Nineteen Go in THE 20,000 Credit Added ESR Big Apple Derby
A field of Nineteen Three Tear Old Colts will fill the Big Apple starting gate for the first running of the 20,000-credit added ESR Big Apple Derby. The Race will be run at Ten Furlongs over the dirt Course.
PUEBLOS LIMITROFES – his win in the Grade 2 Heat Less Stakes clearly separates the ivanyamil trained son of Liam’s Map from the rest of the field, thus identifying him as the horse to beat in the first running of the 20,000-credit added Big Apple Derby…the question of course is, as it is for every horse in this field, can he handle the 10-furlongs…having never raced beyond one mile and a sixteenth, it will keep the bettors second guessing, and with the size of this field you can certainly expect an overlay…looks best on paper
LEAD THE PARADE – the valesa bred, trotter1 trained son of Laoban has all the lofty credentials that you want to see from a three year old colt entering a Residency Derby…the winner of the 2021 ESR Brooklyn Bridge Challenge has also added victories in the G3 Montana Futurity, the ESR Gotham Derby Prep Stakes, and a second place finish in the G3 Trixy Delight’s Special at a mile; however, despite the impressive record of this New York bred, he has not proven his prowess beyond 8-furlongs…your call
QUIST FOR GOLD – after an effortless victory in the ESR Bobby B Lewis Derby Prep Stks, the trotter1 connections changed their direction for this son of Nyquist and pointed him toward the Bluegrass Derby…facing, at the most, two starts before the Bluegrass a third place finish in the G2 Moises Alou Cap left connections wavering on what was next for the talented three year old…points to make it to the Bluegrass Derby were of the utmost importance and there would be very little margin for error; failure in a Lock Prep race would leave him out of both Derby’s…the decision to run for the 20,000 credits seemed to be the most prudent choice…after an impressive performance in the 9-furlong ESR Hacksaw Derby Prep Stks you can expect this KY bred to be the main rival in the ESR feature…dangerous
MY OLD BOSS – this trotter1 trained NY Bred by Laoban is gaining quite a bit of attention along the Big Apple backstretch and deservedly so…back-to-back victories in ESR Derby Prep races, the last, posting a 109-speed figure, tops in this field, in the 9-furlong ESR Wooden Memorial Derby Prep Stakes has him on everyone’s radar, but can he handle the extra furlong…take some beating
OLDER SON IVAN – a pair of ESR Derby Prep stakes victories over the Poly Surface has propelled this ivanyamil trainee into a major player in the ESR Derby…of course the major concern for most bettors is will he repeat those efforts over the Dirt Course…the KY Bred son of Quality Road has turned in solid efforts over the Dirt Course and convincing victories in his last two starts at 9-furlongs should dismiss any concerns about handling this surface or distance…poised for big effort
LAGRIMAS DE LUNA – you might want to dismiss the fact that the valesa trained son of Laoban still carries the Maiden label considering that the KY Bred is coming off perhaps the best race of his young career…one of two geldings in this field, his second-place finish in the ESR Hacksaw Derby Prep Stakes LTO while posting a career best 103-speed figure and missing by less than a length to top contender QUIST FOR GOLD leaves him a maiden by distinction only and certainly not based on performance…might surprise
VERY GOOD MEMORY – the slowroll trained 3-Year-Old Chestnut Colt by Good Magic made his way into the ESR Derby field by virtue of a second-place finish in the ESR Bayou State Derby Prep Stakes, his only appearance in an ESR Derby Prep…his 102-speed figure marked a career best for the KY bred and a pair of ITM finishes at 9.5 & 9-furlongs respectively has proven that he’s already passed his inherent sprinters pedigree…in top form
A FORCE OF GOLD – not sure what happened in the ESR Hacksaw Derby Prep Stakes LTO, but the kingab trained son of Dubawi failed to respond with his usual closing kick when urged by jockey Reich, flattening out in the stretch drive…prior victories in his previous ESR Derby Preps allow me to dismiss his last outing; perhaps a bounce off a career best 101-speed figure causing the anomaly… if you think you can dismiss this colt based on hisTurf pedigree, don’t…his dam won over $300k on the Dirt and his siblings excel over the Dirt Course…chance if fit
CHINA TANGO – the francua trained son of Laoban was outstanding in his last start winning the ESR Arcadia Derby Prep Stakes by almost two lengths in gate to wire fashion…the victory marked a career best 102-speed figure for the NY Bred…with plenty of speed to his inside, he didn’t catch any breaks drawing post 18, but he has proven to be tactical in previous starts and if he can break well a settle in just off the leaders he should have something left for the stretch drive…fast and fit
CHARLIE SUNSHINE – the trotter1 trained son of Bernardinihas found his best stride when racing around two turns finishing ITM in all three of his two turn races with a third and second place finish respectively in a pair of ESR Preps earning him a spot in Saturday’s field…second in the ESR Arcadia Derby Prep Stakes, look for this colt to save ground from the rail and stalk the early pace setters…improves with every start
SINASTER MINASTER – a formidable entry in the Two Year Old contest ESR Road to the Bluegrass Challenge, the francua trained son of Distorted Humor broke his maiden at nine panels in his first start of his 3yo campaign…connections patiently plotted a path using a second place finish in an ALW NW2L before entering him is his first ESR Derby Prep…leaving little room for error, the regally bred colt turned in a career best effort in the ESR Blue Grass Derby Prep Stakes earning him a spot in Saturday’s Derby…must not ignore
FOURS ARE WILD – after a decisive victory in the ESR Tampa Bay Area Derby Prep Stakes, you would have said the kingab trained son of Curlin was clearly the early favorite to win the ESR Derby, however, in what this writer considers an unorthodox move for these connections, the KY bred was entered right back 3 weeks later, over the Poly surface no less, in the ESR Ruby Tuesday Derby Prep Stks…now I don’t know if the colt was gassed form his 106 speed figure performance in the Ruby Tuesday or he just hated the Poly, or if his connections wanted to get in one more start before the Derby with six weeks of rest heading into the ESR Derby and just gave him a stroll around the KY surface…one thing I do know, these are top connections that know there way around the training area…looks to rebound
MISCHIEVOUS I – the lightly raced, kingab trained son of Into Mischief might be the strongest of the three kingab entries in this race…following up a third place finish in only his third career start in the ESR South By Southwest Derby Prep Stakes, the kingab hopeful turned in a spectacular performance with a first place finish in the ESR Blue Grass Derby Prep Stakes…sibling to multiple graded stakes winners, this colt has quickly become the wise guy horse along the backstretch…might be this good
ZAPP OF LEMONS – the lbailey trained son of Lemon Drop Kid is another lightly raced colt whose named is being whispered about along the backstretch of the New York oval…parallel to MISCHIEVOUS I, the impressive KY bred rode a third-place finish in his third career start in the ESR Sammy F Davis Derby Prep Stakes into a nothing short of sensational victory in the ESR Orange State Derby Prep Stakes while posting an eye-catching 107 speed figure…buzz horse
NYMAJUNAS – if there’s a buzz around ESR Orange State Derby Prep Stakes winner ZAPP OF LEMONS, then there’s a loud hum around the francua trained son of Nyquist who finished a just head bob behind the aforementioned winner…finishing first or second in every career start while improving speed figures with each effort, hum, buzz call it what you want, this horse is hear and is going to make some noise…flips the script
MAKIN JOY – after picking up 50 Derby points in the ESR Rising Star Derby Prep Stakes, the jetman connections took their Bluegrass Derby shot in the G3 Chicago Derby; a disappointing showing in his Bluegrass bid, connections turned their attention back to the 20K credits and the ESR Derby; expect the son of Kitten’s Joy to rebound from his Chicago effort and return to his Rising Star form after a six-week layup…improves off last
BARELY LUKA – following in the footsteps of MAKIN JOY, the ace connections parlayed a victory in the ESR Water of Life Derby Prep Stakes into a visit to Chicago for the G3 Chicago Derby; after battling on the lead the son of Malibu Moon faded badly in the stretch, perhaps all the way back to an entry in the ESR Derby; lightly raced, expect this KY bred colt to vie for the lead and possibly, with another race under his belt, might be around at the wire in his ESR return…pace setter
MYSTERY PARLOR – perhaps proof that you should always give restricted prep races a try with almost any horse, especially with 20k credits on the line, as the trotter1 trained son of Good Magic scored his maiden victory in the ESR Bayou State Derby Prep Stakes; is he that good, we will find out, but a 103 speed figure at 9.5-furlongds has me intrigued…”Do you believe in miracles”
JUAN MO TEQUILA – installed as the 9-1 co-favorite the littlebitiii trained son of Uncle Mo earned that distinction during a hard-hitting campaign with a first, second, and third in three ESR Derby Prep races; a second-place finish to MY OLD BOSS in the ESR Wooden Memorial Derby Prep Stakes while posting a 108-speed figure was the culmination of that impressive campaign while his late running style suits him well in the upcoming feature…honest
NOTES
The field is well represented by four sons of Laoban, two sons of Good Magic, and two sons of Nyquist. The field also features two New York Breds as well as two Geldings. Six horses have also appeared in an ESR Two-Year Old Challenge Series.
HANDICAPPING THE FIELD
This might just be the hardest race I’ve had to handicap this year. While going through the past performances one by one for this article, I found myself wanting to say this is the horse to beat as I studied each entry. Kudos to all that participated, I applaud your skills in breeding and training and can honestly say I would not be surprised by any horse that won this race.
I will start with the horses that I think will get the distance based on pedigree or past performance, and this is just my opinion based of my experience in playing the horses for over 55 years, and the sim for 20 years.
CHARLIE SUNSHINE, SINASTER MINASTER, FOURS ARE WILD, MISCHIEVOUS I, ZAPP OF LEMONS, NYMAJUNAS, A FORCE OF GOLD, MYSTERY PARLOR, JUAN MO TEQUILA, OLDER SON IVAN, and QUIST FOR GOLD. Before I go any further you will notice I didn’t put any of the Laoban’s on this list. I wish I could, I own two of them, but the 9-furlongs was a reach, and I don’t see them getting ten panels.
That is more than half the field, which doesn’t make the final choices any easier.
The one’s that didn’t make it, well I owe an explanation…
The Laoban’s, even though I think all four are exceptional, again I don’t think 10-furlongs is their game.
While I absolutely love everything PUEBLOS LIMITROFES has done on the racetrack to this point, I just don’t see me choosing a Liam’s Map against the top twelve in a 10-furlong affair.
I hedged on MAKIN JOY, he is the one I feel I can be wrong about, and he could easily finish ITM, but my gut tells me he gets caught in the stretch.
I know BARELY LUKA has a win at 9-furlongs, but that Chicago Derby, against good horses, finish bothers me, and he’s meeting good horses against this field.
VERY GOOD MEMORY has a sprinters pedigree from his Dam’s side and while he’s run well around two turns, he’s a viable candidate for getting caught in the stretch.
I will try and break down the contenders here, no simple task.
CHARLIE SUNSHINE has put together some nice races since turning his attention to racing around two turns. He hasn’t broken triple digits yet, so I am inclined to think that even if he does in this start it still won’t be enough.
I love the pedigreeof SINASTER MINASTER, and you would think a Distorted Humor would stand out far above this field, so what’s the rub…he doesn’t like to win.
FOURS ARE WILD isnot my favorite of the kingab entries… I do wonder about that precarious start over the poly last out, enough to make me wary of a wager. Still, he has that 106 over the dirt, and a return to that race makes him a major player in this field.
MISCHIEVOUS I is a live one. A must use in all exotics. Lightly raced with his best starts still in front of him…high marks
ZAPP OF LEMONS is a mirror image of MISCHIEVOUS I. If you find yourself between a rock and a hard place deciding between these two, join the club.
NYMAJUNAS was second only to ZAPP OF LEMONS and the Nyquist colt seems perfectly suited for this distance. The hum is getting louder.
A FORCE OF GOLD – not loving his last start but he does have that run all day pedigree and that has my respect.
It was a shock when MYSTERY PARLOR broke his maiden to make this field, but don’t sell him short here. That was a solid effort, and it was 9.5 furlongs. Something to consider.
If the back-to-backwins over the poly are an issue for you, then OLDER SON IVAN is not the horse for you. It doesn’t bother me.
JUAN MO TEQUILA checks all the boxes and looks like he gets better with distance. No surprise at 9-1.
I took my Bluegrass Derby shot with QUIST FOR GOLD and if he won the Moises Alou Cap you would not have seen him here in this field. I guess that’s as good an endorsement as I can give a horse.
THE PICKS
It’s really a toss between MISCHIEVOUS I and ZAPP OF LEMONS. Both are lightly raced with their best racing in front of them. The slightest of edge to:
ZAPP OF LEMONS – last was bang up
MISCHIEVOUS I – your welcome kingab
QUIST FOR GOLD – knew he was going to win his last, have that same feeling now
GREAT JOB PETE! Thanks for the write up and analysis!
Sensational write Pete!
Thank you for the write up Pete and for the competition! Best of luck to everyone! It’s been fun!
Nice write-up, Pete! Good luck all.