Flightline Wow or Whoa?
Saturday September 3rd was a big day for racing. It started with Zaaki winning his second straight Group Two Tramway Stakes at Sydney and continued with Minzaal winning the Group One Sprint Cup at Haydock. As the day wore on Saratoga saw the Jockey Club Gold Cup go to Olympiad. Graded stakes were run across the globe and certainly the connections of those winners will always remember the day. But as the end drew near there was one race that all of racing will remember for a very long time – the Pacific Classic at Del Mar.
This race attracts the top West Coast older horses as well as up and coming three year olds and is run over the American classic distance of a mile and a quarter. Past winners include California Chrome, Candy Ride and memorably the top mare Beholder. But from now on the Pacific Classic will be forever remembered for the performance by Flightline.
This year’s field was solid with five graded stakes winners lining up behind heavy favorite Flightline topped by Dubai World Cup winner Country Grammar. But going in the racing community expected Flightline to be the heavy favorite. He was making his first try at the distance but he was undefeated and really untested in four previous starts. But no one anticipated what actually happened once the gates opened.
Winning by 19 ¼ lengths while geared down and nearly breaking the stakes and track record Flightline cruised down the stretch with jockey Flavien Prat looking over his shoulder for competition repeatedly. Immediately tongues were wagging, comparing Flightline to the greats of American racing. Secretariat’s 31 length Belmont Stakes triumph was the most common frame of reference. Within twenty four hours Flightline had been assigned a 126 Beyer Speed Figure (the most common speed figures used in America). That number was the second highest figure ever assigned to a horse in the thirty one years the figures have been published in the Daily Racing Form. Only Ghostzapper who once ran a 128 has gone higher. (Andy Beyer who created the speed figures assigned Secretariat a 139 in the Belmont but that was before the figures became widely disseminated).
Just as quickly as the accolades came in the detractors spoke out too. Is Flightline a great horse? With only four other starts under his belt that is certainly a valid question to ask. Certainly he has had the most impressive first five starts of any horse since Ruffian but her first five starts all came in one year (indeed over just a five month period). Flightline made his first start in April of 2021 as a three year old and took twenty months to get to the Pacific Classic. In 2021 he not only broke his maiden but won an allowance and the Grade One Malibu against fellow three year olds. His only prior run of 2022 saw him win the prestigious Grade One Metropolitan Mile at Belmont. All of his wins have been eye-catching but none quite like the tour de force shown at Del Mar.
So where do you come down on this horse? Is he an all time great or did he just deliver one performance for all time? If he retired tomorrow would he be remembered for his talent or just for what might have been? And for the international contingent how do you feel about him being compared to Baaeed who has twice as many starts to his name?
Wonderful article Spin! It was an awesome race and I also loved the jockey cam footage.
126 Beyer and his sheets numbers should be huge based on the final speed and his wide trip.
.From Timeform: “Flightline’s rating now stands at 143, an outstanding figure which only a handful of horses in Europe have ever bettered in Timeform’s experience, namely Frankel (147), Sea-Bird (145), Brigadier Gerard and Tudor Minstrel (144), all of those, of course, on turf.”
The first thing to point out is Timeform have in real terms only recently rated US dirt racing.
The overall performance is excellent. It cannot though be compared to the two most recent horses listed (yes 1970’s show how few times horse do this).
Both Frankel and Brigadier Gerard were unbeaten grade 1 winning 2yos’s (note BG had Mill Reef to run against another 140+ rated horse).
The two were then classic winning multiple times winners against older horses at 3 at grade 1 level. This is the true merit of a horse not only the best of a generation but better than the ones before. These are the things that link most of the top performing sires the ability at 3 to beat their elders at the top level and great 2yo ability.
They both had full season’s at 4 one remand unbeaten the other only beaten once (in a race with the highest Timeform speed figure ever seen). If Roberto had not run BG would be rated over 150 which shows the subjective nature of ratings at times.
The currently unbeaten Baaeed has far better credentials when it comes to the breeding shed than Flightline, though is inferior in terms of true ability shown on an individual race basis to date. His overall profile is better (number of races run, constant quality and soundness). Sometimes these outstanding horses never get to show what they are worth. I know John Oxx knew Sea The Stars was capable of far more than he showed but nothing was good enough to push him.
On a side note no stallion rated 140+ has produced a horse of equal rating or above, that could change with Sea The Stars and Baaeed.
Well it is a shame that today’s great horses are more lightly raced than yesteryears champs but…that was crazy good performance. I look at the fact it was only his “5th” career start and he left us with jaws dropped. If not geared down late he, wins by even more and breaks the track record rather easily in only his 5th start! I hate when people try to compare horses from one generation because there are simply too many variables. Secretariat’s Belmont was the greatest race I have ever seen and remains so, but Flightline’s win was one of the greatest efforts I have seen in quite some time. Ownership hinted at a 5 year old campaign which would be great because the industry needs these superstars. I for one would feel cheated if he was retired after just 6 starts. It wouldn’t be Justified.
All you need to do is watch how full of run he was on the backstretch (climbing the ladder) fact of the matter he had way more in the tank than he showed. He eased well before the line and was still close to Candy Rides record and Candy Ride was pushed all the way around the track by MDO that day. Flightline is a generational horse and I hope we get to see more of him.
Spectacular effort, plain and simple. Perhaps the best race I’ve seen in…..hmm, perhaps let’s not go overboard. I remember Frosted’s Met Mile, where he powered away to win by 15 in under 1:33. After that? A nice win in the Whitney, then a surprise loss on an overconfident ride in the Woodward, and a brutal defeat in the Classic. I think the big question- 10f- was answered emphatically, but that’s not a surprise with his pedigree. You could- could- ask the familiar refrain, “who has he beaten?” Well, I kind of subscribe to the thought that “you can only beat who shows up,” and he’s certainly done that. He’ll be a deserving favorite in the Classic, but I can’t play him at less than 2-1, which he will most likely be. I still don’t think Life Is Good wants any part of 10f. We’ll see if this scares him into the Dirt Mile, but I doubt it. Epicenter is rapidly improving. We still don’t know what to make of Charge It, a 23 length winner of the Dwyer. If those horses, particularly Life Is Good, show up in the Classic, I think that gives us a better take of how Flightline stacks up. He’ll be pressured early by Life Is Good, and Epicenter will get a nice stalking trip. Call me crazy, but Epicenter’s Travers, over a fairly deep surface in 2:00 3/5, also eased up in the last 16th, was a very nice race. In fact, he came home faster over the final half mile than Flightline did. Granted, comparing surfaces is like apples and oranges, but the Saratoga surface was pretty deep and tiring all meet long. If he’s sitting at 4-1 or better, I’ll be all over him.
Flightline is certainly an electric horse, perhaps a generational talent. But I think we can pump the brakes on the Secretariat talk. For now, at least. From a figures standpoint, he towers over everyone right now. We’ll find out soon enough if the “numbers” are accurate predictors of talent.
Finally, I echo the wishes to see him at 5. But if he stomps the Classic, what else is there to prove, and is it worth the risk with a horse of this caliber who’s had his fair share of physical issues?
Completely agree with you. I was just talking to someone this morning and said if he wins the Classic no way we see him at 5. I remember Feathered was better on turf, too bad we will never see this guy on the turf. With his breeding and record on the track (especially if he remains unbeaten) he will be retired. Seeing how they have clearly have had issues with him as well there is absolutely no reason to continue risking him on the track (though Tapit hasn’t had a really good stallion son he should still get the mares). I won’t expect much in the shed from him though and wouldn’t touch him till he’s proven, but that’s a personal preference. Love getting to see him run, wish we had him on the track longer.
excellent !!!!!
https://youtu.be/q63Cq_KSI5M
I saw many of the greatest horses of all time in person. Dr Fager (3 times) Damascus (twice) Buckpasser (3 times) and the brilliant but ill fated Graustark. Dr Fager was sinfully fast from 2 furlongs to 2 miles. He broke track records carrying a house on his back. He crossed the line first 19 times in 22 starts. The only horses to beat him were brilliant animals and Damascus had a helper. I saw most of Secretariat’s races on TV or video. No question in my mind that his Belmont was the greatest single performance in racing history. Flightline is every bit as talented as both the good doctor and Big Red. Very few horses of modern vintage impress me. But Flightline’s last three races blew my mind. This big guy is the real deal! IF (big IF) he stays sound, nobody can touch him. He makes multiple stakes winners look like Amish rejects and does it effortlesly.
Lets not forget the ladies! Rachel, during her 3 yo year when running against her own gender, was running daylights past the competition.
And she beat the boys! It kind of made me sad when so many fans took sides in regard to Rachel v Zenyatta. Both did things you had to see to believe. I loved both of them.
Couldn’t agree more! They each excelled in their own theater.
Spin: Fantastic work. Thank You.
It’s as Wow for me…
Sjmeola
A couple things. First, I don’t understand why anyone would think Flightline would get into a speed duel. Like Spectacular Bid, he’s incredibly fast. I don’t think he worries about horses being ahead of him. He KNOWS he’s going to catch them.
He’s made graded stakes horses look like $10,000 claimers all three times he’s run against them. It’s not right to compare a horse like Frosted to Flightline.
I’m an old guy. The last person who gets carried away by the next big thing in any sport. But there is something special about this horse.
I understand the idea of people wanting to remain calm and keep their head. I think this is a rare occasion where really young fans who haven’t had a chance to see as much as us old guys have, are in agreement. This horse as run three jaw dropping races in a row. Every time shocking me. After forty plus years of watching racing.
I feel bad for Life As Good. He’s a great racehorse. He may never get the respect he deserves. But he won’t be the first great talent in sports who just happened to come around at the wrong time.
I hope I didn’t offend anyone. If I’m wrong. please don’t feel bad of telling me so!
Also, I forgot to mention, go back and watch the last sixteenth of a mile of the Pacific Classic. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a jockey pull up as hard as Flavian Pratt did with Flightline. That’s the scary thing. I don’t think there’s any doubt he could have had a much faster time. I hope Epicenter ran a faster last half mile.
If things go the way I think they will, this is in many ways a chance for horse racing fans to potentially get that once in a lifetime experience. If it happens, that doesn’t take anything away from all the other great racehorses we’ve all loved.
We will see. I wasn’t directly comparing him to Frosted- that would be a bit ludicrous. The thought process I intended to imply is let’s wait and see a bit more- a horse like Frosted has destroyed fields previously, only to return to Earth with a resounding thud. Granted, there may never be a thud with Flightline. He’s decimated every field he faced. That said, perhaps I should have been more clear that I was not “comparing” him to Frosted. No offense taken at all! Finally, outside of the Met Mile, where he broke poorly, he’s never really been challenged with a pushed hot pace for an extended length. He may get that test in the Classic. If he’s as good as he has looked, he’ll probably swat that away like he seats flies with his tail.
As far as how many more races, I see that it was announced that he will stand at Lane’s End following “the end of his racing career.” That may not mean next season, but when those big farms make a commitment to buy a big ticket stallion, they usually can’t wait to get him into the shed and start recouping some of their investment. Hope he runs at five, but if he stomps the Classic field, there’s not much more to prove. I’m sure there are plans for insurance policies and all that should he run at five, but those things are pricey.
“Swats flies”
Damn autocorrect!