I think the game is extensive as far as horse racing Sims are concerned but I believe for your average gamer or average fan or person familiar with horse racing it’s digestible if you are willing to put in time and effort
I do believe if the intention is to make the qualifying system “better” and perhaps more realistic then,yes, there needs to be an overhaul and adaptation of a points system more similar to the one used in real life. I believe 2 year old races in the game are too heavily weighted relative to what the current system is in real life. I also believe player purchased races, especially grade ones, naturally dilute the Derby trail and the traditional preps and also make it more difficult to navigate a path to race. I know this is a money making enterprise and some player sponsored races have become part of the fabric of the game but if it were up to me I would discount them as points races on the Derby trail.
Lastly The Cranberries and the song Dreams kind of encapsulates the 90’s for me as a child with them playing often from my sister’s boombox
I just had some of these conversations so these questions hit the nail on the head for me. Thanks
The game is not really hard, but you need to put some time and $$$ to get it done. A little luck help, just like in real life, you have a $100.00 horses that are worthless and you come out with a $20 or less horses and they become champions. I’ve being lucky to have few good 2 yo horses and they become crap when they are 3 yo, I believe that need to change a bit and make more close to real life. Beside that no changes…. Thank you
The Derby qualifying system is also contentious / controversial in ‘real life’, so it would be foolish to think that the game is somehow lacking & just needs to adopt an existing, perfect system. There’s also the fact that the landscape of the game (in regards to how players attempt to achieve this elusive ‘success’) is always evolving… I think of the tweaks we are proposing as adjustments to hit a constantly moving target. And for me, that’s part of the fun of the game, in that it ain’t gonna be mastered any time soon.
Just because the real life system is not perfect does not mean it is not better than what we have in game. It is a constantly moving target which is why changes should be made
Thanks for the thoughts! It’s been awhile since I’ve had a legit contender, but wasn’t it something like user-bought Graded/Group races are only worth 1/2 the points? That’s a built-in deterrent, but of course if you made them worth zero points, there’d be little incentive to buy them.
Question 1 – really depends on your definition of success and failure. The game gets easier the more time you spend within it and certainly gets easier the more you spend.
Question 2 – the game needs two teaks on our current rating system. First, based on the fact that horse abilities seemingly rise and fall from race to race in today’s game, basing any rating system on the last 12 months doesn’t work anymore. I would love to see the rankings system tweaked a bit, where a greater emphasis is put on more recent starts. Use a quarterly system where the most recent quarter (or third if you prefer, 3-4 months) results are worth more points than the previous 3 quarters or 2 thirds. It would reward horses who are in form but not totally penalize results from the past 3-12 months. Per the Derby, and other races in general, the game needs a mile category. Create an 8/8.5F category and call it good. Why should a horse have the same points count towards the BB Classic and the BB Dirt Mile? Seems foolish to me. Make these two changes and you’ll have the Derby field full of routers who are hitting their form at the right time. If there is a race or two that are important (like, say the BB Juvenile at 8.5F on dirt) then count it as a lock race and we’re good.
Question 3 – the older I get the more I like Cranberries that I can eat.
Interesting takes. Quarterly certainly would weed out the untenable 2yo superstars come 3yo duds problem, but could still be manipulated by the player-bought stakes. Mike (he who needs no introduction) has always done a good job, in my mind, of reacting but not overreacting with tweaks to the gameplay, so I would not get behind a solution that makes the system more complex (and I doubt he would implement it.)
The Mile points category, on the other hand, makes a lot of sense to me. As we all (should) know, there is a massive difference in performance / horse distance preference +/- as little as 100m sometimes ( 1/16 mile). It could be tricky applying to spring 3yo on dirt, since most Derby preps are in that 8.5.f-9f range, for a race run at 10f.
Any thoughts on Lenny’s ‘short route’ class suggestion?
Question1: No the game is not too hard in theory. But with more and more horses in the sim and some players having multiple accounts and literally 1000 horses combined or more which differs from years ago it has now brought light to so things that could be tweaked in the game or addressed.
Question 2: I agree with Lenny271 on this one and a while back I believe it was he that posted similar in the forums regarding the rating system. I do lots of BTB articles each year on mainly Graded races. I look at some of the races I preview and many times I have had to shake my head as to how is it possible that this horse qualified for the graded race while knocking out what I would definitely consider much better horses based on their racing schedules and most recent performances. When I see a horse that has won a bunch of allowance races and maybe placed in one Listed Stakes and most all were soft and/or short fields and have not won or placed in a recent start over the past several months but are knocking out recent graded winners and placers in recent starts that seems to be a concern to me. This is not just in 2 and 3 year old races but graded races for older horses as well. You ask for examples, this is the best example I feel I can give as I don’t want to call out horses and it is really not possible to go back and look at a race and see what horse knocked out a horse that would be considered better qualified. So I agree with Lenny271 on the points he addressed as I have seen too many times good horses being knocked out of a graded starts by lesser horses that I feel have no business being in the race and have no change at hitting the boards. I don’t have a fix for the problem, but agree we need a reevaluation of the point system and how we can better ensure the best horses are actually qualifying and running in our graded races.
1. I don’t think it is to hard. Would I like to see some changes? Sure, everyone has a few things. Personally I lost count of just how many males I have claimed because in the horse work F/M is fillies and mares and C/H/G is colts and horses and geldings. It still drives me wild because I still screw it up so that is something that for a new player that may be a horse person (which i think most are) you can accidently make a crap claim thinking you are making a great one and then you loose all your buying power for 4-6 months….ask me how I know lol. Otherwise as far as difficulty I don’t think its hard per’se just time consuming. If you want to do well for free you can but you have to claim a lot, run a lot, and get lucky. You have to get lucky, but you also have to spend the time. I do think the hot sires hit a bit too often and the smaller sires not quite enough, that definitely favors players who spend more $$$$.
2. I don’t pay as much attention to the derby as others. I do think it should be tailored more towards jan-april races than 2yo form. I also would like to see the points system for stakes be tweaked a bit maybe? I honestly am not familiar enough with it to know how it could be done. I have noticed if you a nice 3yo (colt or filly) and you frequently can’t get them in a graded race early half. It seems those races are flooded with horses that ran in privately bought stakes or ran in stakes with maybe shorter fields where then handfuls of horses were put in to see what sticks. I don’t blame the individuals that take advantage of this system as much as the system but it is frustrating when you think you have that one good horse and continuously get bumped from the races you need. Again, I don’t know enough about the system to suggest how this could be corrected.
3. Cranberries are fantastic to eat, fantastic to drink, and fantastic as a supplement…they might be alright listening too, but I think I only know one song, before my time.
I think you make a good point about gearing towards Jan-Apr. In a sense, eliminating the 2yo races from the Derby points doesn’t necessarily mean they are at a disadvantage, if those stakes points accumulated at 2 help those horses GET INTO the Derby-qualifying races at 3.
This would require a new category by itself, something like Derby Stakes Points… along the lines of Lenny’s “route” points, it would be just for 3yos, earned only at 3, at a narrow range of distances (8f to 10f).
1. The game has progressed to a state where I don’t have much fun with it. Liked it a lot more years ago. Too many horses now and races haven’t been added to compensate. Speed numbers are way too high. The game is way too much pay to win.
2. Just use the real Derby points system. I don’t know why this hasn’t been done ages ago (other than there have been zero game changes in years so draw your own conclusions about maintenance mode). That said, it doesn’t affect me so I don’t view it as a primary concern. Dirt racing is awful in the SIM. Dirt stallions are dramatically under rated compared to turf stallions and dirt races, because there is a glut of horses and no new races have been added are always packed so your horse spends its entire career facing 14-horse fields.
3. Dolores’s voice in Linger will break even the hardest hearts at 2 am on a Saturday night. The band’s music has aged extremely well. I have them as the 4th greatest band of the 90s behind Nirvana, Hole, and Smashing Pumpkins. This is based on how often I still listen to them, so while PJ is a seminal band, I never feel like throwing Jeremy on.
Sorry to hear the fun element is waning. It is cyclical for me, and others I’ve spoken with, and the solution has always been some strategic navel gazing, retooling, and trying new approaches to keep it fresh. I am in the midst of a reboot right now, and plan on writing a BTB article about it as well. My mares are old and my choice of sires is no longer competitive, so that’s one place to start.
No arguments on Dolores (RIP) but I’ve got several others ahead of the Pumpkins (Soundgarden, Stone Temple Pilots, the Pixies if we are generous with the timing.)
Also weren’t Hole’s songs allegedly written by the Smashing Pumpkin’s frontman? You could be accused of double-dipping 🙂
1) Game is the right level of complicated, based on just enough real world with the perfect pinch of RNG to keep things interesting.
2) The current Derby system is pretty dang solid, The Derby is easily the most coveted prize and insanely hard to win. Keep it how it is… the rules are clear, the challenge is difficult and the randomness in winners is fantastic
3) Band… although both are less than enjoyable ingesting in any sizable quantity
I happen to know you’re a pretty rational dude so your statements carry weight with me, for sure. I can agree with the ‘coveted and insanely hard’, and it damn well should be. I don’t want to make it easier to win by any means, and randomness has to be a factor… but I suppose the perception of what is ‘fair’ to the trainers might be more subjective than I imagined.
#3 brings up an either/or scenario… Would you rather eat a bag of raw cranberries, or listen to the Cranberries for 16 hours straight?
1 The game is not to hard. The reality is people have to high expectations. The chances of doing well in the sim far outweigh real life. The game is not like playing alone on easy settings on a stand alone PC or gaming console. It is meant to be hard and a challenge, set realistic goals on a global or even individual horse basis.
2 It took Godolphin and before it became a brand over 30 years to win an English Derby. Why should the sim version of a classic be any easier (it probably is). To many people playing easy level alone on their PC/Console. This is the real fake world it is hard enjoy any success you get.
3 I don’t think drink Cranberries alone will solve the burning.
1. The game isn’t that hard. Just make sure to earn a lot of bp’s and use them well and you’ll build up a good stables in time. The hard thing is that it takes time and effort. Of course if you have real money to spend you’ll reach the heights faster.
I think the Derby point system works now, its clear that you need to earn the route stakes points to be able to make the cut. You’re all but guaranteed to make the big race if you can win an ALW (4) + Stakes (16) + Grade 1 (128) or any combination of results adding to that total (148 stakes points).
The key now is to make sure you lock up the ALW and Stakes wins as a 2yo or early in the 3yo season so that if your contenders can rise to the top when the 9F+ grade ones open up. If a horse can’t win a Grade One route, then they probably aren’t ready for the Derby either.
The only change I could see make sense to make sure the cream of the 3yo crop can qualify for the Derby might be to double stakes points from the Derby Locks. That way those who finish top two in the locks would most likely have enough points making 2nd place lock finishes equivalent to other Grade One victories.
I think the game is extensive as far as horse racing Sims are concerned but I believe for your average gamer or average fan or person familiar with horse racing it’s digestible if you are willing to put in time and effort
I do believe if the intention is to make the qualifying system “better” and perhaps more realistic then,yes, there needs to be an overhaul and adaptation of a points system more similar to the one used in real life. I believe 2 year old races in the game are too heavily weighted relative to what the current system is in real life. I also believe player purchased races, especially grade ones, naturally dilute the Derby trail and the traditional preps and also make it more difficult to navigate a path to race. I know this is a money making enterprise and some player sponsored races have become part of the fabric of the game but if it were up to me I would discount them as points races on the Derby trail.
Lastly The Cranberries and the song Dreams kind of encapsulates the 90’s for me as a child with them playing often from my sister’s boombox
I just had some of these conversations so these questions hit the nail on the head for me. Thanks
The game is not really hard, but you need to put some time and $$$ to get it done. A little luck help, just like in real life, you have a $100.00 horses that are worthless and you come out with a $20 or less horses and they become champions. I’ve being lucky to have few good 2 yo horses and they become crap when they are 3 yo, I believe that need to change a bit and make more close to real life. Beside that no changes…. Thank you
The Derby qualifying system is also contentious / controversial in ‘real life’, so it would be foolish to think that the game is somehow lacking & just needs to adopt an existing, perfect system. There’s also the fact that the landscape of the game (in regards to how players attempt to achieve this elusive ‘success’) is always evolving… I think of the tweaks we are proposing as adjustments to hit a constantly moving target. And for me, that’s part of the fun of the game, in that it ain’t gonna be mastered any time soon.
Just because the real life system is not perfect does not mean it is not better than what we have in game. It is a constantly moving target which is why changes should be made
Thanks for the thoughts! It’s been awhile since I’ve had a legit contender, but wasn’t it something like user-bought Graded/Group races are only worth 1/2 the points? That’s a built-in deterrent, but of course if you made them worth zero points, there’d be little incentive to buy them.
Thanks! We (me) here at Burning Questions like to be hitting nails on heads when it comes to timeliness.
I see that your main two concerns are starting to be the consensus among commenters… 2yo races and player-bought races overvalued.
Looking good Donnie!
Question 1 – really depends on your definition of success and failure. The game gets easier the more time you spend within it and certainly gets easier the more you spend.
Question 2 – the game needs two teaks on our current rating system. First, based on the fact that horse abilities seemingly rise and fall from race to race in today’s game, basing any rating system on the last 12 months doesn’t work anymore. I would love to see the rankings system tweaked a bit, where a greater emphasis is put on more recent starts. Use a quarterly system where the most recent quarter (or third if you prefer, 3-4 months) results are worth more points than the previous 3 quarters or 2 thirds. It would reward horses who are in form but not totally penalize results from the past 3-12 months. Per the Derby, and other races in general, the game needs a mile category. Create an 8/8.5F category and call it good. Why should a horse have the same points count towards the BB Classic and the BB Dirt Mile? Seems foolish to me. Make these two changes and you’ll have the Derby field full of routers who are hitting their form at the right time. If there is a race or two that are important (like, say the BB Juvenile at 8.5F on dirt) then count it as a lock race and we’re good.
Question 3 – the older I get the more I like Cranberries that I can eat.
Interesting takes. Quarterly certainly would weed out the untenable 2yo superstars come 3yo duds problem, but could still be manipulated by the player-bought stakes. Mike (he who needs no introduction) has always done a good job, in my mind, of reacting but not overreacting with tweaks to the gameplay, so I would not get behind a solution that makes the system more complex (and I doubt he would implement it.)
The Mile points category, on the other hand, makes a lot of sense to me. As we all (should) know, there is a massive difference in performance / horse distance preference +/- as little as 100m sometimes ( 1/16 mile). It could be tricky applying to spring 3yo on dirt, since most Derby preps are in that 8.5.f-9f range, for a race run at 10f.
Any thoughts on Lenny’s ‘short route’ class suggestion?
Question1: No the game is not too hard in theory. But with more and more horses in the sim and some players having multiple accounts and literally 1000 horses combined or more which differs from years ago it has now brought light to so things that could be tweaked in the game or addressed.
Question 2: I agree with Lenny271 on this one and a while back I believe it was he that posted similar in the forums regarding the rating system. I do lots of BTB articles each year on mainly Graded races. I look at some of the races I preview and many times I have had to shake my head as to how is it possible that this horse qualified for the graded race while knocking out what I would definitely consider much better horses based on their racing schedules and most recent performances. When I see a horse that has won a bunch of allowance races and maybe placed in one Listed Stakes and most all were soft and/or short fields and have not won or placed in a recent start over the past several months but are knocking out recent graded winners and placers in recent starts that seems to be a concern to me. This is not just in 2 and 3 year old races but graded races for older horses as well. You ask for examples, this is the best example I feel I can give as I don’t want to call out horses and it is really not possible to go back and look at a race and see what horse knocked out a horse that would be considered better qualified. So I agree with Lenny271 on the points he addressed as I have seen too many times good horses being knocked out of a graded starts by lesser horses that I feel have no business being in the race and have no change at hitting the boards. I don’t have a fix for the problem, but agree we need a reevaluation of the point system and how we can better ensure the best horses are actually qualifying and running in our graded races.
Answer – Cranberries
Question – What is a natural remedy for Donny’s burning sensations.
I’m sorry, the format you chose post your reply is putting your standing in serious jeopardy.
Ahh, the Cranberries. I was lucky enough to see them live at the, now non-existent, Polaris Amphitheater way back when. Good show.
I remember hearing that the band’s original name was “The Cranberry Saw Us”.
Which is pretty cool, right?
1. I don’t think it is to hard. Would I like to see some changes? Sure, everyone has a few things. Personally I lost count of just how many males I have claimed because in the horse work F/M is fillies and mares and C/H/G is colts and horses and geldings. It still drives me wild because I still screw it up so that is something that for a new player that may be a horse person (which i think most are) you can accidently make a crap claim thinking you are making a great one and then you loose all your buying power for 4-6 months….ask me how I know lol. Otherwise as far as difficulty I don’t think its hard per’se just time consuming. If you want to do well for free you can but you have to claim a lot, run a lot, and get lucky. You have to get lucky, but you also have to spend the time. I do think the hot sires hit a bit too often and the smaller sires not quite enough, that definitely favors players who spend more $$$$.
2. I don’t pay as much attention to the derby as others. I do think it should be tailored more towards jan-april races than 2yo form. I also would like to see the points system for stakes be tweaked a bit maybe? I honestly am not familiar enough with it to know how it could be done. I have noticed if you a nice 3yo (colt or filly) and you frequently can’t get them in a graded race early half. It seems those races are flooded with horses that ran in privately bought stakes or ran in stakes with maybe shorter fields where then handfuls of horses were put in to see what sticks. I don’t blame the individuals that take advantage of this system as much as the system but it is frustrating when you think you have that one good horse and continuously get bumped from the races you need. Again, I don’t know enough about the system to suggest how this could be corrected.
3. Cranberries are fantastic to eat, fantastic to drink, and fantastic as a supplement…they might be alright listening too, but I think I only know one song, before my time.
I think you make a good point about gearing towards Jan-Apr. In a sense, eliminating the 2yo races from the Derby points doesn’t necessarily mean they are at a disadvantage, if those stakes points accumulated at 2 help those horses GET INTO the Derby-qualifying races at 3.
This would require a new category by itself, something like Derby Stakes Points… along the lines of Lenny’s “route” points, it would be just for 3yos, earned only at 3, at a narrow range of distances (8f to 10f).
I think we might be getting somewhere!
1. The game has progressed to a state where I don’t have much fun with it. Liked it a lot more years ago. Too many horses now and races haven’t been added to compensate. Speed numbers are way too high. The game is way too much pay to win.
2. Just use the real Derby points system. I don’t know why this hasn’t been done ages ago (other than there have been zero game changes in years so draw your own conclusions about maintenance mode). That said, it doesn’t affect me so I don’t view it as a primary concern. Dirt racing is awful in the SIM. Dirt stallions are dramatically under rated compared to turf stallions and dirt races, because there is a glut of horses and no new races have been added are always packed so your horse spends its entire career facing 14-horse fields.
3. Dolores’s voice in Linger will break even the hardest hearts at 2 am on a Saturday night. The band’s music has aged extremely well. I have them as the 4th greatest band of the 90s behind Nirvana, Hole, and Smashing Pumpkins. This is based on how often I still listen to them, so while PJ is a seminal band, I never feel like throwing Jeremy on.
Sorry to hear the fun element is waning. It is cyclical for me, and others I’ve spoken with, and the solution has always been some strategic navel gazing, retooling, and trying new approaches to keep it fresh. I am in the midst of a reboot right now, and plan on writing a BTB article about it as well. My mares are old and my choice of sires is no longer competitive, so that’s one place to start.
No arguments on Dolores (RIP) but I’ve got several others ahead of the Pumpkins (Soundgarden, Stone Temple Pilots, the Pixies if we are generous with the timing.)
Also weren’t Hole’s songs allegedly written by the Smashing Pumpkin’s frontman? You could be accused of double-dipping 🙂
1) Game is the right level of complicated, based on just enough real world with the perfect pinch of RNG to keep things interesting.
2) The current Derby system is pretty dang solid, The Derby is easily the most coveted prize and insanely hard to win. Keep it how it is… the rules are clear, the challenge is difficult and the randomness in winners is fantastic
3) Band… although both are less than enjoyable ingesting in any sizable quantity
I happen to know you’re a pretty rational dude so your statements carry weight with me, for sure. I can agree with the ‘coveted and insanely hard’, and it damn well should be. I don’t want to make it easier to win by any means, and randomness has to be a factor… but I suppose the perception of what is ‘fair’ to the trainers might be more subjective than I imagined.
#3 brings up an either/or scenario… Would you rather eat a bag of raw cranberries, or listen to the Cranberries for 16 hours straight?
Replies are mandatory (not just Cadet.)
1 The game is not to hard. The reality is people have to high expectations. The chances of doing well in the sim far outweigh real life. The game is not like playing alone on easy settings on a stand alone PC or gaming console. It is meant to be hard and a challenge, set realistic goals on a global or even individual horse basis.
2 It took Godolphin and before it became a brand over 30 years to win an English Derby. Why should the sim version of a classic be any easier (it probably is). To many people playing easy level alone on their PC/Console. This is the real fake world it is hard enjoy any success you get.
3 I don’t think drink Cranberries alone will solve the burning.
1. The game isn’t that hard. Just make sure to earn a lot of bp’s and use them well and you’ll build up a good stables in time. The hard thing is that it takes time and effort. Of course if you have real money to spend you’ll reach the heights faster.
2. I’m not going for the Kentucky Derby.
3. Black metal is the new black!
Answer to Question 2
I think the Derby point system works now, its clear that you need to earn the route stakes points to be able to make the cut. You’re all but guaranteed to make the big race if you can win an ALW (4) + Stakes (16) + Grade 1 (128) or any combination of results adding to that total (148 stakes points).
The key now is to make sure you lock up the ALW and Stakes wins as a 2yo or early in the 3yo season so that if your contenders can rise to the top when the 9F+ grade ones open up. If a horse can’t win a Grade One route, then they probably aren’t ready for the Derby either.
The only change I could see make sense to make sure the cream of the 3yo crop can qualify for the Derby might be to double stakes points from the Derby Locks. That way those who finish top two in the locks would most likely have enough points making 2nd place lock finishes equivalent to other Grade One victories.
Cheers!