The New Yorker Tests General Crook – Could We See a Triple Crown Again?
In a season of real life racing that has been Topsy-turvy, in the sim we have the exciting possibility of seeing only our second Triple Crown winner. General Crook is the heavy favorite to do it in the New Yorker on Saturday and he would join just the illustrious I Seek U in doing it. General Crook has already made history by being the first Breeders’ Bowl Juvenile winner to take the Bluegrass Derby also. Still there are thirteen horses lined up, hoping he is not up to the grueling mile and a half test. Let’s take a look at the field.
#1 Mendo Purple 9/1
Third choice in the field is Mendo Purple, the horse who ran General Crook to within a neck in the Bluegrass Derby. The scratchbred son of Roses in May x Unbridled’s Song x Damascus skipped the Middle Jewel so he’s fresh for this start. The Bluegrass Derby was his third start of 2020 and he won the two races prior, a grade three and a grade one to earn his way into the Derby. The deep closer was seventeenth early on in the Bluegrass Derby before making a sustained run that just came up short. He ran a career best 108 speed that day. He is easily the best runner for his sire who stands in Japan. That horse’s get have a strong preference for dirt but are nearly evenly split in terms of sprint vs. routes. Damascus on the backend will certainly be a plus in getting the distance but he’ll have to stay closer to the front runners than he is used to in order to not get swallowed up in the stretch. He’s a tough call.
#2 Mustang Brook 14/1
One of the horses who has run longer than ten furlongs is Mustang Brook. His last race came at a mile and five sixteenths and he ran a solid second in what was a listed stakes. Mustang Brook won the Grade Two Ransom Stakes at a mile and an eighth as a juvenile. That race which is run in November is often an indicator of two year olds moving forward at the right time. Mustang Brook has not made good on that promise until that listed race. Part of the problem is that he is a confirmed front runner and he tries to really run off from the field early on. That can be a disadvantage going shorter distances but often can be an advantage going longer distances (think the great Magniforma). This is the first New Yorker runner for trainer Deyoto in seventeen years and he has a very strong pedigree. His dam, the grade two winning Curlin x Giant’s Causeway mare Gracebrook was third in the Bluegrass Oaks and was twice grade one placed as a three year old. He is a son of Kentucky Derby winner Nyquist who did not run in the Belmont, but Gracebrook’s best distance was a mile and a quarter and she only ran longer once. She should add stamina to his pedigree and if he can distance himself enough from this field early on he could pull an upset.
#3 Flavors of Mayhem 10/1
Starting in December, Flavors of Mayhem won four straight races including a listed and a grade one, both going a mile and three sixteenths. He entered the Bluegrass Derby off a front running score in a listed going a mile and an eighth on the turf, an interesting training strategy for sure. The colt who likes to be on the lead was second behind Speed Genes early on in the Derby but he tried to make a move at the stretch call. Unfortunately he could not hold off the closers and finished sixth, beaten seven and a quarter lengths. He did finish four lengths ahead of Speed Genes who is a grade one winner so that is a mark in his favor. The son of Uncle Mo is out of the Sadler’s Wells x Alydar mare Across the Sunrise. A Hall of Famer based solely on her production record Across the Sunrise has produced three other grade one winners including two who earned over five million dollars. Her best foal (so far) is Fake Honeymoon by Bernardini who not only earned over five million dollars but was also an End of Year winner. The Breeders’ Bowl Classic winner was best at a mile and a quarter but he was also second by a half length in the New Yorker. The other five million dollar earner was Evil Sunrise by Pivotal who actually won the New Yorker although he did most of his racing at a mile and a quarter. At 10/1 this colt has a good chance to follow in his family footsteps.
#4 Hopkinson Flyer 7/1
Second choice in the field is Hopkinson Flyer. He entered the Bluegrass Derby as an undefeated grade one winner. He’d only had five starts though which was likely a disadvantage compared to his more seasoned competitors and may have contributed to his loss by a length and a half when third. He ran a career best 106 speed which was his third straight triple digit speed, with each one better than the last. That is often an indication of a horse moving forward and he certainly is capable of moving forward here again. In his two races prior to the Bluegrass Derby Hopkinson Flyer was last early on but his jockey in the Derby kept him a little more forwardly placed, thirteenth out of the twenty and his late run was strong. He is another who skipped the Middle Jewel and will be fresh here. Hopkinson Flyer has one of the best pedigrees in a field of great pedigrees. He’s a son of the recently deceased Arrogate out of the Hall of Fame mare Union Jack Flyer. Union Jack Flyer is by A.P. Indy x Awesome Again. She won seven grade ones, all at a mile and an eighth against other mares but she was twice second in the Japan Dirt Cup against males. As a three year old she was also second in the mile and a quarter Grade One Birmingham by only a half length. As a broodmare she has produced one other graded winner Homicidal Jack by Dubawi. He was a grade two winner going a mile and three sixteenths and was second in the Grade One Sand Castle Classic at a mile and a quarter.
#5 Gotyouoncamera 10/1
A great example of how a horse can improve when gelded, Gotyouoncamera was just one for five before getting the old snip snip. Since then he has won three straight including two listed stakes. The first came at a mile and a quarter where he ran a 108 speed, the second was at a mile and five sixteenths where he ran a 106 speed. He has speed but he doesn’t need to be on the lead early and is content to stalk when necessary. He’s a son of Gun Runner out of the Street Cry x Wild Again mare Wicked Streets. She was a stakes winner at a mile and a sixteenth. At that distance she also came a head short in a grade two. The furthest distance she ever ran was a mile and a quarter and that proved too long for her. Her first foal (of four) is a stakes winner by Bernardini but he is an out and out sprinter. Gun Runner obviously won the Breeders’ Cup Classic and is a young stallion in the game. Whether he adds enough stamina to this pedigree will be a big question mark.
#6 Order the Code Red 10/1
Order the Code Red entered the Bluegrass Derby on a three race win streak. The Tapit x Giant’s Causeway x Street Cry scratchbred won the Grade Three Rebel Yell at a mile and a sixteenth in March and followed that up with a strong win in the Grade One Wooden Indian (a Lock Prep) at a mile and an eighth in April. In the Rebel Yell he ran a 107 speed and he improved that to a 108 in the Wooden Indian. His running style is generally sitting not too far off the pace early on before making his bid. In the Bluegrass Derby he got shuffled farther back than is his preference and he never really got going, finishing thirteenth. He hasn’t run since but his blue x blue x blueblooded pedigree says the distance should be no problem for him. It may have been that after running two really fast races in a row Order the Code Red just bounced in the Bluegrass Derby and if that’s the case he is certainly capable of bouncing back here.
#7 General Crook 6/1
Here’s the horse with the big target on his back. Everyone will be gunning for General Crook to keep him from winning the Triple Crown. Trainer Pleasanttap has handled this colt masterfully. He’s won seven of nine starts with one second and one third. Four of those victories have come in grade one routes (including the Bluegrass Derby and the Middle Jewel). The first was the Sparkling Wine Stakes in October which propelled him to a victory in the Breeders’ Bowl Juvenile. Pleasanttap’s amazing confidence in his colt saw him give the horse four and a half months off before returning in mid-March in the Grade Two Land’s End. That saw his only route defeat where he finished third. That was his only start before the Bluegrass Derby and it was likely that good rest and prep that gave him the ability to win. In the Bluegrass Derby he was ninth early on and made a sustained bid that saw him hold off Mendo Purple by a neck with a 108 speed. Two weeks later he was farther back in the Middle Jewel but he came roaring up and won by almost two lengths with a 109 speed. So can he get the distance and will the wear and tear catch up to him? Well he’s a son of Belmont Stakes winner Union Rags out of the Bernardini x Mr. Prospector mare First Degree Bern. He’s the second End of Year Champion for First Degree Bern who was herself a champion and is well on her way to the Hall of Fame. First Degree Bern was second in the Breeders’ Bowl Juvenile Filly but blossomed at three to win the Bluegrass Oaks. She tried the New Yorker but was found wanting in the long race against males. Her three year old season saw her beat older mares in the Breeders’ Bowl Distaff. She never won a race beyond a mile and three sixteenths but she also didn’t try longer distances too often. Her first champion son was Low Fidelity, a son of Broken Vow. He won a grade one as a two year old but really blossomed at three. He was unlucky in the Triple Crown, finishing second in both the Bluegrass Derby and the New Yorker, both of which were run over off tracks. First Degree Bern also produced a grade three winner by Tale of the Cat who was good enough to run fifth in the Bluegrass Derby. Pretty amazing for a mare who has only produced six foals, including a 2020 two year old. So the question of whether General Crook has the pedigree to get the distance is a distinct yes. The wear and tear factor? Well we’ll see on Saturday.
#8 Fiercely Frosted 10/1
Grade Two Fountain of Ute winner Fiercely Frosted certainly has the pedigree to get this distance. His sire Frosted was second in the Belmont behind Triple Crown winner American Pharoah and his scratchbred backend is Dynaformer x Sadler’s Wells. He won the Fountain of Ute with an impressive 108 speed but bounced hard in his next start, the Florida Derby Lock Prep finishing tenth. That cost him a spot in the Bluegrass Derby but he ran that weekend in the Grade Two Captain Hook over this track. That race was also a mile and an eighth and he finished second with a 105 speed. His preferred running style is to sit just off the pace before making his move. There’s several runners in this race that really love to wing it on the front end and he may find himself farther back than he’s used to or else he’ll have to use his speed more than he’s used to in order to keep up. The pace factor in this race is really interesting and will have a big impact on how some of these horses are used to running.
#9 Oldmoon’s Mine 10/1
Oldmoon’s Mine is a grade two winning two year old who is four for four in sprints. Even though his record doesn’t necessarily reflect it he may just be better routing. His two lifetime best speeds have come in his last two starts. The first was a 106 when second in the Arkansas Derby, a Lock Prep. It may have been lucky for him to finish second there as a win would have propelled him to the Bluegrass Derby. Instead he got a good rest heading into the Middle Jewel where he was beaten by General Crook by just a length and three quarters. There is certainly no shame in losing to a horse as good as General Crook and he ran a 107 speed in that start. He sat midpack early and was second at the stretch call. He just couldn’t hold off the General at the end but he ran a very good race. The colt has certainly outrun his pedigree. He’s by the Louisiana stallion Mean Season, a son of the top sprinter Henny Hughes. His dam is the Mineshaft x Summer Squall mare Rainbowinthemine. He is her second foal and first stakes winner.
#10 Personable 10/1
A breakout performance in a player-bought grade one gave Personable his first stakes and graded win. That race, the Partnership, was run a day after the Lock Prep California Derby. He won by a half length with a 106 speed and it sent him into the Bluegrass Derby as a bit of a longshot. He outran his odds to finish fourth after tracking the early leaders and putting his head in front at the stretch call. He’s the only horse aside from General Crook who ran in both the Bluegrass Derby and the Middle Jewel. Personable did not do as well as that horse, he ran a poor twelfth after never getting near the lead and tiring late. His grade three winning hemare did his best running at a mile and a half and longer so he has that positive to his name. He’s a son of Mendelssohn and that hemare is by War Front x Unbridled. This is Mendelssohn’s first crop and he’s by Scat Daddy so the jury is out on whether he can get a distance runner. War Front perhaps gets a bad rap in the game for siring horses who can’t go long but in my experience with the right combination he does just as well as any sire getting a long distance runner and Unbridled certainly gives him that.
#11 Var Reaching 13/1
The only horse in this field who does not have at least a listed win to his credit is Var Reaching. Trainer Kashbarn (who won last year’s Bluegrass Derby) believes his colt will benefit from the added distance of the New Yorker and finally break through in a stakes race. The colt has been unlucky to not win a stakes race, having hit the board in five of them. In February he was second in the Grade One Dreams of Zambia behind Flavors of Memory who he meets again here. Off that big race Kashbarn entered him in the Lock Prep All Saints Derby. The late running colt never lifted his feet in that start and Kashbarn got a little greedy, running back just three weeks later in the Lock Prep Arkansas Derby where Var Reaching made a mild move to finish ninth. Kashbarn says “Var Reaching may like the longer distance and has been resting and training for this race since being ousted from the Derby.” He gets his name from his sire Var and a play on the term far reaching which perhaps is a karmic way of getting him that longer distance. He’s out of an Awesome Again x A.P. Indy mare and is her second foal. One thing I will mention is that her DDS is the great Fappiano who is so good in the game and adds class and stamina to any pedigree. Kashbarn is a great competitor and says “I do with the Best of Luck to General Crook and trainer Pleasanttap who has the extremely rare opportunity to get the Triple Crown. It is an honor to be in the same race as him in what could possibly be a historical moment in racing history.”
#12 Moland 19/1
The second foal of Uncle Mo in the race is Moland. He’s out of the Hall of Fame mare Land Slam. Land Slam was a two year old champion after winning the Breeders’ Bowl Juvenile Filly among other races. Her trainer graywolf believed strongly in his filly and ran her against males in hopes of making the Bluegrass Derby. It wasn’t to be but later in her career she proved to be a very good sprinter and did beat males at the graded level. The twenty year old mare might be said to have been a disappointment as a broodmare until her 2017 foal Greywolf’s Honor. The son of Honor Code became his dam’s first grade one winner, doing so in a sprint as a two year old. Her 2018 foal Land Boss by Street Boss also was a grade one winner, again as a sprinter. To make it three in a row is Moland who is bucking the family trend by being a grade one winning filly (!) who did it going a mile and three sixteenths and beating males while doing it. She took the Take Your Final Shot back in April where she trailed the field in last before motoring home to win by open lengths. Unfortunately she couldn’t replicate that run in the Bluegrass Derby where she was again near the back of the pack and finished seventeenth. She’s facing an uphill battle here but what a Cinderella story if she were to win or even hit the board.
#13 Arrogate’s Malibu 14/1
The other sire with two entrants in the race is Arrogate. His loss earlier this week will be a great one to the breed. When he was at his best he could run with anyone. Arrogate’s Malibu is out of the grade two winning Malibu Moon x Deputy Minister mare Malibu Moon’s Lady. Malibu Moon’s Lady was a very good three year old who won two grade twos at a mile and a sixteenth which gave her a chance to run in the Bluegrass Oaks where she finished seventh. She’s produced four foals including an unraced two year old and two of them are grade one winners. Her 2018 foal My American Lady is by American Pharoah and she has a ton of stamina. As a three year old she won back-to-back grade ones at a mile and a quarter. This year she has stretched out as far as a mile and three quarters in a grade one where she finished second. Arrogate’s Malibu finished second in the Grade One Back Up Battle in November going a mile and a sixteenth. He returned about five weeks later to win the Grade One Merry Christmas after running near the back of the pack early. He won that with a 104 speed and in his next start he ran a 102 in the Grade One Vermont Is 4 Lovers at a mile and an eighth. He lost that race by just a half length after making a sustained run. He rested until the Bluegrass Derby but came up short, finishing seventh. Perhaps he needed that race and coming back five weeks later he will be sharper.
#14 Mr. Take Charge 11/1
Mr. Take Charge exits a win in a mile and five sixteenths listed stakes four weeks ago. The scratchbred son of Take Charge Indy x Mr. Prospector x Deputy Minister has been getting better with each race this year. In January he took an allowance at a mile and an eighth with a 99 speed. He came back at the same distance to finish third in a listed with a 100 speed and jumped up to a 104 when stretched an extra furlong in another listed. His win in his most recent start saw his speed drop to a 102 but he won by almost three lengths so it is likely he was geared down towards the end. The colt likes to sit just off the pace and has been discussed the pace could be very fast early on. Take Charge Indy is a son of A.P. Indy out of Broodmare of the Year Take Charge Lady, indicating that he should produce good distance runners. Mr. Take Charge is inbred to the quality sire Deputy Minister who adds a lot of class to sim runners.
I rarely make predictions or single out any particular horse but like so many other players I would love to see a sim Triple Crown. Good luck Pleasanttap and General Crook!
Excellent job, Spin! A great read!
Great article. It’s a must watch race. Congrats to everyone with a runner.
Great write up Spinny .. I hope The General wins but I think the wear and tear mite rear it’s ugly head (even though he did back up with an amazing race last start) this race looks right up the alley for Hopkinson Flyer
Goodluck to The General hopefully he wins
Fantastic article Eliza!! This should be an incredible race. Can the General do it? I can’t wait to find out
Thanks Spin! Great read good luck to all
Thanks, great article. Good luck everyone.
GOOD LUCK GENERAL