE
Extreme Choice was the highest rated Timeform two year old by perennial leading sire Redoute’s Choice who can certainly be called a sire of sires with Snitzel and Not A Single Doubt among his many sons at stud. Extreme Choice is a younger son but based on his early success he certainly puts himself in contention for the best sire son of Redoute’s Choice. Extreme Choice was the leading freshman sire of 2020/2021, a year in which his son Stay Inside won the Golden Slipper and was named Champion Two Year Old. He also has two additional group one winners and his stud fee for 2023 is AU $275,000, second highest in Oz behind only I Am Invincible.
NO NAY NEVER
In contrast to some of the other stallions on this list No Nay Never has been among the top sim sires for the last four years. The group one winning two year old by Scat Daddy has been very popular and quite expensive during that time but in 2022 his real life progeny moved from strength to strength. Among the best was European Champion Two Year Old Blackbeard as well as Breeders’ Bowl Juvenile Filly Turf winner Meditate and four time group one winner Alcohol Free. His stud fee increased to 175,000 Euros and for good reason. It is safe to assume that this stallion can be considered top to elite level.
Decreases:
AMERICAN PHAROAH
The only stallion previously mentioned as having been decreased is American Pharoah. The first Triple Crown winner in 37 years entered stud with high hopes and was one of Mike’s top freshman sires ever introduced when he began his career in 2016. Indeed his foals were so highly regarded that in 2017 Mike made this announcement:
Could only rate him so high with no history. The industry seems to love him and his mare book is off the charts. If he busts it’ll be a shocker of Alysheba proportions. Still can’t put him in the “uber elite” status yet, but he can’t be ignored.
So he hasn’t been a bust of Alysheba proportions but he ‘only’ produced six grade/group one winners from his first four crops. Considering the expectations and the mentioned quality of mares he received he has been a disappointment. For 2023 his stud fee dropped to its lowest level ever of $60,000
JUSTIFY
The other Triple Crown winner of this century, Justify’s first crop of foals are only three years old. I’m somewhat surprised by this announcement as Justify’s two year olds of 2022 were not a bad group. Three of his babies earned graded wins which isn’t bad considering Justify himself did not race as a two year old. Indeed already in 2023 a member of that crop has won a grade one. From his first Australian crop he has produced two group winning two year olds in 2023 and a Northern Hemisphere two year old has also won a group three. Yes Justify was highly rated as an incoming sire but do his early results ‘justify’ a drop?
SEA THE STARS
If I disagree with Mike’s downgrade of Justify I really don’t understand the logic in dropping Sea The Stars. He has been a top three stallion in Europe for the past five seasons with only Galileo, Dubawi and Frankel ever rated above him. To top that off in 2022 his best ever son Baaeed was rated at 138 from Timeform, among the best in the modern thoroughbred era. Sea the Stars was obviously an elite rated sire in the game and apparently Mike thought he was a little two good. I haven’t seen the numbers so I can’t say he’s wrong but I will anyways – Mike you’re wrong!
Great coverage Spin! And surprising to find out that even Mike could be wrong once in a while.
Great job on the write up Spin! I should have clarified about Justify & STS before giving the list. Those were more recalibrations then anything else. Not really anything significant about either one of them changed ratings wise.
Beautifully written Spin. So informative and entertaining.
SJ
Beautiful informative piece.
Great work spin unfortunately a couple there I have been hitting cheap for next years breeding looks like the bubble on my heist has burst lol
Thanks muchly Spin — very interesting info & commentary.
Thanks Spin
Oh for a return to Capitalist for 10 points
Spin is the best!
Any thoughts on Japanese stallions? I know typically we expect them to be rated lower than their stud fee equivalents in other countries, but surely there is someone who deserves attention or had a bump?
The SAF Sires are still being overlooked…GIMMETHEGREENLIGHT, DANON PLATINA, VERCINGETORIX AND WHAT A WINTER and PATHFORK making a killing over here and needs SERIOUS upgrades. TRIPPI needs downgrade and SAF sires ARE TURF SIRES NOT DIRT SIRES…
KZN Yearling sales 29 June 2023: 1. Vercingetorix average R434 000 [8 lots]. 2. Gimmethegreenlight R402 500 [6 lots] 3. Danon Platina R302 000 [9 lots]
Bloodstock SA Yearling Sales 21 April: 1. Vercingetorix average R854 000 [35 lots] 2. Gimmethegreenlight R746 000 [28 lots] 3. Danon Platina R479 000 [21 lots] 4. Lancaster Bomber R464 000 [23 lots] 5. What A Winter R441 000 [22 lots]
MOST UNDERRATED STALLION NOW WITH FRESHMAN SIRE AT STUD: ELUSIVE FORT – HE NOW STANDS KOMMETDIEDING – 3 LOTS SOLD AT AVRAGE OF R1.2 MILLION!!! NO STAKE WINNERS IN SIM…FARCE!
Good write up Spin, thanks for your efforts!
Always remember, not all the goods are given out, as far as who’s been upped or downed.
That’s true, but Mike did say “Not much in Downgrades this year..” ….and… “Downgrades – All in all, not a lot to report here. The only notable one is American Pharoah”
No mention of Justify or STS. If any downgraded adjustments were made of either, I would think it would be notable.
I’m curious about what ‘recalibrations’ means? Distance preferences?
You would think with STS it would be to increase his AWD in the game. They never seem to stay as well as they should and more importantly slow down maturity of his offspring (potentially increase longevity if trained correct).
Justify is harder to fathom especially as his first crop were only 2yo’s. It is hard to adjust anything from there. The only thing that comes to mind is he has someone who gives him news from the Keeneland sales, the 20+ stallion pedigree yearlings Coolmore dumped and that did not sell well maybe had an influence. This could have changed his surface preference dynamics.