Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

2019 Freshman Sire Profile – Justify

Justify

Scat Daddy – Stage Magic, Ghostzapper

Enters Stud 2019 at Ashford Stud for a fee of $150,000

RACE RECORD

It is difficult to discuss Justify’s race record without talking about the records he set along the way. He became America’s thirteenth Triple Crown winner and the second to do it while undefeated. He was the first horse since 1882 to win the Kentucky Derby without racing as a two year old. And then he was gone. Justify’s legacy will always leave fans and historians wondering what might have been. He beat every horse that came after him and while there seemed to be much promise in the 2018 three year old crop early on the crop seemed to fall apart as the year progressed. The only horse he beat in his career that has gone on to win a grade one route race was Good Magic who took the Haskell over the summer. Nevertheless no one can discount the incredible feat he achieved in just a few months in 2018.

For those less familiar with his individual races I will offer a quick rundown. Between February and April he went from a maiden win to an allowance to defeating Bolt D’oro in the Santa Anita Derby (G1). Many thought Bolt D’oro should have been the previous year’s two year old champion off two grade one wins and a third in the Breeders’ Cup but he was overlooked in favor of Good Magic. Bolt D’oro was coming out of a tough race versus McKinzie in the San Felipe, his first start since the Breeders’ Cup. In that race Justify made an easy lead and left Bolt D’oro to try and catch him but Justify was alone at the finish by three lengths. Then it was on to Kentucky where, on a miserable rainy day Justify had to compete with not only a big field but an incredibly sloppy track. He broke well and sat second early on before inheriting the lead from sprinter Promises Fulfilled as that rival faded badly. As Justify took the lead down the stretch he was challenged by Good Magic who had spent the trip stalking Justify in fourth but Justify had enough to cruise to the finish in first.

His Preakness may be most remembered for the surreal conditions it was run under. Preakness Day was another rainy day which brought another sloppy surface. But while the rain was pouring during the Derby by the time the Preakness was run a heavy fog had settled over the racetrack. It made it nearly impossible to see the horses from any part of the track except right in front on you. This time Justify went straight to the front and tried to control the early pace but Good Magic was battling him head to head the entrire way. Coming down the stretch Good Magic started to fade but from the fog two late challengers emerged. Justify gutted out a half length victory over Bravazo who was a neck in front of Tenfold who again was just a neck in front of Good Magic.

On to the Belmont and Justify caught a fast racetrack and a clear day at Belmont Park. Justify was the heavy favorite to win over a field that was suspect. Second choice Hofburg was lightly raced with his biggest finish coming in a second in the Florida Derby (G1). He looked like the wise guy horse after closing in the stretch in the Kentucky Derby but he had not raced since. Justify easily gained the early lead with a quick opening first quarter and was able to keep the pace slow running around 25 second quarters for the rest of the race. The late challenge came from the European Gronkowski who had never run on dirt before. He closed from tenth to be second, beaten a length and three quarters.

And then the magical ride was over.

PEDIGREE

Scat Daddy retired from racing with two grade one wins, a solid overall racing record and a spot at Ashford Stud courtesy of his co-owner Michael Tabor (a stakeholder in Ashford). He was a son of Champion Two Year Old Johannesburg but Johannesburg had not done much as a sire. Scat Daddy began his career shuttling to Chile and expectations were modest. But then his foals hit the ground running. He entered stud in 2008 and shuttled from 2009-2011. His foals from those years made him the leading sire in Chile from 2013-2016. His offspring included two Chilean Horses of the Year. In Europe he became known as a sire of crack sprinters. From his first crop came French Champion Two Year old No Nay Never (now one of the hottest young sires on the planet). Subsequent crops produced champions Caravaggio and the brilliant filly Lady Aurelia. In the US came G1 winners Daddys Lil Darling, Celestine, Lady of Shamrock and Harmonize. But all of these were turf runners. He sired some nice graded winners on the dirt and polytrack including Daddy Long Legs, Handsome Mike and El Kabeir but the one hole in his resume was a big dirt colt. Of course Justify rectified that but in 2018 Scat Daddy also sired UAE Derby (G2) winner Mendelssohn and grade three winner Flameaway both of whom chased Justify home in the Kentucky Derby. Scat Daddy sadly died in 2015 just as the world was beginning to know the depth of his talent.

Justify’s damline goes back to one of the great foundation mares of the breed, Julia. Julia was known to produce quality fillies who became great broodmares and begot more great female talent. Julia was born in 1756 but she reverberates through pedigrees across the world to this day. Justify’s more recent family members have continued the tradition. His dam Stage Magic was grade three placed as a runner but from four foals to race she has also produced a grade three winning in the Lieutenant by Street Sense and another winner. Third dam Voodoo Lily was a multiple stakes winner, including a grade three win and is responsible for six stakes placed foals but her best foal may have been the unraced mare Layreebelle by Tale of the Cat who has produced grade two winner Spellbound by Bernardini and grade three winner Kid Cruz by Lemon Drop Kid. Justify is inbred 5x3x5 to Mr. Prospector, 4×5 to Nijinsky II and 5×5 to Narrate. Narrate was another mare who was a major influence on the breed. She only produced two female foals but they were the full sisters Yarn and Preach, both by Mr. Prospector. Yarn was the dam of Champion Minardi and sire Tale of the Cat. Her daughter Myth by Ogygian produced Johannesburg. Preach was the more successful racer, winning a grade one but she is best remembered as the dam of Pulpit.

IN THE SIM

Scat Daddy’s unfortunate passing makes rating him in the game difficult. He was scheduled for an upgrade in 2016. It was announced just days before he died. Scat Daddy’s 2015 crop included six graded stakes winners. The best foal was the Hall of Fame mare Swapsco Kitty but also two other grade one winners and three grade three winners. The other two grade one winners and two of the grade three winners were likely bred after the upgrade was announced. Again it makes one wonder what might have been. Overall Scat Daddy only sired four grade one winners in his entire sim career. Obviously one must consider Scat Daddy as a serious pedigree influence now and discard much of his actual sire and DS stats. The DS stats in particular will change dramatically as the 2015 foals start retiring and also as he is used more often in scratch breeding. Interestingly Ghostzapper as a DS in the game is quite good and produces very versatile foals (60/40 dirt to turf) and crosses well with a number of sirelines with the foals often following their sire in surface preference.

BREEDING RECOMMENDATIONS

Justify really offers breeders a lot of options. Even though he carries three crosses to Mr. Prospector only one of those will carry on to his foals and the inbreeding to Nijinsky II and Narrate will both fall off as well. Even the Storm Cat sireline could be reintroduced through the backend. The same can be said for the one strain of A.P. Indy he’ll carry (through his second dam by Pulpit). With the flexibility both Scat Daddy and Ghostzapper bring to pedigrees breeders might even consider trying turf mares or if scratchbreeding turf backends. No Nay Never was produced from an Elusive Quality mare and Lady Aurelia from a Forest Wildcat (by Storm Cat) mare. Interestingly Caravaggio’s second dam is by Relaunch, the damsire of Ghostzapper. Ghostzapper’s half brother City Zip might infuse speed into this pedigree and he also did well with turf and dirt runners. Relaunch’s sire In Reality figures prominently in the pedigree of Empire Maker who, as a fellow Belmont Stakes winner fits the traditional type of dirt routers a breeder might want from Justify. Another line to consider is Street Cry mares as Justify’s graded winning half brother is by Street Sense. Overall this is a very exciting prospect and the best advice I can give is that this might be a young sire worth sending quality mares and high class backends to.

7 thoughts on “2019 Freshman Sire Profile – Justify”

  • waremblem5

    My only hope is the SIM doesn’t engage in the deplorable tactics used on American Pharoah where a bunch of BPs and credits were spent on his initial shares and he wasn’t given a proper grade being promptly upgraded in year two. This does nothing for the legion of people who bred to AP in good faith in year one. Justify should enter the SIM with an elite rating which will place him as a top 10 sire.

    Nothing to add to his race record, it speaks for itself. He was never beaten and is the greatest horse of this century (so far).

    • Insane reply on all levels.

      Tough in reply to the original article it is with concentrating on the horses half brother who also joins the game as a sire this year. Both had a lot of ability but were very fragile. This horse seems to have thrown mostly to his dam as is very untypical of a Scat Daddy which might be a good thing going forward.

      • waremblem5

        I’m not sure what you find insane. Justify is an undefeated Triple Crown winner. That is literally the most difficult thing to accomplish in the sport. When you combine that with his outstanding pedigree he most certainly should enter stud as one of the top rated stallion in the SIM. As for the AP fiasco, when games make mistakes they compensate their customer base. This was not done. The entire AP going to stud rated incorrectly then upgraded when literally nothing had changed in real life (except his poor SIM stats) was handled poorly and I really hope the same mistake isn’t made with Justify.

        • rickybobby

          Many triple crown winners didn’t become great sires. Elite is earned, not given.
          He’s not even a top 3 horse this decade however.
          Beat a weak crop with slow times. AP would of lapped he m in the belmont

          • waremblem5

            Agree to disagree on AP but you are off base on Triple Crown winners. Seattle Slew, Secretariat and Affirmed all went on to become good to great to legendary sires. There is no point at looking at horses before them as it was a completely different sport.

          • rickybobby

            Became good sires… That’s not elite.

  • desertdog

    I’m a hater, I think he’s nothing special despite his record. He will be highly rated in the SIM. I doubt highly he is anything great in the real world.

Leave a Reply