Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Uncategorized

A Brief (sort of) History of the Bluegrass Derby – by afc

Well, so I screwed up. I apparently cannot count. I figured I would pen this thing as “The Bluegrass Derby Finally Makes Legal Age,” but alas, that was last year. This year, the Sim will celebrate the 22nd running of the Bluegrass Derby. Not the 21st. When you get old, you need counting tools. Like toes. And fingers. I’ve only got 20. Well, there’s a 21, but we’re not gonna go there. I started in the Sim in late 1999, which apparently was the first year there was a Bluegrass Derby. My, how things have changed over the years. The old vets among you will recall that there was no breeding early in the game. None. Zippo. I think that came around 2003 or 2004. Back in the old days, you pretty much had the horse pool to choose from and that was it. Of course, I may be wrong….maybe there was breeding from the start? If there was, I was blithely ignorant of its’ existence, and stumbled and bumbled through a couple years of disastrous selections from the “horse pool” and suffered through a mind numbing 73 consecutive losing starts to begin my Sim career. Oh, yeah, I was ready to quit. Until I learned I could simply get more stables! Yeah! So I did…..and got more crappy horses from the horse pool.

See, when you start, the first thing that pops to mind is, “I’m gonna win this Kentucky, errr, Bluegrass Derby thing! Definitely! If not this year, then next year! Yeah! How hard can it be? I know racing. I know pedigrees. I’m about 499 times smarter than everyone else playing the game, so how can I possibly fail?”

Mercy, mercy, mercy. How stupid. How utterly stupid. How utterly clueless. You soon find that this wonderful game has a superb method of humbling you. Repeatedly. Brutally. It beats you down with all the subtlety of a bulldozer piloted by a mad drunk. You get crushed again and again and again. Then what? Well, like most of us…..you simply come back for more, and continue on your quest. You become Captain Ahab to Mike’s version of Moby Dick. It’s a quest that won’t end, one that seems to be eternally out of your grasp. Most times, you’re miles away…..IF you get lucky, you may miss by thismuch…..but you have to be lucky in the Derby to even get thisclose. It’s that hard. Look at the superb players (all way smarter than I can ever be) who’ve missed out at the Derby. Given, he of the 29% win rate. Dixie, perhaps the best of all time. Lenny and his Evil Empire. Lots of huge swings there, and more misses. I’m missing more than a few huge names…….but they know who they are.

So, we’re all going to now take a stroll down Derby Memory Lane. It’s a fun story, with a lot of twists and turns. Some of the stuff here will be factual….some will be complete falsehoods, fantasies of my mind. I’ll allow you to try and figure out which are true and which are fake. That’s part of the fun. I may take a backhand swipe at some people. Just know if I do, it’s because I like you and I know you can take it. Finally, if I don’t insult you, don’t be insulted…..it’s just that I don’t know you, and seriously, I don’t really know if you can take it. Can you handle the truth?

1999 Derby #1! Interesting fun fact! Did you know the inaugural Bluegrass Derby was run as a LISTED STAKES RACE? Yup. It was. The Bluegrass Oaks, meanwhile, was a true Grade 1. The Derby? Bleh. A $1,000,000 listed stakes race. The race was won by PHARRUN PROSPECT (Distinctive Pro-Lyphard-In Reality). Pharrun Prospect ran a whopping 64 times in his career, and the original owner, mpm12, actually put him up in a claim race late in his career….and he found himself back in claimers once again before he was mercifully retired. 64 races? What wear and tear? The Bluegrass Derby was his 12th start (he rotted in the dreaded horse pool for his first six races before he was snapped up), and he never again won a big race on dirt. He did find limited success on turf….but 64 runs? Won’t happen today….he’d have negative speed figs by then. Interesting side note to the inaugural Derby. Apparently, there was a dreg of a fellow who went by the alias Dr. Dipper Lip, and he and one of his henchmen, aka Bentnose, went in search of one Billgulch before the race, and threatened Billgulch, accusing him of some sort of conspiracy if his horse in the race, GATLING PROSPECTOR, were to win. They threatened Billgulch with a “kneecapping” if something didn’t happen to prevent the future Horse of the Year, Gatling Prospector, from winning. You have to know Billgulch to figure this out….but in an odd twist, the Prospector’s jockey mysteriously pulled a Shoemaker and stood up in the irons a mere 16th from the wire, allowing Pharrun Prospect to lurch past him and claim the prize.

2000- DOWN THE JAZZ (Benny the Dip-Tom Rolfe-Sister’s Prince). In addition to a pedigree only a mother could love, the story of this guy is pretty damn spectacular. Never mind that he’s the second Derby winner in the first two years to be claimed, this one is better- he was dumped into a 25K MCl in his first career race. Ouuuuccchhh. That’s bad for the original owner, and an incredible stroke of luck for Derby owner fleurdelis. Down the Jazz went on to win Horse of the Year, despite losing his last ten races of the year after a follow up to the Derby in which he won the Middle Jewel Stakes. After that, he was so exhausted, he reportedly needed a feeding tube just to get stuff in his gut. Don’t believe me? Look at his incredible string of races leading up to the Derby…..his trip in Kentucy was the ninth start- OF HIS THREE YEAR OLD SEASON!. Hoo boy. Want more? You got it! What did he do in the weeks leading up to the Derby? Rest? Train? Nah. He went to freakin’ Australia to run in the 12F Sydney Derby on 4/22…then flew back to Kentucky to win the Bluegrass Derby a mere two weeks later. More? He ran in the G1 Santa Clara Derby on 4/1….then rolled back to the G2 John Wooden the very next week. Two week break, trip around the world to Sydney, then back to Glory Time.  If you’re counting, that’s 19 races- at age 3. Wow. Well, if you needed the poster boy for how much the game has changed, and how much the approach to it has changed, here he is….DOWN THE JAZZ!

2001- BUDA WITH THE SLEW (Danzig-Seattle Slew-Night Invader). I remember this guy. I think I did his Eclipse Award writeup, and he’s the first Derby winner we’ll see in the Hall of Fame. He also had a rather inauspicious start to his career, although he wasn’t claimed. He started his racing on grass, and was successful, winning the Grade 1 High Flyer Stakes at age 2, and after a third place finish in a G3 on grass, he entered the….Breeder’s Bowl Juvenile? The Juvenile? Not the Juvy Turf? Yup, precisely. Which probably never happens today, what with the point system the way it is. Anyways, first start on dirt in the Juvy, and he just crushed the field, with a speed figure 13 points greater than his career best to that point in time. Sheesh. I don’t know if this was a move of sheer brilliance, or one of those “oh, SH##” moments where he was entered in the wrong race (yes, back then it was pretty easy to screw up turf and dirt entrants). At the start of his three year old year, he briefly bounced back to grass after a couple of mediocre dirt efforts, then suddenly found his form and simply exploded, winning the Corkscrew Stakes and the Santa Clara Derby impressively before storming off to a facile Derby win. But, alas, the end was nigh…..after a gut wrenching effort to barely get up in the Middle Jewel to set up a second consecutive run at the Triple Jewel, the tank was running on empty and he was crushed like a fine powder in the New Yorker. He did bounce back to win the G2 Buckeye Derby after the

 New Yorker fiasco, but he won only one more race in a splendid career- the 8.5 furlong G2 San Valenzuela Breeder’s Bowl Stakes with a scorching 129 speed figure, which at the time, was the fastest figure ever recorded in the Sim by about a mile. And then…..he was gone. Gutsy, dual surface Grade 1 winner, oftentimes brilliant, and as mentioned previously, immortalized in the Hall of Fame.

2002- TOWER STORM (Storm Cat-Forty Niner-Tower Walk) The favorite for the Derby, he laid a beating down on this field. He took a commanding six length lead around the far turn, and waltzed home to an easy as “pye” victory, winning by 3 ½ lengths with a ridiculous 116 speed figure, a record for the Derby at the time by a wide margin.  He was denied a shot at the Triple Jewel when his rival, Unbridled Fury, who was the only horse closing in the Derby, dropped Tower Storm in the Middle Jewel with an incredible 119 figure (Tower Storm ran a 118 in defeat). This was, however, pretty much the end of the rivalry, as Unbridled Fury never again came close to his staggering Middle Jewel performance. Tower Storm, on the other hand, regrouped and continued on with another Grade 1 win in the Princess Cup at 10f, after bypassing the New Yorker with no Jewel on the line. At his dominating best, Tower Storm was a tower of power- he won the BB Juvenile by 3 ½ lengths and a Grade 1 Derby prep race by a whopping 6 ½ lengths.  He may well have been the first “bred” horse to win the Derby- his game dam Forty Nightmare produced an absolute nightmare when Tower Storm arrived. Alas, as an eligible “he-mare” it is interesting to note that Tower Storm was never bred….what might have been. One of the also rans in his Derby win? The easy as “pye” RAY OF PYE, himself a future Hall of Famer and a versatile dual surface beast who won G1 races on both grass and dirt. Perhaps more importantly, Ray of Pye introduced us all to the inimitable “LordPye” on the message board. His rants occasionally pop up to this very day. Always entertaining, too.

2003- I SEEK U (Gone West-Unfuwain-Mr. Prospector) The lone Triple Jewel winner to date, and his story is one of just not brilliance, but of a great degree of self-realization, awareness and really, kindness. I Seek U didn’t have a fast start at two- in fact, he raced only twice at age two, and began his Derby quest mired in allowance ranks, while some pig named ERUPTION was scooping up all the headlines leading into the Derby. You see, Eruption was mine, so maybe I imagine things, but after running a scorching 113 in the Movieland Futurity at age 2, I thought I had it all figured out, the Derby. WRONG WRONG WRONG! I Seek U, meanwhile, didn’t even enter a graded stakes until March, finishing second in the Felipe Alou Cap. Even a follow up win in the G1 Chicago Derby didn’t assure him a spot in the field. He was late to the party, and despite showing incredibly rapid development at 3 (he ran, in succession, figs of 99/103/107/113 leading up to the Derby), it looked like he wouldn’t make the cut….until another player, who will remain unnamed (I do remember her name, however- you figure it out) decided to keep a qualifying colt out of the Derby just to give I Seek U a shot. As it turns out, history isn’t just made- sometimes it’s given in a way- and I Seek U made the most of his chance. I Seek U was a flat out blazer. He would go to the front and dare everyone else to catch him. He did it in the Derby, by 4 ½ lengths. He did it in the Middle Jewel by 3 ½ lengths. In the Triple Jewel finale, he and one of his major rivals, SILVERWORE, the Derby runner up, put on a show for the ages in New York. The two of them went head to head early, ala Secretariat and Sham, separated by only a head for the first half of the race. Unlike the IRL stars, though, this battle didn’t end at the six furlong marker. Silverwore and I Seek U continued to trade brutal blow after brutal blow for the entire 12 furlong marathon, with I Seek U finally vanquishing his rival by a hard fought ¾ of a length. It was one of those races that makes you wish you could still watch races this far back on the viewer. A titanic struggle for the greatest of all prizes in the Sim. There was only One. And there still is only One. I Seek U, we salute U.  As does the Hall of Fame. Oh, yes…Eruption? Well, he got drubbed to the tune of about 25 lengths in the Derby, leading to the famous MB thread, “The Eruption Bounce.” Comeuppance, indeed, with about twelve shots of sewer drainage to boot. But….I will claim revenge!

2004- GRANHEE (Sakhee-El Gran Señor-Dixieland Band) Talk about an inbred freak- this guy is 3x4x4x5 to Northern Dancer. One of the oddities of the Sim, particularly in the old days, was the success of significant inbreeding. Don’t believe me? Look at the eye watering number of graded stakes winners with a pedigree of Danzig-Nijinsky II. It was like we were being overrun by five legged freaks. Despite this grass loving pedigree, Granhee ran a Grannheed total of three races on turf, with only a single show spot for his efforts, or lack thereof. His real thirst was dirt, and he ate it up. He won the G2 End of the Line Futurity at 2, and then the California Derby at 3 to secure his Derby spot. In Kentucky, Granhee held off a late charge by TERN OF THE WHEEL to take the Derby by one length, in a time that was one of the faster Derbies run. He finished fourth in the Middle Jewel to Derby also ran TUFF ENUFF, but did bounce back to win the Travellers in August. Later in the year, he demonstrated some distance versatility, taking the one mile G2 It’s All Your Fault Stakes. After that, he endured a grueling streak of 16 straight defeats, and only won a single allowance race before calling it quits. This was another Derby with a fairly weak field, as there were no Eclipse Award winners among the losers. Granhee is the lone winner for the highly regarded theatrical stables, and this prize will always be remembered. Some good insight here- he could have continued to bang his head against a grass wall, but instead took a shot at the switch, and boy did it pay off. Having said that, while a premier grass horse, Sakhee didn’t exactly disgrace himself in his lone dirt try where he lost the BC Classic to Tiznow in thrilling fashion as New York and the USA lurched back towards normalcy following the downing of the Twin Towers, the Pentagon attack and United 93.

2005- ANTICOSTI (Unbridled’s Song-Danehill-Fappiano) Hoo boy. Anticosti. Well, I could go on and on and on about MB stories pertaining to all sorts of stuff, which just kind of went to show what kind of emotions the Sim could stir among us, and suffice to say, it’s not always good. Hey, I was as guilty of MB flaming as much as anyone else, but there were shots taken at the time that were juuuuuussst a bit outside, as Bob Eucker would have said. I think the term “nerfing” also appeared around the time of Anticosti. But all of that chatter still can’t take away from ANTICOSTI’S brilliance.  His owner, stoners, has to rank in the top echelon of players, back at this time and up through today- as this is being written, I believe stoners has in one of his stables the top ranked horse in the entire Sim. It’s just been, watching him play, a study in patient handling.  Anticosti was no exception. He would sit midpack and wait to pounce. A solid but unspectacular juvenile year set him up for a white hot spring campaign up to the Derby, which saw him win all four of his graded stakes starts leading into the Derby. He won the Derby in condescending fashion, easily cruising to the lead nearing the top of the lane, and simply cantered home without anyone remotely threatening him. In his next race, he…..skipped the Middle Jewel????Really? Yup. And then, he skipped….the New Yorker? Yup again. See? Patience. But it didn’t quite work out as planned, as he contested the Princess Cup on a wet track he obviously detested, and made one of his worst career efforts. He bounced right back, though, to capture the G1 Swaps Stakes in his next start. Strangely, he tailed off dramatically after the Swaps, and never won another big race. Still, he captured four Grade 1 races as a three year old, but still didn’t win an Eclipse Award. That’s a bit befuddling. In an interesting side note, DUBAI PROSPECTOR put forth the best performance by a filly in the Derby thus far, finishing second to Anticosti. Interesting side note #2- a storm starts brewing in the fall of 2004, and it’s beginning to rear its’ head as 2005 comes to a close……they’re coming! They’re coming!

2006- VIRTUOSO (Cryptoclearance-El Prado-Fit to Fight) Well, we need a bit of digression to tell this story in anything remotely close to how it actually happened. Briefly….somebody stole somebody else’s “prize” mare in the fall of 2004 (said prize mare produced all of one stinking stakes winner). Somebody #2 got seriously pissed off at said theft, and in a fit of pique, labeled Somebody #1 “Osama Bin Laden” and swore vengeance not just on Somebody #1, but against the entire Sim for this maddening theft of what was essentially a worthless computer byte pile of dung. See what I mean? Sometimes, the Sim stirs emotions….and I never claimed that they were normal in any sort of way. Anyways, I am Somebody #2, Somebody #1 will remain unnamed, although suffice to say, he and I are very good friends to this day, so all turned out well after my little fit of rage. In short, that was the genesis of the Super Stables. Yeah, I know, the name is kind of egomaniacal and all, but you gotta understand, it was intended to be. Super was really the first big conglomerate- an originally five headed monster that eventually went down to three, and above all else, stirred more debate in the Sim than almost anything I can recall. It ranged from downright hatred to grudging acknowledgement that perhaps we were on to something. Now, look at the Derby. Stable groups of 50, 80, sometimes well over 100 stables. It’s largely a numbers game, and we decided to play it. So, by 2005, we had a boatload of good looking two year olds. Virtuoso was one of the outsiders, but all along, he looked like the one who would have the Derby distance hit him square in the forehead. After a nice warmup in the Corkscrew, he closed like a scalded dog in the Derby stretch to just run down Ermington Pegasus. Virtuoso went on to win the New Yorker convincingly, but faltered in the Middle Jewel. After that, it was pretty much pffft for Virtuoso. Meanwhile, runner up Ermington Pegasus went on to become a super horse, winning G1 after G1 on the way to a Hall of Fame career and multiple Eclipse Awards. Ermington Pegasus won the war- but Super won the battle. We set out to win a Derby. We got it.  Needed a Derby record of five entrants, but finally….the prize.

2007- ATAUN (Gone West-Sadler’s Wells-Blushing Groom) Gone West became the first Sim sire to have two Bluegrass Derby winners (there is at least one more to come, in somewhat stunning fashion) when the late blooming Ataun closed stoutly to just get up in the closest finish in Derby history, nipping runner up 20-1 shot PASSING STONE by a head, whose owner reportedly collapsed like he was indeed passing a stone at the finish. Ataun, like I Seek U before him, was still in allowance ranks at the end of his two year old season. In contrast to I Seek U, Ataun, no disrespect intended, was a bit of a plodder. His Derby figure of 101 is one of the slowest in history. Like a couple of winners before him, his final prep was a win in the Grade 1 Corkscrew, a pattern that has repeated itself multiple times, making the Corkscrew one of the most important preps for the Derby. He did hit the board in all three Triple Jewel races, finishing second in the Middle Jewel to Awesome Force, and also taking the show spot to Awesome Force’s New Yorker win. The Derby was Ataun’s final graded stakes win, although he did find future success at longer distances, finishing in the money in more than one G1 dirt route race. Never an explosive type, he would grind down the opposition. His losses to Awesome Force were not suspect, as Awesome Force went on to a career that ended in the Hall of Fame. Still- he won the Big One. Welcome to a pretty exclusive club, Ataun.

2008- KISSIN STREETCRY (Street Cry-Sadler’s Wells-Gone West)  A pattern begins to emerge with the second consecutive Derby winner with Sadler’s Wells as a dam sire, after a Derby winner with a son of Sadler’s Wells (El Prado) in the same DS slot. Around this time in the Sim, it seemed a potent pairing to toss a dirt sire in front of a long turf influence in the DS slot- you’ll see Sadler’s Wells, Danehill, Lyphard and El Prado as DS in some of the above winners. Kissin Streetcry was another bred along those lines. Kissin Streetcry was yet another slow developing type, not making his stakes debut until the initial race of his three year old season. He got a critical G2 win two starts before the Derby- without that win, he likely fails to make the field entirely. Once let loose in the Derby, he stalked the early pace of SUNSET MESA, before overtaking him at the top of the lane and cruising home an easy winner. He also took down the New Yorker in impressive fashion. He went on to a successful career afterwards, winning another two Grade 1 races and finishing in the money in a handful more G1 races. Strangely, Kissin Streetcry is still active- he was never retired, although he hasn’t seen the track in more than a decade. I know his former owner, and I think he walked away from the game a number of years ago. While Kissin Streetcry is a member of an exclusive club, he came ever so tantalizingly close to Sim immortality- the third place finisher in his Derby, FOLSOM BLUES, launched a furious stretch rally in the Middle Jewel to nail Kissin Streetcry at the wire. One half length- over a career of 30+ races, that relatively microscopic margin is all that stands between Kissin Streetcry and a Triple Jewel. Unfortunate, but….so it goes.

2009- HOT AND SPICY (Awesome Again-AP Indy-Kingmambo)  Here’s another bit of a mystery- Hot and Spicy switched barns early in his two year old season, and it wasn’t via a claiming race. So….did he really go to the auction? I have no way of knowing, but CoolK got a nice runner when this one landed with him. After a frustrating 0 for 5 start to his career, he started to take off. He quickly got a win and marched through allowance ranks, winning his first Grade 1 at the end of his two year old season. In the first year of “Derby Lock Prep” races, he won the 8.5f All Saints Derby to “lock” his spot, and then took a rather unconventional, but since much copied angle for success. His final prep was a grass allowance race. Shifting back to dirt for the Derby, Hot and Spicy defeated perhaps the deepest Derby field ever- two of the also rans won Horse of the Year awards (Jeepster, Distorted Storm) and another (Distorted Dragon) was an Eclipse Award winner. Distorted Storm eventually entered the Hall of Fame as well. Hot and Spicy lost the Middle Jewel to Jeepster (who also went on to win the New Yorker and BB Classic in a HOY campaign), but bounced back to win the G1 Clerk of Scales at 3 and the G1 Cosmopolitan Handicap at age 4. He won a third Grade 1 at 4 at a flat mile as well. He was one of the rare ones who were rock solid at a mile, but could also carry their speed to 10 furlongs. There’s not many who can do that.  Hot and Spicy joined the Sim Hall of Fame shortly after his retirement, off a total of six Grade 1 wins during his illustrious career.

2010- LUCKY’S HOWIE (Gone West-Dynaformer-Nijinksky II) Gone West gets his third Derby winner with Lucky’s Howie. The Sim, however, is now firmly in the era of the “wear and tear,” and Lucky’s Howie pays a dear, dear price. After his Derby win, he has only three restricted allowance wins for the remainder of his career. A heavily raced two year old, he hit the graded ranks hard at two, running a total of nine races at two, with a G3 win to show for it. He didn’t let up early at three, and ran five more times before the Derby, securing his spot with what would be an issue of contention in the Sim down the road- the dreaded “bought” Grade 1 race. They were, at the time, controversial, since many rightfully saw it as a way of “buying” your way into the Derby. If you spotted your race in the right spot, with as little advanced notice as possible, you could walk away with a pretty easy field. Lucky’s Howie got what he needed with a solid second in such a race. This is not a criticism of his owner- I don’t even know if he bought the race- but rules be rules, and he played within the structure of them and won. Big time. As the second longest shot in the Derby field, Lucky’s Howie carved out an excellent trip, moved to the front at the top of the lane and held off all challengers to secure his spot in Sim lore. After that, as mentioned, it was downhill- fast. Still, he’s in the club, and it doesn’t matter how you kicked the door in- it opened, and that’s all that really matters. The second place finisher, YOU SEE LA, had the distinction of being only the second filly to hit the board in the Derby to this point, and nextbonus’ charge continued to terrorize the boys for the rest of the year, winning the G1 Clerk of Scales and finishing a solid third in the Travellers Stakes on her way to an Eclipse Award.

2011- INDY STORM CAT (Indy-Forty Niner-Storm Cat) The second to secure his Derby spot with a win in the All Saints Derby lock prep. Lagging near the back of the pack, he launched a sustained rally to wear down 12.9-1 third choice and eventual New Yorker winner ERIC’S FAST, and drew off to a convincing 2 ¼ length win. And that was pretty much it for Indy Storm Cat. He had nothing to show for the rest of his career except for three allowance level wins. That said, he still joined the club, and not even Gronk can throw him out. His relatively uninspiring sire, Indy, disappeared almost as quickly. As best as I can find, Indy has sired a total of one grade 1 winner in the Sim. Wow. He chose the right G1 to win, right? In fact, YOU can have Indy right now for a mere 37 bp’s. Any takers? Bueller? Bueller? Among his Derby victims, Eric’s Fast went on to Eclipse Award glory.  To this day, Indy Storm Cat is still active. He made an appearance last year, at age 11. It did not go well……Interesting side note- there’s another oddball double- two in fact- looming on the horizon. Wait- make it three! Can you say four? MAYBE! Read on to see….or see if you can figure it out before going ahead…..

2012- RAS EL HANOUT (Tanino Gimlet-Sadler’s Wells-Forty Niner) So, several more trends….another Sadler’s Wells DS Derby winner, and another Forty Niner lurking in the pedigree (that’s the third time, in case you lost count). After a slow start to his career on turf, he switched to dirt and really woke up. He won his dirt debut in listed stakes company, and then began his three year old season with three straight graded stakes triumphs on dirt to secure his spot. With points in his corner, he had a six week break coming to Kentucky for the big day, and in a tightly close pack, while racing never more than six lengths off the lead, he leveled off and made his trademark run, collaring the leaders around the 1/8th pole and cruising home to an easy win. He finished a decent third in the Middle Jewel, and after a fourth in the New Yorker, he bounced back to take the G1 Eddie Haskell Stakes. Sadly, that was pretty much it for Ras El Hanout. He ran some nice races, with several on the board finishes in graded company at four, but never made it back to the promise he showed in the Derby. Of the also rans behind him in the Derby, SKITZOID stole the three year old Eclipse with a late charge of victories in the Travellers and the Jockey Club Guild Cup. There were two other Eclipse winners in the field in BOLTON VALLEY and STREET ETIQUETTE. Ras El Hanout was a bit of an oddball for the Super stables. He was bred “on the cheap” with the sire cost of the unproven Tanino Gimlet sitting at around 200 bp at the time. It had been six years from our first Derby victory, but it wasn’t like super  had disappeared (see Jeepster above). This was, however, the swan song for super as far as Derby winners go…..there’s a lot to that, and I will get to it (whether you care or not). Oh, yes!  The doubles! Well, the two Derby wins is obviously the first…..The others? First, with Ras’ win in the Derby,  super made it back to back year’s in the winner’s circle on Derby Day, with Lana Turner taking the 2011 Bluegrass Oaks. Double #3- the relatively unsung Tanino Gimlet also happened to sire the winner of the 2000 Guineas on this very same day. Oddball double #4? Read on….

2013- GIMLET NEAT (Tanino Gimlet-Kingmambo-Exclusive Native) Well, that’s not hard….Tanino Gimlet, whomever the hell he is/was, sires his second consecutive Derby winner. Really? Yup. His career is similar in its’ early days to Ras El Hanout- he started out, uninspiringly, on grass, made a switch to dirt late in his two year old year and kind of blew up. After a relatively horrific effort in the G2 Gary Asher, he stepped up large at 13-1 to win the Arkansas Derby lock prep. Going directly to the front in the Bluegrass Derby, Gimlet Neat held off a sustained late run by EL QUERREQUERRE to secure his place in Sim lore. In perhaps his most crushing Derby defeat, Lenny’s Evil Empire watched dishearteningly as the favored EVIL SUNRISE could only manage third. In the Middle Jewel, Gimlet Neat faded badly while KARUKAZA cruised to victory with EVIL SUNRISE second. Karukaza would then go on to capture the G1 Clerk of Scales and the G1 Japan Dirt Cup to claim three year old Eclipse honors. Karukaza is part of the given stable group, and in an odd turn, the winning jockey on Gimlet Neat in the Bluegrass Derby was none other than…..D. Givins. Something tells me he’d rather be the trainer than the cpu byte midget on the winner’s back, but take what life gives you, right? Gimlet Neat pulled a Houdini after the Derby- he never won another race, and only hit the board once. Talk about a fall from glory. That said, you have to scale the heights to suffer the fall from glory, and on one glorious day, Gimlet Neat did just that. I’m pretty sure selurnivek  wouldn’t change a thing. One other interesting side note- this is one of the few Derby runnings that did not include any Eclipse Award winners. Yeah? WHO CARES!

2014- MOUNTNOIR (Malibu Moon-Storm Cat-Mr. Prospector) The Fernando charge is another study in how much the Sim has changed over the years. Recall the first Derby winner and his 64 starts? Or Down The Jazz making the Derby his 19th career start? Well, Mountnoir ran a total of 20 times- in his entire career. At least he made the most of it. He has one- count ‘em, ONE- Grade 1 win in his career. He made his way to the Derby on the strength of a couple of G3 wins and a G1 third place finish, and then chose the perfect time to run the race of his life on the first Saturday of May. In doing so, he held off the late charge of eventual Hall of Famer and six time G1 winner I WON’T LOOK BACK in deep stretch. Talk about perfect timing. As quickly as he arrived, Mountnoir was gone. He was crushed in the Middle Jewel, and never once even hit the board in any race. Hey, go to stud. You earned your break. Enjoy it, Mountnoir.

2015- SWINGING BIG SHAFT (Mineshaft-Distorted Humor-Giant’s Causeway) That’s quite a name, yes? Mtk swung his big shaft around like a pro here, guiding him to a Derby win. Hard to believe, but he looked like Limp Little Shaft early in his career and entered his three year old season as a maiden.  The maiden label disappeared in his first start as a three year old, and he proceeded to win an NW2L allowance before jumping directly into graded stakes ranks. He did not discredit himself, finishing a promising second in the G2 The Hustlin’ Hoosier, dropping a nail biter in the final jumps. He then had the good fortune of finding a sponsored G1 in early April, and after changing his usual front running tactics to more of a closer type style, he emerged on top and qualified for the Derby. I do think he’s the only one who’s entered his three year old season as a maiden to make the Derby, much less win it. I could be wrong, but….still, maiden to Derby winner over the course of five starts is pretty damn salty. His Triple Jewel dreams ended with a dismal fourth in the Maryland muck two weeks later, but he still remained a force at three, running solid, if losing, efforts, including a hearbreaking ½ length loss in the Travellers while firing a career best 118 figure. He had limited success at age four, winning the G2 Bluegrass Cup Classic, before running out of steam and ending his career with a series of beatings in allowance races. Perhaps Viagra may have helped….or not. Around this time, purses were adjusted to reflect the current state of times, and I do believe that Swinging Big Shaft is the second Derby winner to surpass the $5 million mark in earnings, joining only Triple Jewel winner I Seek U in this exclusive group at this point in Sim history. The Sim was spared a third Super Derby win when runner up BELT LINE ROAD and his Silky Sullivan style late charge from dead last fell short by a length and a half….oh, what could have been……

2016- PAPA’S GHOST TED (Papa Clem-Ghostzapper-Victory Gallop) Perhaps the most shocking Derby winner of all time, but I’m sure the owner of the T syndicate, aka HijackedTed, really doesn’t give a damn. Frankly, I’m a bit stunned he even made the Derby field, especially considering the field had only 19 colts, with the Eclipse winning filly SWAPSCO KITTY taking a slot in the starting gate. Anyways, check this out- Papa’s Ghost Ted sports a career record of 46-4-5-7. That’s right. Four wins. His sire, Papa Clem, has one graded winner in his entire Sim sire career. That one graded winner, right here, sports all of one graded stakes win. Timing? Hell, yeah. He somehow got into the Derby with only one listed stakes wins, and a couple of thirds in G1 Derby prep races. How? HOW???? I dunno. This all happened during my sort of self imposed exile from the Sim for a few years…..the game had switched to the beta version by this time, and I just never really got it, and I suppose I sort of missed the breeding clickfest ( you all remember the clickfest- you’d load up three windows of possible breedings, see that it opened “within an hour of x o’clock” and then spend that hour or less madly clicking away until your fingertips blistered), so I was totally out of touch….anyways, I probably would have vomited all over myself if someone suggested the possibility of a Papa win in the Derby, so perhaps the exile was a good thing. At any rate, Papa’s Ghost Ted somehow pulled it off with a late rally while second choice Swapsco Kitty, who had never been off the board to that point and had already beaten the boys in G1 company, could only manage fifth. Well, in the long run, it doesn’t really matter much that this was to be the final win of Papa Ghost Ted’s otherwise checkered career, does it? He didn’t just lose a lot afterwards- he often lost in stupefying fashion, dropping the last six races of his three year old season by a nearly 70 combined lengths. He continued to suck dirt for the rest of his days, absorbing nearly 40 length drubbings on more than one occasion. Unreal. But it just goes to show, it doesn’t matter. He won the Derby. Would anyone here refuse to take Papa’s Ghost Ted in their barn on the first Saturday of May 2016? Didn’t think so.

2017- CARL’S SHAMELESS (Shamardal-Unbridled-AP Indy) Here begins the tale of perhaps the most ungodly feat the Sim has ever seen, and perhaps will ever see. After a FTO win in a turf sprint at two, the career of Carl’s Shameless sort of cratered, as he failed to clear NW2L allowance level on the grass. Ho hum. Just another bum. Wrong. Late in his two year old year, punter34 tried the switcharoo to dirt, and boy, did it pay off. His speed figs jumped significantly, as he busted through NW2L conditions in his first try. Working methodically through alw conditions, he graduated to graded stakes ranks in March, finishing an inspiring third in the G2 The Land’s End. With one final shot to make the Derby field, Carl’s Shameless fired a warning shot to all comers with a wire to wire job in the G1 California Derby lock prep. When the clouds opened on Derby Day, leading to a rare off track for the big race, it was anyone’s guess as to how their horses would react. Regardless, it didn’t bother Carl’s Shameless one bit, as he bounded out to the front as soon as the gate popped open, and never relinquished the lead. He just merrily cruised around the track, clean as a whistle while everyone else got slopped with mud. Carl’s Shameless failed to win another race at age 3, and his downfall was never more obvious than the trouncing he absorbed in the G1 Middle Jewel. The field was notable for three Eclipse winners, including Carl’s Shameless himself, runner up LOW FIDELITY and the reigning two year old champ, WARRIOR’S DANZ TED.  While he managed a solid second in the G1 Travellers, Carl’s Shameless never came close to regaining the form he showed in the Derby, as he won only three allowance races for the rest of his career. His drop off in form isn’t shocking….look at past winners who followed the same dubious path. But for one glorious day, it just did not matter. Speaking of which, there’s another glorious day coming, much sooner than anyone would expect……the tale continues to a shocking finish.

2018- GODBLESS THIS MESS (Distorted Humor-Storm Cat-Danzig) This guy got off to a decent start at two, winning four of his first six races, including a listed stakes race while never finishing worse than second, all on the main track. He took a pounding in his first try at graded company in the Grade 1 Movieland Futurity to close out his juvenile season, finishing a disappointing ninth as the close up third choice. Undeterred, he captured another listed stakes in his second start at 3, and then improved significantly while finishing second in the G1 Florida Derby lock prep, which garnered him enough points to make the Derby field. Sent off at 13.4-1 in Kentucky, he closed stoutly in a Derby where most of the front runners simply fell apart after a mile. Snaring the lead in mid-stretch, he held off a final gallant run from two time Eclipse Award winner GOLD WAR FRONT to take home the Derby roses. Despite decent fourth place finishes in the Middle Jewel and Travellers, Godbless This Mess never saw a win again on the main track, and now calls the grass his home, albeit with middling success. Meanwhile, runner up Gold War Front has had a fantastic career, with victories in the Travellers, Glenn Kegasus Tradition Killer and the Sand Castle Classic and is just shy of $10 million in career earnings. But this isn’t about him- it’s about Godbless This Mess, who famously became the second Derby winner in a row for punter34. Not only that, but Godbless This Mess calls barn plugger03 home, and right next to him, for a brief time, was 2017 Derby winner Carl’s Shameless. Good grief. Back to back Derby wins? Wow. From the SAME STABLE??? Holy crap. A feat that will likely never be duplicated again. Of course, I’m sure punter34 planned it this way. Just ask him. I’m so sure……and just to top it all off, Godbless This Mess is the only Derby winner to be produced from a Hall of Fame mare, MAGPIE’S CAT, who made the Hall strictly off her broodmare career. Just a great story all around.

2019- GIANT’S KASH (Giant’s Causeway-War Front-AP Indy) Finally, we’re reaching the end. I’ll bet you’re tired. I am. We’ll finish up with a horse who put forth one of the most dominating three year old seasons since the days of I Seek U. Giant’s Kash didn’t particularly stand out at age 2- by the end of that year, he was still contesting sprint distances, despite a FTO maiden win at a flat mile. He started his 3 yo campaign with a couple of listed stakes wins, and then secured his Derby slot with a solid second in the 9f G1 Florida Derby, where he closed with a rush to miss the top spot by a rapidly diminishing ¼ length. In Kentucky, he sat well back in the field before launching a bid around the far turn. Nabbing the lead in the stretch, he held off a strong closing run from two year old Champion, INTO BEING NICE, who closed from dead last, passing everyone but Giant’s Kash. After faltering in the Middle Jewel on a sloppy track, Giant’s Kash took a bit of a breather before taking the G1 Eddie Haskell Stakes, G1 Travellers and the G1 Breeder’s Bowl Classic.  He ended his season with a fifth in the G1 Japan Classic, but he had already done enough to secure Horse of the Year honors by that time. He continues to be a force to be reckoned with, and though he has yet to win at age four, his most recent start saw him just missing with his trademark late run in the Sand Castle Classic, finishing third by a rapidly diminishing ¾ of a length. He looks to have a lot more in the tank, and he’s but two G1 wins from securing a spot in the Hall of Fame. Time will tell for Giant’s Kash, but his time for fame already arrived with his Derby win.

So, that’s about it. It’s been a fun journey for all the winners, and a source of frustration for the near misses and bombing favorites. But it’s the Derby, and with the spring brings renewed hope all over again. Given is loaded up this year, Lenny is Lenny, mtk is back, and a host of others again go for the big prize on Saturday. Good luck to all. It’s a win you’ll never forget, if you manage to get it. Personally, it’s been a great ride, and the two Derby wins stick out boldly as a career highlight, one I’d never get without my super partners. So, thanks, topicount and fatattack,  and finally….this is for you, JC, aka whirlwind, bentnose, Dr. Dipper Lip, or whatever part you’re playing up above now. Miss you, man. We’ll meet again……never say never.

3 thoughts on “A Brief (sort of) History of the Bluegrass Derby – by afc”

Leave a Reply