GRADE-3 CHESTER WEST HANDICAP
New York (NY)
Saturday, April 23, 2022 — 2:00:00 PM EST | Race ID : 2801517
The Chester West Handicap
Grade III / Group 3*CPU – Purse : $150,000
Restricted to 3 Year Olds and Older
8 Furlongs | ~1600 Meters | One Mile Fast Dirt
UNDERLAY / OVERLAY RACE STUDY (thru 04/22/2022):
| total races | 106 | total horses | 1474 | ||||
| underlays | 371 | wins | 31 | places | 33 | show | 26 |
| win % | 8.356% | place % | 8.895% | ||||
| avg win pay | $15.97 | avg plc pay | $8.34 | ||||
| win ROI $ | -$0.67 | place ROI $ | -$0.56 | ||||
| overlays | 424 | wins | 47 | places | 40 | show | 36 |
| win % | 11.085% | place % | 9.434% | ||||
| avg win pay | $26.04 | avg plc pay | $12.45 | ||||
| win ROI $ | $0.89 | place ROI $ | $0.55 | ||||
| non-select | 679 | wins | 28 | places | 33 | show | 44 |
| win % | 4.124% | place % | 4.860% | ||||
| avg win pay | $28.32 | avg plc pay | $13.35 | ||||
| win ROI $ | -$0.83 | place ROI $ | -$0.80 |
Here’s the capsule breakdown for the 14 entries:
| 1 | 12 | GUNS N JONESES | PACE | 5.80% | SPEED | 6.44% | CLASS | 6.15% | BET VALUE | 99.58% |
| trainer | padrebri15 | RANK | 11 | RANK | 11 | RANK | 9 | RANK | 7 |
EARLY POSITION – REAR PACK
comment … first crack at Stakes company in his 13th start, GUNS N JONSES is still eligible for allowance nw-3x so it’s a pretty good class jump. He’s finished first or second in 10 of his 12 lifetime races and even though he likes to rally in the stretch, his only 2 out of the money finishes were at 9 furlongs, which you’d assume he’d relish. GUNS N JONESES 12-1 odds are fair and he consistently gives a good effort, likely candidate to finish top-5!
| 2 | 11 | ULYSSES CAUSE | PACE | 8.55% | SPEED | 7.48% | CLASS | 13.22% | BET VALUE | 134.29% |
| trainer | jastables19 | RANK | 5 | RANK | 7 | RANK | 2 | RANK | 3 |
EARLY POSITION – LEAD PACK
comment … ULYSSES CAUSE’S record in Stake competition 10 starts, with 1 place and 2 shows. His other 10 starts resulted in 4 wins, 3 places and 3 shows, so he’s a proven good allowance runner. He’s certainly tested this level of competition and has a nice 2nd place effort in the Grade-3 Nickes Memorial last September, he’s priced right at 11-1 so I wouldn’t count him out!
| 3 | 11 | SECOND SPIKE | PACE | 10.18% | SPEED | 9.81% | CLASS | 7.16% | BET VALUE | 116.57% |
| trainer | lenny11 | RANK | 3 | RANK | 1 | RANK | 6 | RANK | 6 |
EARLY POSITION – ON OR NEAR THE LEAD
comment … another runner in a long list that showed lots of improvement after being gelded. SECOND SPIKE is coming off the 3 best races of his 14-race career, the last race, a Grade-3 Winchester Cap victory was the very best. He produced a blazing 119.325 speed rating, a career best. The only reservation is the dreaded “bounce” factor after a 115-117-119 speed rating progression, at 11-1 I’d take the risk and look for a repeat effort.
| 4 | 5 | MAKE MY TOES CURL | PACE | 11.19% | SPEED | 9.11% | CLASS | 5.27% | BET VALUE | 54.20% |
| trainer | redhill13 | RANK | 1 | RANK | 3 | RANK | 10 | RANK | 13 |
EARLY POSITION – ON OR NEAR THE LEAD
comment … it will be interesting to see which of the 3 identified early speed runners actually gets the early lead, my program says it’ll be MAKE MY TOES CURL, as none of the 3 regularly go to the front early. In his last race the most dynamic of his 22-race career, MAKE MY TOES CURL scored his only wire to wire win of his career. A repeat of the “blazing”, 120.646 speed figure certainly makes him a primary contender to win. The oddsmaker has made him the 5-1 2nd favorite, pretty low considering he’s never won a Graded Stake in 9 tries!
| 5 | 13 | INDIO MARA | PACE | 4.30% | SPEED | 7.12% | CLASS | 1.01% | BET VALUE | 86.20% |
| trainer | justhaack | RANK | 12 | RANK | 9 | RANK | 13 | RANK | 10 |
EARLY POSITION – REAR PACK
comment … trainer justhaack has a problem most trainers wish they had, his colt INDIO MARA is very talented and versatile, the son of sire Gun Runner has had sucess on dirt and turf and his late running style means he should take to the longer distances very well. His only Stake effort was a 7th in the Grade-2 Evolving Serpent at 7 1/2 furlongs, where he was coming on late. I think he’ll make a good showing, likely top-5, 13-1 odds are fair as there’s likely a Graded Stake win in his near future!
| 6 | 8 | CRY FOR JUSTICE | PACE | 7.35% | SPEED | 8.84% | CLASS | 6.18% | BET VALUE | 83.59% |
| trainer | stockswami18 | RANK | 8 | RANK | 4 | RANK | 8 | RANK | 11 |
EARLY POSITION – MID PACK
comment … took 4 whacks at Stake company in 2019-2020 as a 2- & 3-year-old with a 3rd place finish in an Open Stake as his best showing. Dropped back to allowance level in his last 8 races and managed 3 wins and 2 placings. CRY FOR JUSTICE posted a 116.942 career best speed rating, besting an Open Allowance field last start so he’s back to try and succeed at the Graded level. He seems fit and at his best but at 8-1 I’d take a pass at the betting window!
| 7 | 10 | HURRICANE LEGEND | PACE | 7.78% | SPEED | 7.22% | CLASS | 1.08% | BET VALUE | 71.19% |
| trainer | desertdog18 | RANK | 7 | RANK | 8 | RANK | 12 | RANK | 12 |
EARLY POSITION – MID PACK
comment … HURRICANE LEGEND is proof that the “curse of the Breeders Bowl Juvenile” winner is alive and well. After his BBJV win, HURRICANE LEGEND’S record was 4 wins in 6 starts, with a Grade-1 & Grade-3 win already on his record. Fast forward 10 races later and he still has 4 wins, although HURRICANE LEGEND did manage a solid 2nd place finish in the Grade-2 South Bend Derby 5 races ago. Hard to imagine a budding superstar still has to prove himself, but horse racing is a “what have you done for me lately” sport. His 10-1 odds seem a bit short considering his last 2 races a 15th and a 10th! Redemption? Maybe?
| 8 | 23 | BREATH OF HOPE | PACE | 2.24% | SPEED | 1.96% | CLASS | 0.67% | BET VALUE | 98.07% |
| trainer | 2020massatoga5 | RANK | 14 | RANK | 14 | RANK | 14 | RANK | 9 |
EARLY POSITION – NEAR THE REAR
comment … looking at BREATH OF HOPE’S past performances, one has to wonder how talented colt like him has only managed 1 win in his 16 lifetime starts. You can blame at least some of it on his late running style, he’s usually still mid pack when the field hits the 3rd call and his late stretch rallying style just needs even more distance to bear winner’s fruit. Given that 8 furlongs seems a bit short for him to reach winning contention, 23-1 odds are fair and tempting, so given that, he’s a runner I’d include in my exotic wagers back end!
| 9 | 21 | ONE N BONE | PACE | 9.40% | SPEED | 5.78% | CLASS | 1.46% | BET VALUE | 134.02% |
| trainer | wandavision | RANK | 4 | RANK | 12 | RANK | 11 | RANK | 4 |
EARLY POSITION – LEAD PACK
comment … looking back over his 19-race career, it’s hard it’s imagine ONE N BONE was entered and claimed in his 4th race for a paltry $3000 in a nw-2L claiming event. He’s gone on to win 9 races including 5 allowance contests. He’s versatile and has won on turf and dirt. ONE N BONE does his best racing when he’s top 3 and close to the pace early, which he should be in this field. At 21-1 he’s got some value and while there’s lots of questions and risk, the reward is decent!
| 10 | 4 | BUCK THE EMPIRE | PACE | 2.24% | SPEED | 9.24% | CLASS | 7.27% | BET VALUE | 53.50% |
| trainer | hkseries2 | RANK | 13 | RANK | 2 | RANK | 5 | RANK | 14 |
EARLY POSITION – NEAR THE REAR
comment … perusing BUCK THE EMPIRE’S past performances, one fact literally jumps off the page. He’s contested 21 of his 22 lifetime starts at 8-furlongs and on the fast dirt surface. Ironically his lone try at 8 1/2 furlongs was his worst finish, a well beaten 6th, but it was only BUCK THE EMPIRE’S 3rd race and against Stake company. What’s really surprising is that he’s has a late running closing style which is usually more contentious as the distance increases. He’s had some success, but he only has 1 Open Stake win and his best Graded Stake finish was a decent 3rd in the Grade-3 The Not Far Stake. BUCK THE EMPIRE is the 4-1 favorite and may well finally get his 2nd Stake win but is certainly undervalued odds wise!
| 11 | 73 | WEST VIRGINIA KASH | PACE | 7.78% | SPEED | 3.81% | CLASS | 6.49% | BET VALUE | 550.38% |
| trainer | kashclaim | RANK | 6 | RANK | 13 | RANK | 7 | RANK | 1 |
EARLY POSITION – MID PACK
comment … WEST VIRGINIA KASH has done virtually everything asked of him in his 7-race career, after winning his maiden in his 1st start, he won 3 straight conditioned allowance races, then placed 2nd in his first Open Stake try and won an Open Stake in his next start. WEST VIRGINIA KASH then tried Grade-1 competition and ran a respectable 6th. Does that sound like a 73-1 odds runner to you? There are 2 obvious potential drawbacks to his success, first he’s a 3-year-old facing older runners early in the season, usually suicide. Also, his speed figures are 10-12 points below the level he needs to contend at this level. Daunting yes, impossible no, I’m putting all the spare change I can find on his nose, may even start a go fund me page! 🙂
| 12 | 7 | TWIRLING TIZZY | PACE | 6.67% | SPEED | 7.05% | CLASS | 22.67% | BET VALUE | 129.76% |
| trainer | horizons6 | RANK | 9 | RANK | 10 | RANK | 1 | RANK | 5 |
EARLY POSITION – REAR MID PACK
comment … the first 10 months of 2021 were not kind to trainer horizons6’s TWIRLING TIZZY, after capping off 2020 with his 4th straight win, TWIRLING TIZZY went into a 5-race tailspin that I’m sure caused his trainer lots of sleepless nights. The good news is that he seems to have come back to form last December with 2 back-to-back 2nd place efforts, the last a very game 2nd in the Grade-2 Curious George, where he missed the win by a scant head at the wire. He’s got the class, credentials and at 7-1 is a bit of an overlay, making him a “prime” contender!
| 13 | 8 | JUST AWESOMENESS | PACE | 6.27% | SPEED | 8.47% | CLASS | 8.97% | BET VALUE | 98.96% |
| trainer | zkingab8 | RANK | 10 | RANK | 5 | RANK | 4 | RANK | 8 |
EARLY POSITION – REAR MID PACK
comment … for whatever reason JUST AWESOMENESS never started his career until he was a 4-year-old, so he’s very lightly raced with just 9 career starts. He’s made the most of them, winning 6 including an Open Stake in his 2nd last start earning a respectable 115.928 speed figure in the process. His last start was a near miss 4th, only losing by a 1/2 length in a 4-horse photo. While his 8-1 odds don’t make me do back-flips, they’re fair and if I were to make a “sleeper” pick, JUST AWESOMENESS would be it!
| 14 | 16 | CRYSTALLINE TONES | PACE | 10.26% | SPEED | 7.66% | CLASS | 12.41% | BET VALUE | 202.98% |
| trainer | stormborn4 | RANK | 2 | RANK | 6 | RANK | 3 | RANK | 2 |
EARLY POSITION – ON OR NEAR THE LEAD
comment … he was dropped into a $150K claimer just 3 races ago and that was the start of a 3-race winning streak which has rejuvenated CRYSTALLINE TONES career. This will be his first race at any Stake level and that’s a very tall order. His good early speed and odds of 16-1 make him a value bet and if he can outgun the field and grab the early lead, watch out!
My opening charts show you the results of my underlay and overlay spotlight selections since 01/15/2022, I’ll try to update them weekly so you can see how effective they are at highlighting potential winners! As usual, good luck to all entries!
Here’s the program Spotlight runners:
| UNDERLAY SPOTLIGHT | OVERLAY SPOTLIGHT | |
| JUST AWESOMENESS | CRYSTALLINE TONES | |
| MAKE MY TOES CURL | SECOND SPIKE | |
| CRY FOR JUSTICE | TWIRLING TIZZY | |
| BUCK THE EMPIRE | ULYSSES CAUSE |
Thanks for the coverage! Hoping longshot West Virginia Kash can boost things up going against older horses. It’s a gamble putting him in here, we’ll see what he learns with the elder folks.
Don’t be too hard on yourself, it’s usually late summer (August) before 3 year olds are effective against the older guys, they’re just not filled out enough. West Virginia Kash is a good runner and will be just fine. btw/ I only managed to collect 42 cents and 12 campaign buttons on the go fund me page so I had to throw in the other $1.58 out of my pocket to cover the $2 bet !!! 🙂 lol
sorry to hear the go fund me didn’t come through. and neither did West Virginia Kash. I’m sure the horse will improve as the year progresses.
Thank you for all the work you did on this very tough race.