A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the BTB
Or…Come with Donny B. down the rabbit hole of internet thoroughbred obscurity
Full Disclosure: I’ve been inspired by all the fantastic articles appearing in the BTB of late. In particular, I enjoy the Promising Sires series by GCLIFFO, the Freshman Sire profiles by SPINROUND, weekly ESR race previews from TROTTER and the occasional epic masterpiece by ITCH. Throw in your special reports and your weekly beats from a growing cast of new contributors (too many to name), and we can make the argument that we’re living in the next ‘golden age’ of fake horse journalism.
The horses are fake, not the journalism.
Stuck at home on a forced day off from work – “Keep your contagious *** away from us”, they said – I could not let this abundance of digital goodness go unchecked.
I sat down to write an article that would do the opposite of what was already out there, either giving bad advice or pointing out stallions who were expected to be great but are stinking up the joint.
Some would call it a manifestation of my ‘contrarian nature’, perhaps a natural sarcastic leaning to which I am inclined. Others might say I am ‘a dick’. Tomato, tomatillo.
The thing is, when I started doing my ‘research’, I found I am as guilty as anyone with my flagrant use of stallions that have no business being in the pantheon of ‘useful’ progenitors, even if they are just fake horses. So instead of parodying the great work of you industrious and talented BTB contributors, I’m taking this a different route.
Enjoy?
WICKED RICH
Wicked Rich is a (typically) 10- point stallion standing in the ultra-competitive Simulated New York region. It is my opinion that NY bred stallion fees are inflated in our wonderful game, due to the intense intraresidency competition for NY breds, as well as the abundance of player-bought statebred races that come with the territory. Add to that the annual prestigious and now legendary CVBEAR series of championship races, and you get a scenario where NY breds of modest means cost more to breed than some of their Kentucky counterparts. It is a logical consequence of the supply-and-demand model of the game. But back to Wicked Rich.
Wicked Rich (Yes It’s True x Affirmed x Tom Rolfe) is listed as a Turf Route sire, despite typical expectations for a grandson of Is It True (dirt sprint) and son of Yes It’s True (dirt sprint). He’s been lightly used in the game, having 16 winners from 25 foals over a five-year period – that’s 5 foals per year. Not quite “Dirty Dozen” neglected sires-territory, but an outlier nonetheless. Of those 25 foals, only 3 have earned $50k, led by the definitely turf-bred
WICKED CLIFFS , stakes-placed at 2 despite never racing in New York. Wicked Rich’s top earner is my homebred SIMULATED REALISM . She has been useful in the NY bred ranks but is not stakes quality & went unclaimed for $15000 only 4 starts back. I also have TWO CHICKS who is looking very promising, but admittedly comes from a family of overachieving turf runners.
WICKED RICH had been bred to mostly crap, let’s be honest, so the true measure of what he can do is still up for debate. I found him by scouring the dregs for cheap NY options. But how come I’ve never heard of this sire before?
The horse WICKED RICH was a $120,000 Keeneland yearling in 2007, subsequently an unsuccessful 2yo pinhook attempt when he was a $150,000 RNA (reserve not attained) the following July. The initial attraction seems to be in his pedigree; he is the second foal of a full-sister to THE TIN MAN, winner of the Arlington Million (2000m turf) and three other G1’s on the grass http://apps.keeneland.com/sales/Sep07/pdfs/1993.pdf . Perhaps Yes It’s True was an odd choice of sire for this family, but now we understand the turf inclination in the game. He was initially campaigned by someone named Seth Benzel, then later with Ken McPeek under the same ownership group. He broke his maiden and won a first level allowance, both going long on turf at Churchill, and quickly fizzled out – 9 starts, 2 wins, one third, $70,980. (Statistics compiled from Equibase.com and Keeneland.com)
But how did he end up as a New York stallion?
BloodHorse’s Stallion register indicates that he entered stud in 2014, and their latest entry has him offered at $2,500 Live Foal, Buckridge Farm, NY for the year 2017. But when you dig deeper, other threads emerge. I use the same outfits ‘mares bred’ reports to see how popular / unpopular certain stallions are to commercial breeders… so without paying actual money to generate a report of all a stallion’s runners, I can find out how many mares they’ve covered, retroactively.
https://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-racing/thoroughbred-breeding/mares-bred/2017
Hmmm. 2017, none reported. That’s not to say he wasn’t breeding, but no mares reported him as the covering sire to the Jockey Club.
2016, same.
2015, here we go. Wicked Rich was reported breeding 3 mares… in the state of South Carolina.
Wait, what?
2014, nothing again.
2013, he bred 7 mares… in South Carolina.
2012, nothing
2011, one mare in South Carolina. His last race was in early 2011, so I can buy this one.
The gaps here are what feel bizarre to me. There are plenty of ‘backyard stallions’ across the globe who are going to be bred to only the owner’s mares, or bred for pleasure horses or some other equine sport. Europe has the flat racing and the jumps, and some stallions breed for both. I am determined to figure out what is going on with this stallion, and if he was so unloved in South Carolina (which had no racetracks or legal pari-mutuel wagering), how did he get offered in New York for a not-peanuts $2,500 stud fee?
Equibase was of little help in this regard, at least their free data. On Wicked Rich’s stats page as a runner, the website lists “Leading Progeny”.
There are two.
The ‘top earner’, COOSAWATCHIE, is a 6yo maiden who is unplaced in 7 starts, earning $3,683.
Ok, fine. But she is a 2013 foal, and bred in New Jersey.
Bloodhorse says he covered no mares in 2012. Typical thoroughbred gestation is 11 months. Something doesn’t add up here.
This reminds me of a Mitch Hedberg joke (and tangentially of my friend, Squirrel, who has been known to imbibe the beverage in question). “The commercial for Diet Dr. Pepper says it tastes just like regular Dr. Pepper. Well, then THEY F***** UP!”
Is there some secret South Carolina – New Jersey thoroughbred embryo wormhole that isn’t public knowledge? Probably not. Let’s look for more clues.
The breeder of COOSAWATCHIE, and the other current “Leading Progeny” horse named Trulywicked(NJ) is Wes Carter. Wes Carter signed the ticket at Keeneland for Wicked Rich as a yearling back in 2007 (Wes Carter for Carolyn Vogel, says the Keeneland Sales Results search engine). That’s gotta be something… we’ll look into Wes Carter once we find more about other Wicked Rich foals.
Pedigreequery.com is a great source for exploring sire lines and female families, but since the information listed on each horse is essentially voluntary, the information is reliably incomplete. But we can get clues. There, Wicked Rich is credited with 15 foals, including the two NJ breds previously mentioned. They were all foaled in New Jersey and the listed breeder in Wes Carter. So one part of the mystery is solved. Perhaps Mr. Carter was not so diligent in reporting his mares bred to the Jockey Club, but registered the foals properly when the time came…. and perhaps the stallion stood in South Carolina, where his mares live, then are shipped to New Jersey to foal. Njbreds.com rules indicate that a mare can be a ‘resident mare’ if it resides in New Jersey from November 1st of the year prior to foaling, through the foaling date.
Equineline.com provides more info, and the free info I like is sales results of progeny – you can search by several useful parameters including dam, second dam, sire of sires, the whole shebang. In the last 4 years, there have been about 10 2yo’s offered for sale at auction in North America, all consigned by Wes Carter. A few of them even brought a few dollars, such as SOCASTEE, a $50,000 purchase by KOID (Korea) at the Fasig-Tipton Midatlantic sale in 2016. The catalog page indicates that Wicked Rich’s first foals are 3yo of 2016, which doesn’t exactly match the Blood Horse report (those mares would have been covered in 2012, where none were reported). I guess you really can’t believe everything you read.
All this divergence, but I am trying to understand why Wicked Rich is a NY stallion. If he stood in NY in 2017 and we can disregard the Blood Horse report, any NY foals would be born in 2018 or later… so none to race yet. The latest catalogue page I could find was of this 2yo of 2018, and it appears Mr. Carter does not sell them as yearlings http://www.fasigtipton.com/catalogs/2018/0521/360.pdf
Let’s try another tack. BloodHorse has our man standing at Buckridge Farm. I searched for it on Facebook and found… a co-operative that raises cows. But then there’s this article that made a bunch of my research redundant. Oops!
https://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-racing/articles/211744/consignor-carter-showcasing-stallions-foals
On further review, there is evidence of a Buckridge Farm in Kinderhook, NY, owned by Amy Boll, but there is no website and does not appear to be a commercial endeavor. My best guess is that Mr. Carter plans to break into the NY bred market with his same SC sired and raised Wicked Rich babies… just foaling them a little to the North than he’s done in the past. In order to be eligible for NY-stallion series and some breeder’s awards, the stallion needs to be registered in NY state. If my calculations are correct, we’ll see some of these at Fasig-Tipton MidAtlantic this May.
I still want to know about Wicked Rich’s first trainer, Seth Benzel, why he had an impressive run from 2008-2011 ($1.5 million in earnings in 2010) and then only 9 starts since 2012. More searchs reveal… he seems to have transitioned into equine art, and then abstractionist painting. Fascinating. https://www.agora-gallery.com/artistpage/Seth_Benzel.aspx
I guess I’ve learned a lesson here… read all the search results you can before going down the rabbit holes. But sometimes you’ve got to dig and make the connections yourself, unless a journalist (BTB or otherwise) has done it already.
I’m so glad you have a real day job for the thought of you with more free time on your hand is about as scary as it gets. LOL
Free time + cold medication and questionable judgement = ???
Yep, too much time on your hands :0)
I laughed. You may now be one of the foremost experts in the world on this subject. Not sure what the appropriate reaction to that is….congrats, I guess.
Get well soon and don’t quit your day job.
“And Now For Something Completely Different”
So you’re saying it was a success!
For myself, I’m thoroughly looking forward to the next in series 🙂
Well I can fill in one more South Carolina connection for you. The foal Socastee is obviously named for the town just south of Myrtle Beach SC. Since I live just south of there I guess I gotta use Wicked Rich for the growing South Carolina horse industry 🙂
Very cool, thanks for the info nugget.
Thanks you for this well done article. Another good BTB read. You are correct in that there have been many good articles and previews in BTB lately and I enjoy reading them all. I usually write up a preview on a race each week, sometimes two if I have time. I do it for fun, to pass time as I am retired and because it does help in learning more about the horses and their bloodlines and other aspects of the Sim. So I do it for my own personal knowledge too. Thanks again for your article which was a good read for me this morning.
Thanks naskippy, your contributions are some of the ones I am talking about! We are all making great contributions (well, not so much me) to the great game!
You had me at Mitch Hedberg.
My daughter and I tell some variation of the Escalator joke just about every week.
Sorry for the convenience.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQCU36pkH7c