Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Uncategorized

Finding Hope In Sadness, the Death of Arrogate

The death of Arrogate at age seven has left many in the racing world shocked and saddened. The Unbridled’s Song stallion was an amazing racehorse with an equally amazing pedigree. He was considered the best chance for his sire to leave a son capable of passing on the family lineage and upon his death he was close to completing a third season at stud. He was bred to some of the finest mares available in the United States giving him an even greater chance to be an outstanding sire. His first weanlings were sold last year and he was the leading sire of weanlings by average at the two most prestigious sales, Fasig-Tipton and Keeneland’s breeding stock sales. The big question is, from his limited crops will he be able to reproduce his own talent and continue on the Unbridled’s Song line. We can look to history to find hope for Arrogate.

Going way back in history we find a similar situation with Commando. Commando was a winner of seven of nine starts, with two seconds in his career. He was named both a Champion and Horse of the Year as both a two and three year old before he was retired to stud and later was inducted into the Hall of Fame. Commando died after serving only four seasons at stud. From twenty seven foals he sired ten stakes winners (imagine those days!) including two sons who entered the Hall of Fame, Colin and Peter Pan. Commando was the leading sire in North America in 1907. His son Colin struggled with infertility during his stud career but Peter Pan produced multiple champions. However it was his stakes winning son Black Toney who became his best offspring. Black Toney became the foundation sire for Idle Hour Farm. He is best remembered for Hall of Fame members Black Gold, Bimelech and Black Helen. His sons and daughters produced many fine runners as well although nearly a century later the Commando sireline is no longer active.

Perhaps the most famous example of a sire who died young but left a lasting legacy is Bold Reasoning. Bold Reasoning was a stakes winning son of Boldnesian, a useful sire by Bold Ruler. Bold Reasoning was a better runner than his record perhaps suggests. As a four year old he set a track record at Belmont Park running six furlongs in 108.4. Bold Reasoning died midway through his second season at stud but he left behind a son who would change the breed. That of course was Triple Crown winner Seattle Slew. Seattle Slew sired 10.1% stakes winners and his sons A.P. Indy and Slew o’ Gold were both inducted into the Hall of Fame. Seattle Slew sired numerous other champions, both male and female but his primary legacy was to continue the Bold Ruler sireline. While he was a great sire he was a bit unlucky as a sire of sires. His Kentucky Derby winning son Swale died after winning the Belmont Stakes and Slew o’ Gold suffered from infertility although he did sire grade one winning Awe Inspiring and Gorgeous from his first crop. Later in his career Seattle Slew sired A.P. Indy. A.P. Indy was named Champion Three Year Old and Horse of the Year in 1992 after winning the Breeders’ Cup Classic and Belmont Stakes among other major victories. A.P. Indy is responsible for top sires like Bernardini, Congrats, Flatter, Mineshaft and promising young sires Take Charge Indy and Honor Code. That said it was a son from his first crop who is most prominent. That is Pulpit, a grade two winner who is the sire of Tapit. Tapit in turn has lead the North American Sire List four times so far in his career and is the sire of several sons who have sired grade one winners. It is safe to say the Bold Ruler sireline is not disappearing anytime soon.

Dubai Millennium was the best son of leading sire Seeking the Gold. Seeking the Gold was primarily known as a sire of great fillies, and indeed his broodmare sire stats are tremendous. But Dubai Millennium put them all to shame. A homebred son of Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum’s Godolphin Stables, Dubai Millenium was almost destined for greatness from the start. Aside from being a son of Seeking the Gold his dam was a daughter of Fall Aspen, Kentucky Broodmare of the Year in 1994. Fall Aspen produced nine stakes winners, four of whom won grade ones. Dubai Millennium’s dam Colorado Dancer was a group two winner herself. Dubai Millennium won nine of ten starts including four group one races. Three of those races came on the grass in Europe but perhaps his most memorable win was a tour de force in the Dubai World Cup on the dirt. Sadly Dubai Millennium was injured midway through his four year old season before he could make a tilt in America in the Breeders’ Cup Classic. Even more sad was that he suffered from grass fever after his first season at stud and had to be euthanized. He sired only fifty six foals and for many stallions that may have been it. But one of those foals was a son named Dubawi. Also owned and bred by Sheikh Maktoum Dubawi was a group one winner at both two and three. He was best at a mile but he was classy enough to finish third in the Epsom Derby at a mile and a half as well. Retired to stud Dubawi become the only sire in British history to sire over one hundred group winners, including forty one group one winners as of this writing. In addition to being a great sire in Europe his runners have conqured races in Australia, America and across the globe. He is also an emerging sire of sires.

So while the loss of Arrogate is tremendously sad we can hope this great runner will leave behind foals who will carry on his line and the Unbridled’s Song sireline. While he doesn’t exactly qualify for this list we can even look to Unbridled’s Song as inspiration. His sire Unbridled also died young at age fourteen after siring 437 foals and over eight percent stakes winners. Ten of his stakes winners were grade one winners including Unbridled’s Song and Empire Maker. Right now Empire Maker seems like the heir apparent to his sire but perhaps Arrogate can sustain his own sireline.

6 thoughts on “Finding Hope In Sadness, the Death of Arrogate”

  • I finally flipped the bill to buys an Arrogate share in the sim. I was hesitant, but was looking for good blue blood sires. I ended up with Arrow Volley in my stables which was a scratch bred and I think my only Arrogate runner in my stables (ARROGATE x MALIBU MOON x DEPUTY MINISTER). He won his first Maiden outing with a 73 speed rating and then headed off to run in his first Allowance race in PA running a 71 speed and came in second in a NW2L Allowance. Thus I was extremely disappointed in the loss of the sire, Arrogate of which I finally reached out and added to the lineup in my stables. I sincerely hope this will not negatively effect my horse or that of others. A great horse that passed way too soon in his racing career and which should have been a long life and history.

  • Goodluck to the Arrogate foals , hopefully there is something that can carry on his legacy

  • jubalrutledge

    Great write up !!! Thank you
    We lost two others this year A.P. INDY and Forty Niner, both were past their sire services But names that will Live a long Time .

Leave a Reply