My Favorite Belmonts
I went to the Belmont Stakes every year for a long time. It was a family tradition. I’ve seen some great runs and great horses but the most memorable races were a bit more quirky. I thought I’d share the three most memorable Belmonts for fun.
# 3 2004 – Birdstone Defeats Smarty Jones

With all the Triple Crown attempts I saw in person there were horses I liked and horses I didn’t trying to nab the Crown. I truly believed that with the long drought between Affirmed and well every year that passed by we would be rewarded with a superhorse the way we got Secretariat twenty five years after Citation. I think I was proven correct with American Pharoah who was simply awesome but that is another story. At some point during the drought I changed my mind and decided to root for any horse that had a chance at taking it.
I didn’t initially like Smarty Jones. I don’t know why he just didn’t do it for me. But after he took the Derby and Preakness I was on board. I even went to see him in his public workout in Philadelphia where thousands thronged the rail to get a glimpse of the hometown hero. (Photo above).
I also thought he was a good horse in a mediocre crop, giving him a great chance at victory. So when the Belmont Stakes came around I knew I wanted to be at the finish line to photograph history in the making. I woke up at 4:30 in the morning to drive to Belmont to be the first car in line to get into the parking lot. I was one of the first through the turnstiles and I flat out ran to my spot while my boyfriend parked the car and lugged in our gear. It was a long day of waiting to say the least. 120,000 people jammed into the grandstand that day which was the largest crowd by far ever to grace Belmont Park. (Since then the Stakes has been limited to 100,000 attendees). It was also the last year that NYRA allowed patrons to bring their own booze on Stakes Day which I think was a great decision but I won’t get into why.
Standing at the rail right in front of the finish line I was trapped by the time the races started. No bathroom breaks, no souvenir shopping, nothing. Luckily we had folding chairs and weren’t on our feet all day. The crowd was raucous as the horses exited the tunnel from the paddock and as they came to the starting gate. The Belmont starts just before the finish line so the gate is right in front of the crowd. Smarty ended up on the lead early on in the race and was pressed through quick fractions in what were considered controversial rides by two other jockeys. But as he entered the far turn jockey Stewart Elliot let him go and he put his rivals away, drawing out to a big lead. Elliot was perhaps not as familiar with the Belmont track as he should have been – a move on the turn at a smaller track is often a wise decision but at Belmont if you move entering the turn you still have a half mile to go before the finish line.
Still with a clear lead the grandstand rocked with 120,000 people believing they were witnessing history. The ground was shaking it was so loud. Birdstone was closing in on Smarty Jones but people were sill cheering their hero home. Until Birdstone passed Smarty. Then the roar became utter silence. It was surreal. You could hear the hoofbeats of the horses as they crossed the finish line with Birdstone in front. Very few of us cheered as he was led into the winner’s circle but as a fan of both Nick Zito and Mary Lou Whitney and racing in general I gave him a good ovation. It wasn’t his fault that he spoiled the show people wanted. He ran a great race and his connections were gracious in acknowledging that they were proud of their horse while also aware that they disappointed so many fans. I believe it was Zito’s first Belmont Stakes victory and as a native New Yorker it was especially poignant to him.
I will never forget that moment when cacophony turned into utter silence. That eerie feeling will always be a part of me.
#2 2008 Da’ Tara Stuns

So surprisingly in 2008 I was again not a fan of the Triple Crown hopeful Big Brown. I didn’t like his ownership group (turns out for good reason) and they just rubbed me the wrong way. Trainer Richard Dutrow was a character unto himself and another controversial person which I won’t get into at this time. Nevertheless the horse had talent there was no doubt. He became the first horse to win the Kentucky Derby from the 20 hole and he won it smartly. His Preakness was even better. Another similarity to 2004 was that the crop he raced against was not the strongest. Although his pedigree was suspect for the distance he seemed a very strong candidate to break the drought.
My son was a huge fan of Big Brown so of course we had to go to the race. He was certain it was going to happen. At that point in time he was too young to do the wake up early and stand at the rail all day thing. I think by that time NYRA had banned folding chairs on the apron so it would have been a really long day. So we purchased tickets in the grandstand at the top of the stretch and were able to move around and buy souvenirs and check out the paddock, etc. Most of the people around us were not racing regulars and many were at the track for the very first time. My group of four (my son, husband and father) were answering a lot of questions all day. It was actually kind of fun introducing so many people to the sport instead of being surrounded by the regulars down at the rail. Overall it was a much more relaxed day than 2004.
I have to insert a quick explanation of my father. He is the person who got me interested in horse racing in the first place. I was a horse crazy kid who was desperate to take riding lessons but lived in the city and for various reasons it was not feasible to get me to a stable every week to be around horses. But every day in the newspaper there were entries and results and occasionally stories about horses racing in New York and across the country. (Remember those days?). There were also races on tv sometimes! So I lived my horse fantasies vicariously through these medium. My father was not a huge fan of the sport but he would bet on the big days at our local OTB. Now my father never plays the favorites. It is anathema to him. He would rather go home without a winning ticket than one that pays only small dividends. It’s longshots or nothing for him. He is also the person who took me to the Belmont Stakes for many years when I was too young to drive. We had a tradition of going to our local deli and grabbing sandwiches – Italian combo for me and cheeseburger sub for him and then heading to the track for a day of fun.
As we got older my father only occasionally attended the races with me but when we were buying tickets in 2008 he said to count him in. So there we were, the four of us waiting to see Big Brown bury the competition. Most of the people around us had $2 souvenir tickets and little else riding on the race but dreams of seeing history. The race turned out to be anti-climactic. Longshot Da’ Tara (another Nick Zito trainee) lead the field on a merry chase around the Belmont oval while Big Brown never factored and was pulled up in the stretch. There were no great cheers from the crowd, only perplexed looks and disappointment. It was hushed all around us until I saw the results – longshot after longshot after longshot – all on my father’s trifecta ticket. I started screaming at the top of my lungs “POPO WON! POPO WON!”. Popo being what my son had called his grandfather since he was a baby. All the newbies were looking at me like I was crazy and my father had a shocked look on his face. But boy was it a fun day!

#1 1998 – Real Quiet and Victory Gallop
This may be my favorite racetrack memory of them all, not just for the Belmont Stakes. I didn’t have a camera then so I apologize for no picture. Before the hype of Triple Crown chance after Triple Crown chance the Belmont Stakes was a fairly relaxed day at the races. On a busy Stakes day maybe 40,000 people would be in attendance. If you’ve ever been to Belmont Park you know that that’s a manageable crowd to be in. The place is huge. Heck it held 120,000 in 2004 so you have to imagine the size of the grandstand, apron and the backyard picnic area. With a small crowd like that you could walk around all you like, even watch the horses in the paddock and then run to the apron to catch the early races at the rail.
That year I watched most of the races by the tunnel where the horses emerged from the paddock and headed out to the track which is also adjacent to the winner’s circle. While of course I wanted to see the Belmont with Real Quiet going for the Triple Crown against his arch nemesis Victory Gallop I was also really excited to see another three year old of whom I was a huge fan – Coronado’s Quest. Coronado’s Quest was a headcase and trainer Shug McGauhey didn’t think he could handle the craziness of a Kentucky Derby crowd in spite of a win in the Wood Memorial. He also thought the mile and a half of the Belmont might be too much for the horse after not running in the Triple Crown races so he entered him in the Riva Ridge on the undercard. As I stood at the gap I began a conversation with a professional photographer from the New York Times. She was specifically assigned to get photos of Coronado’s Quest although she did not cover racing as her beat. I told her that he was going to be the first horse out of the tunnel and that he would not be in the post parade with the other horses, rather he would be turned loose right in front of us and run in the opposite direction of the rest of the horses. She thanked me profusely after the race so I assume she got her shot.
But I digress. As the Belmont edged closer and closer I stopped wandering around and kept my spot by the tunnel. The crowd began to linger there as well and I didn’t want to miss a thing. On my left was a girl younger than I was. She may have been ten or twelve and she was in love with Real Quiet. She had been introduced to racing the year before when Silver Charm won the Derby and Preakness before falling just short in the Belmont behind Touch Gold. Of course Silver Charm’s trainer was Bob Baffert who also trained Real Quiet so she was instantly attracted to him. She also loved that he was nicknamed “The Fish” because he was so narrow as a young horse. She reminded me a lot of myself when I was her age. She was chatting non-stop, mostly with the curmudgeonly racetracker on my right. He was gruff with her saying that all his money was on Victory Gallop who had been closing on Real Quiet in both the Derby and Preakness and that the distance of the Belmont was going to give him enough ground to get by his rival. The difference between the two was striking – she was in love with the romance of the sport, he was in love with the gambling. They bantered back and forth and while he was much older and what many would consider a typical New York gambler he was not overly demeaning with her.
Overall I was ambivalent about the results of this race. It was before I decided to fully support all Triple Crown hopefuls and I wasn’t crazy about Real Quiet but I didn’t dislike him either. I was more excited for the race just for the sheer fun of it. Real Quiet had natural early speed but wasn’t a front runner. Victory Gallop had no early speed and was near the back of the pack for all his races. Much like Smarty Jones in 2004 Real Quiet took the lead around the far turn. He entered the stretch about four lengths in front of the fast closing Victory Gallop. With a furlong to go Real Quiet was desperately trying to hold on as Victory Gallop closed the gap with every stride. To my left the little girl was imploring her hero to hold on. To my right the man with all his money on Victory Gallop was shaking his program like he was whipping his horse down to the wire. It was the perfect encapsulation of everything that’s great with the sport. The two horses hit the wire together and it seemed like forever for the stewards to get the photo results up. Everyone was quiet waiting for the final results to light up the tote board. Of course Victory Gallop got his nose down just in front of Real Quiet’s and the man next to me cried out “I knew it!” while the girl was bravely trying to hold back tears.
When I think back on that race I often wonder if that girl was so brokenhearted she gave up on racing or the taste of the racetrack hooked her for life. Maybe she even grew up to be a curmudgeonly gambler. I hope it was the latter.
LOVE LOVE LOVE the picture of the money winners! I have only been to two Belmonts live. The first was High Echelon and the other was Seattle Slew. What a day!
My only Belmont Stakes witnessing was 1999. I had my Derby pick (finished 7th, as I recall) to rebound. I got a good look at the field as they emerged from the tunnel on the way to the track. From my position in the grandstand, I got several glimpses of the race action (Silverbulletday streaking to the lead with Charismatic) but it was in this strange stop/start kind of fashion. Luckily, I had spent far too many years of my life as a movie theater usher and I was pretty good at piecing together plots with many gaps of information. During the long stretch run, I knew I had a chance but then a blank spot from my vista. Then, just before the line a clearing, and, yes (Yes!), Lemon Drop Kid had won. I jumped up and backwards (about five feet of each it seemed–the crowd must have parted as if for someone whom they hated were stage diving) in celebration, only finding out later what had transpired with Charismatic and that Mott’s horse, Vision and Verse at 55/1, had blown up my trifecta ticket of Lemon Drop Kid–Charismatic–Best of Luck.
I’ve never seen live racing East of Santa Anita and probably never will due to my disenchantment with the way they’re running the sport everywhere in America, but up thru last year I saw every Triple Crown race for 50 years straight via the TV. (the Breeders Cup of last year was the first big American TV racing event I skipped since I got interested in 1970)
My fave will always be Secretariat as the picture of perfection, winning by 31 in 1973.
2nd fave has to be American Pharoah breaking the 37-year Triple Crown draught in 2015,
I was at Big Browns Belmont! I was general admission. My husband and I were dressed too well for it. It was HOT. We bought a beer each and then I had to use the bathroom. Lo and behold the general admission bathrooms weren’t working and there was a line at least 30 ladies deep for the one bathroom that was. We high tailed it to my parents house 20 minutes away and watched on tv.
I felt the same about Big Brown and his connections.
My first in-person Belmont was last year, so what can I say? My favorite Preakness visit was the year the lovely Ms. Fastnfirm and I won Turfside Terrace tickets. There was an injured jockey’s fund fundraiser contest where you had to go to five bars where jockeys were bartending on five consecutive nights. First one was in our neighborhood, and max eight people were there. I said, “we can win this.” We did!
1982 Conquistador Cielo crushed the Met Mile by 7 lengths, and came back 6 days later to romp in the Belmont in the slop. That was certainly memorable for me.
I didn’t watch this race in person but watched on live TV and purely from a betting perspective my favorite Belmont was 2016. I was all over Destin (he was also my derby horse) and I was pretty confident he was going to win this one. I’ll never forget my wife, and in-laws laughing at me as I yelled “Where the hell is the wire?!?” as Creator was coming on. Ultimately Creator would beat Destin by a nose killing my win bet but I had wheeled Destin in both spots of the exacta and had a nice pay day off the race anyways. Still one of my favorite races to watch.
My favorites of the Belmont are actually two that I attended First was the 1969 Edition when Arts and Letters stopped Majestic Prince’s chane to win the Triple Crown. I had A&L in the first two legs and he couldn’t get past MP. I was only 25 but scraped up a $500 win bet and A&L won for me in the Belmont. For a 25 yo at that time this was a huge score. What made this amazing was that A&L had run the Derby on May 5th, the Preakness on May 15th, and won the Metropolitan on May 30th just a week before the Belmont. Imagine a horse today being asked to run 4 major races in 5 weeks. People would think the trainer was crazy.
A close second all time favorite that I attended was Secretariat’s amazing 25 length win in 1973. Big Red just toyed with his protagonist – Sham, and the rest of the field. Amazingly he was hand ridden by Ron Turcotte who just sat chill and enjoyed the trip. Might have been the most amazing race I ever saw until Zenyatta came from out of the clouds onto the horse racing landscape.
Finally, I have to put in a couple words for American Pharoah in 2015 and Justify in 2018, even though I wasn’t there. AP broke the long streak of non-Triple Crown winners and that was a thrill I will always cherish. As far as Justify goes, all I can say is that what Bob Baffert did as a trainer in getting this 3yo from an unraced 3yo on 2/17/18 to a Triple Crown winner in 4 months was a training achievement that personally I believe was the best ever.
My favorite was Rags to Riches over Curlin. Bad break for Rags but she hung in there and in the stretch two great horses went head to head the whole what neither giving an inch. Amazing call also. It would take too much out of Rags and she wouldn’t race again but the win is immortal.
The Birdstone over Smarty call was one of the saddest I’ve ever heard. Everyone was so disappointed!
Was there every year from 1987 through 2004 (only missed Thunder Gulch in ’95).
My fave has to be Easy Goer finally getting by Sunday Silence to thwart a Triple Crown.
Saw eight (I think) of those Triple Crown disappointments.