2019 Freshman Sire Profiles – North America
Many years I write numerous articles profiling the incoming sires for the next breeding seasons. Sadly my list this year was longer than my time available to write. Instead I will share a brief rundown of the sires that intrigue me and why. I’m going to start with North American sires and write a separate article for other locations. With one exception none of these incoming sires share the same sire. When there were multiple offspring of a sire standing stud for the first time in 2019 I chose the one that interested me more. Please feel free to share the sires you are looking forward to in 2019 and why in the comments section.
Accelerate – the Breeders’ Cup Classic winner received his own column previously. By Lookin At Lucky.
Awesome Slew – This son of Awesome Again retires to Ocala Stud in Florida. He was a hard knocking classy runner who competed in graded stakes over the course of three seasons, winning or placing in twelve of them He was unlucky to never win a grade one (had he done that he likely would have been offered a lucrative Kentucky farm retirement). He was second in three grade ones to Drefong, Mind Your Biscuits and Army Mule some of the fastest horses of recent years. His first four dams are all both stakes winners and stakes producers. Sire Canadian Frontier appears under his second dam. His sim pedigree is Awesome Again x Seeking the Gold x Seattle Slew. Not bad when you consider you get the FL-tag.
Bolt D’oro – A frustrating racehorse who looked brilliant as a two year old when he won two grade ones and then faltered badly as a three year old, this horse is a son of Medaglia D’oro. Medaglia D’oro is an up and coming sire of sires whose major sire son currently is Violence. One thing I really like about him is that he is standing at Spendthrift Farms in Kentucky. They have been very successful developing young sires with what seemed at the time like marginal prospects. Their biggest success is Into Mischief but they also stand exciting young prospects Jimmy Creed, Temple City, Cross Traffic and Goldencents. Bolt D’oro descends from a classic Claiborne Farm female line that has produced recent graded runners Zensational, Laity, Flight Forty Nine and Departing among others.
City of Light – I’ll be honest I really loved this horse as a racer (and he is my Pegasus pick provided he makes the race!) but he’s got great talent and versatility. To date he has never been out of the money in ten starts. He is a graded winner from seven to nine furlongs and he is the only horse to defeat Accelerate in 2018. He also ran a gutsy third in the Gold Cup at Santa Anita (G1) behind that rival at ten furlongs which stretched his limits. He is the best son to retire so far by Quality Road who has exceeded all expectations in becoming one of the best sires of his generation. His dam is not a great producer, he is her only stakes winner from nine foals but his second dam and beyond have been very productive. His second dam is the grade one winning and grade one producing mare Fabulous Notion. Under his third dam are grade one winners and sires Subordination and Cacoethes as well as a fan favorite grade one winner Careless Jewel. There’s a lot to like here.
Destin – this colt is a full brother to one of the leading third crop sires, Creative Cause. Creative Cause was a grade one winner, Destin would have been had he not come up a nose short in the Belmont Stakes in 2017. He is a multiple graded winner though and certainly had some talent. He’s a son of Giant’s Causeway and he’s standing in New York which has a competitive local racing scene but you’ll never have to look hard for a locally tagged race in that jurisdiction. If you like the progression Creative Cause has made as a sire this colt should be a bargain with a local tag.
Good Magic – 2017’s Two Year Old Champion was a maiden going into the Breeders’ Bowl Juvenile but his win there along with a second place finish in the Champagne (G1) got him notice. His three year old season was a bit uneven but he did win the Haskell (G1) and the Bluegrass Stakes (G2) nicely and he was second to Justify in the Kentucky Derby (G1). He’s a son of Curlin and probably the best son of that sire to retire to stud so far (and there have been some nice ones) out of a young stakes winning and producing broodmare by Hard Spun. He is related to grade one winners Magical Maiden and Miss Houdini as well as grade two winner and sire Papa Clem. I hesitate to include him on my list as he will certainly be one of the more expensive incoming sires and it is uncertain how Curlin will be as a sire of sires. As mentioned he has a number of young sons in the pipeline like Exaggerator and Palace Malice but until we start to see results Curlin sons are still an unknown proposition.
Good Samaritan – he is being marketed as the last great son of Harlan’s Holiday, to which he probably does own the title. Harlan’s Holiday died young but left a legacy with sire sons like Into Mischief and Majesticperfection. Good Samaritan’s immediate female family is not very active but starting with his third dam he is related to sires Sky Mesa, Bernstein and Wiseman’s Ferry among others. He won three grade two races, one in each year of racing and he did it on both turf and dirt. He hit the board in nine of fifteen starts and apart from his maiden win the rest were all stakes races. He also earned over a million dollars. He flashed talent and a general level of consistency among the best.
Hopppertunity – standing in Pennsylvania this son of Any Given Saturday does not inspire a lot from that standpoint but his dam also produced grade one winner Executiveprivelege and his third dam is the immortal Davona Dale . Nevertheless his allure is that he was an iron horse, running from three to seven and winning graded stakes races in each of those years. His biggest wins came at age three when he won the Clark Handicap (G1) and at age five when he took the Jockey Club Gold Cup (G1). In that five year old season he was also third in the Dubai World Cup behind California Chrome. He offers real quality stamina as he won from distances between 8 and 12f. Another good local tag for a horse who was a real warrior.
Justify – the Triple Crown winning son of Scat Daddy has his own column.
Mendelssohn – here is the sire double, as this colt is also a son of Scat Daddy. He’s a half brother to leading sire Into Mischief as well as superstar Beholder. He was a $3 million yearling purchase and was a grade one winner at two on turf and grade two winner on dirt as a three year old. He also placed in the Travers (G1) as a three year old. Obviously being by Scat Daddy and a half to Into Mischief will lure in some breeders. I also think he’s in an interesting marketing position. He stands at the same farm as Justify but for a significantly lower price ($150,000 vs. $35,000). For breeders who want to breed to Justify but get shut out the farm can easily suggest their other grade one winning son of Scat Daddy who by the way is a half brother to one of the best studs in America right now. Another marketing strategy would be to offer discounts if a breeder sends a mare to both stallions. There are a number of opportunities the stud farm has with these two. Mendelssohn stands on his own feet as a desirable first year sire but if he can capture some of the mares that fail to make Justify’s book or other potential upgrades to what he might get at another farm makes him very intriguing.
Redesdale – another sire standing in the lucrative New York local bred market is this son of Speightstown. Bred by Juddmonte Farms Redesdale’s dam is Harpia, a full sister to the legendary Danehill. She is a direct female descendant of Northern Dancer’s dam Natalma. Harpia has been a disappointment as a dam and Redesdale was sold for $18,000 as a three year old at the Keeneland January Sale. He broke his maiden later that year at Churchill Downs then as a four year old won two allowances at the Fairgrounds. His three straight wins made him a candidate for a class upgrade and he ran next in the Grade Three Commonwealth at Keeneleand where he suffered a career ending injury. Speightstown is showing promise as a sire of sires. Already he has sired four sons who have gone on to sire grade one winners.
The Lieutenant – yet another sire retiring to New York and admittedly none of the sires standing outside Kentucky would make this list if they weren’t standing in regional areas with good local bred circuits. The Lieutenant is a son of Street Sense out of Stage Magic, by Ghostzapper. If that name sounds familiar it is because she has another son beginning at stud in 2019 – Justify. This colt did not win a graded stakes until age five but that year he ran eight times and won or placed in five stakes races. He finished second to Diversify in the Suburban (G2) and third to the hard knocking California horse Dr. Dorr in the Californian (G2). If you need more information on his female family please feel free to read my write up on Justify. If you want an interesting new sire in a great local circuit look no further.
Thanks for the insight!
Good read. Thanks.
I’m interested in Funtastic, even though there hasn’t been any son of More Than Ready to truly stamp themselves as a sire. But he does have a good pedigree behind him and certainly can be one of the new bargain sires in the sim. Oscar Performance, Ransom the Moon are worth a look also.
I have zero excitement about this years crop of fresh stallions. Always Dreaming maybe if he’s cheap.
Always interesting to read this sort of analysis – unlike the game (a simulation) the sires being evaluated here are real-life horses! I liked Mendelssohn a lot as a racehorse, but his pedigree almost guarantees that he’ll sire some good ones. He is a good looking colt, as well.
The Destin link to Creative Cause is also intriguing.
Thanks for taking the time.