2020 Freshman Sire Profile – Catholic Boy
Catholic Boy
More Than Ready – Song of Bernadette, Bernardini
Enters Stud 2020 For a Fee of $25,000 at Claiborne Farm
RACE RECORD
Catholic Boy had an interesting career. He was a grade one winner on both dirt and turf which is in itself quite a feat but it also seemed to give his connections heart burn trying to decide which surface to race him on. He was a graded stakes winner over three seasons of racing and beat some quality horses in each year. At two he broke his maiden on the turf and took the Grade Three With Anticipation Stakes, also on the grass. He switched to the dirt late in the year and won the Grade Two Remsen Stakes at Aqueduct, a mile and an eighth race that has historically been a good springboard to the Triple Crown races. In that race he defeated Avery Island who had come off a commanding win in the Grade Three Nashua.
As a three year old Catholic Boy started his career on the Triple Crown trail. He ran a game second to Flameway in the Grade Three Sam F. Davis but after one more unsuccessful run on dirt he switched back to the grass where he won two impressive races at Belmont Park – the Pennine Ridge (G3) and the Belmont Invitational (G1). What was so impressive about his scores was that he took the lead in the stretch of both starts before being passed by the very nice colt Analyze It and then rerallying for the wins. The Belmont Invitational was run at a mile and a quarter and the ease of Catholic Boy’s win convinced his connections to send him to Saratoga for a tilt at the Grade One Travers Stakes. The field was a stacked one, featuring Champion Two Year Old Good Magic, Belmont Stakes (G1) second Gronkowski, Wood Memorial (G2) winner Vino Rosso and the highly regarded Mendelssohn (another grade one winner). Catholic Boy came away a winner, this time taking the lead in the stretch and drawing away from Mendelssohn. Catholic Boy finished out his season unplaced in the Breeders’ Cup Classic.
His four year old season was an abbreviated one. He started with a win in the Dixie Stakes (G2) where he had to bull his way between horses and showed tremendous resolve to take the win. It looked like an exciting start to the season but he made only two more starts. He was second in the Grade Two Suburban behind Preservationist in July and then was off until October when he was unplaced in the Knickerbocker (G2) what was to be his final start.
PEDIGREE
Catholic Boy is a son of international leading sire More Than Ready. More Than Ready was a crack sprinter by Southern Halo who was game enough to finish fourth in the 2000 Kentucky Derby. He is one of the few tail-male descendants of the great Halo still standing in the United States. Halo of course sired Japan’s super sire Sunday Silence but he has had trouble finding a foothold in the US. More Than Ready has also made his bones in another country – in addition to being a strong sire in the US he has shuttled to Australia for his entire career and is a leading sire there as well. Interestingly he is the leading sire of Breeders’ Cup winners with seven individual winners. His Breeders’ Cup winners have won on turf and dirt and with older horses as well as two year olds although the longest distance his sons and daughters have won on the big day is a mile. As Catholic Boy shows he can get longer distance runners with some of his best distance horses coming in Australia. Only Danehill, Galileo and Sadler’s Wells have sired more black type winners than More Than Ready who has 199 currently including 28 grade/group one winners.
One reason why More Than Ready has done so well in Australia is that he is an ideal outcross for Danehill mares. Group one winners Prized Icon, Dreamaway, Benicio and Perfectly Ready are all out of Danehill mares. Champion More Joyous’ second dam is by Danehill. Interestingly Uni, More Than Ready’s 2019 Breeders’ Cup Mile winner is out of a mare by Dansili, a son of Danehill. More Than Ready’s best son at stud Sebring is out of a Flying Spur mare, Flying Spur being another son of Danehill.
In the United States More Than Ready has done well when bred to mares who carry Mr. Prospector in their backgrounds. More Than Ready is out of a mare by Mr. Prospector’s son Woodman. Catholic Boy himself is inbred 4×4 to Mr. Prospector as his second dam is Seeking the Gold, a son of Mr. Prospector. Two of More Than Ready’s best runners, grade one winners Rushing Fall and Verazano have Mr. Prospector as the sire of their second dams.
Catholic Boy’s female family is solid but not too impressive. His dam Song of Bernadette did not win a race and from six foals of racing age only two made it to the track. Second dam Winner’s Edge was grade three placed as a runner but did not pass on her ability to her foals. Only one of her nine winning offspring won a listed stakes race and that was Return to Paradise by El Prado. Two foals by Deputy Minister earned black type in their careers. On the plus side Bernardini is an emerging broodmare sire (not surprising considering that when he retired to stud he was supported by some of the best broodmares available).
IN THE SIM
In the game More Than Ready gets 12.5% stakes winners and 3.2% graded winners. His progeny lean strongly towards dirt and while his progeny do better at sprints they can also be solid route runners. He has sired three champions and seventeen grade one winners. More Than Ready’s three champion sons have Unbridled’s Song (2) and Smart Strike at DS and he seems to have a strong affinity for Unbridled’s Song in general. Both sires are descendants of Mr. Prospector and that sire’s sons make up a good number of More Than Ready’s successes. Interestingly Danehill has only been represented as DS by one grade one winner by More Than Ready but his sire Danzig is represented by two. Another sire who crosses well with More Than Ready is Deputy Minister.
More Than Ready’s best son at stud Sebring has also done well in the game. He is the sire of sim legend Spiced Turtle as well as two other grade one winners. Overall he gets 8.4% stakes winners and 1.6% graded winners. Spiced Turtle is out of a Sadlers’ Wells mare but he has crossed well with Dubai Millenium and Fastnet Rock (by Danehill) mares as well.
BREEDING RECOMMENDATIONS
Catholic Boy is inbred 4×5 to Northern Dancer which means that the fifth generation cross will fall off a sim pedigree, making him ideal for mares who carry one or more crosses to that stallion. Daughters and granddaughters of Danehill and other Danzig-line stallions should be strongly considered. Another Northern Dancer line that might be useful is Deputy Minister, as he has done well with More Than Ready in the sim and with Catholic Boy’s real life female family. One option might be mares by Curlin, a son of Smart Strike out of a Deputy Minister mare. That would add a third cross of Mr. Prospector to the pedigree but it would be an interesting experiment. As More Than Ready has crossed so well with Unbridled’s Song in the game mares by him should be considered as well.