The 3rd Crop Initiative
This analysis is based on cumulative Northern Hemisphere Sires actuals with first 4yo runners. We are starting to get a good idea of what they are capable of and who if any have a future going forward.
There are only 8 sires who have managed 4 or more graded winners over the 3 seasons the sires offspring have been active. They are the ones who have any realistic hope if a future as any success is not a flash in the pan. Some of these sires are even old news already.
I will also touch on the sires who are below this level with a future though one of these surprise on the basis of his game profile.
Frankel his record is amazing far better than anyone could of imagined. His 24 graded winners already is off the scale. You have to go to 6th crop sires to find a sire with more Sea The Stars that puts how good he is in perspective. He is a superstar in real life and in the game. It will be a shock if he is not the highest rated sire in the game within 5 years.
Union Rags he is a clear second with 8 grade stakes winners. His overall percentages/numbers from basically the same number of foals make him about a third of the value of Frankel. That sounds bad but is not. Frankel is outstanding a super sire, Union Rags is top class it shows the gulf between the top 4 or 5 stallions in the world and the rest. His grade 1 winners are out of proportion to his overall spectrum of stakes/graded stakes/grade 1 winners. Though there is a likely reason for this his average winning distance 7.23f this may not seem very high but for a US based stallion is at the higher end in fact of the 100 best sires in the Northern Hemisphere from this crop only 1 US sire has a higher average winning distance. This obviously give him a greater chance of siring classic type horses which given the nature of US racing have a disproportionate amount of grade 1 races to aim at. He should be on any player’s portfolio sire list who want to breed classic type dirt horses. His game rating has him listed as a Dirt Sprint type sire. Technically this is correct but it does raise questions as to if any sire falls into the dirt route type category. His mix though of game results on prize money suggests he is doing what would be expected mainly dirt horses who’s best distance is just short of a mile. His 2017 offspring results suggest he was silent upgraded and that his game rating is about right have confidence use him.
Nathaniel is the only other sire with more than 4 grade stake winners from his first three crops to race. All 6 have won graded races this year. His offspring are taking time to mature but this was to be expected. They also need a trip most being better at 10f+ an average winning distance of 10.89 is a long way very few active sires would have further. he is a sire to back in real life with unexposed horses at 10f+ especially on soft ground if you ever go racing in the UK with the words soft in the going description. In the game his results are slightly below expectations. His surface requirements are perfectly fine and overall his split of purses indicate the runners want a trip. The questions as to why might not be so much rating but how his offspring are being managed. Are players being bold enough to run at 10f+ and also are they managing them right. It would be a reasonable guess to suggest the game thinks his offspring slightly slowly which in game talk means 5 years old. How many horses are getting to that age with limited mileage to exploit those characteristics? It is worth consideration for Mike to possible to shade the guess code for surface type to reflect potential maturity type as well. That could be a way to indicate feedback something many players desire.
Bodemeister is the first of 5 stallions with 4 graded stakes winners. He has only the one grade 1 winner out of a mare who has produced another grade 1 winner. I think we know where that horse’s ability came from as he has not sired another horse anywhere close in terms of ability. His 2109 stud fee has a massive reduction as well. Overall at less than 3% stakes winners his results are not encouraging. You would not be surprised if a one way ticket to somewhere was not announced within the next 12 months. His game results reasonable reflect his real life results except for the fact his offspring seem to favour a trip which does not reflect his AWD his split should be similar to Union Rags and any change should be only in respect of this factor.
Creative Cause he has done reasonably well all things considered. He does offer good value given his current game prices he can be obtained for under 200 credits/bps. His game rating might be slightly light but the deviation could be as much to do with opportunity. The other observation he is more inclined to be a dirt sire especially with quality runners. The Turf sprint banding should really be Dirt Sprint banding though his offspring have better results overall on dirt in the game which is encouraging. Overall at his current prices he represents good value for money.
Shackleford he is a strange sire in some ways. He has those 4 graded winners but only one other stakes winner. Why such a gulf between hit and total miss? If you look at Creative Cause he has another 7 which is what you would expect and demonstrate positive input form the sire. You do wonder where Shackleford is going and it does not appear in a positive direction at present. His stud fee has been left the same for 2019. In the game he is listed as a Dirt Sprint influence and that appears the case in both real and fake environments. His game results are in line with expectations again showing the reliability of stallion data.
Get Stormy has been at stud for a very low fee. He started in California. He somehow has managed to knock out 4 graded stakes winners. Sires who have stood for a lot more have done a lot worse. These results off a $5K stud fee are good. The caveat would be they have been achieved in turf sprint races for the most part. The quality of grade 3 sprints on turf in the US would be a long way removed for example than the equivalent class of race in Australia (by around 10lbs). Though the facts are simple Mike rates horses on actual results, the fact the world does not have a consistent grading range code over the global (it should) is not his problem. In the game he in recent seasons has had to few runners to make any real judgements though he does throw sprints mostly as one would expect. There would appear to be based on earlier results a probability of a small upgrade, depending on demand he could offer some value.
Sepoy he no longer stand in the Northern Hemisphere for obvious reasons. Apart from Frankel he would have had the second best book of mares here and was just a total dud. Any results that are positive are down to mare quality. He appears to have been downgraded in the game. This was touched upon in a recent article I wrote. Are there any reasons that could explain his failure as a sire? Possibly. He was a big horse who matured quickly at the time he raced young horses development could be aided by the use of anabolic steroids to build muscle. This now in civilised countries has been banned both on performance and health grounds. If you produce big horses that are not strong enough for their frame and by the time they fill out their precocious nature asa long since passed you have a recipe for failure. Food for thought Sepoy has a higher average winning distance in the Northern Hemisphere than all the North America based sires above. He is in the game and real life predominantly a sprint sire.
There are three sires outside of these with some positive upsides for different reasons.
Maclean’s Music He currently has 3 graded stakes winners. His number of stakes winners is good and running at a high percentage. His results for stakes/graded stakes runners would have him pretty much equal to Creative Cause. He did gain some momentum after a classic winner in his first crop the only other grade 1 winner being bred by his owner from a mare who has bred another graded stakes winner. In real life he may have some upside to come. There are two big problems he was an unsound horse only just over 62% of his horses have run lower than all the other sires. You would hope that he is a sire with the high injury threshold for his runners in the game. The other factor is his AWD of less than 6f. Even by the standards of US racing that is very low which indicates he is very one dimensional. He is listed as a dirt sprint sire but the slant to sprinting needs to be emphasised even more. His game price is nuts compared to Creative Cause, it probably tells us a lot about people playing the game. He would appear to being over bred. There is probably a great likelihood he gets downgraded than upgraded in years to come.
Tai Chi he is a sire based in Germany. He has over 10% stakes winners 4 in total only Frankel has a higher percentage with stallions with multiple stakes winners. There is obvious some sort of talent there. Though as with Get Stormy this is being achieved in a weak competitive market. He is though available in the game for less than 20 points. Assuming his rating is reasonable next year this offers value. He should be capable of breeding horses that win races and at that price the horse in question will return a positive bp count to the stable something the best Frankel’s will never do. At times you need to breed a few like this and once in a while you should get a stake winner.
Skipshot I would think given the number of horses he has bred in the game most people would have the same reaction I had WHO? A search came back he is standing at a private fee at a stud without a website and free email account. Looking at his offspring many seem to have been trained and bred by M Yanakov a search got me this https://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-racing/articles/229932/yanakov-sees-longshot-sire-skipshot-gaining-respect it is a good read with some interesting points about the sire. Obviously someone else is taking notice. The reasons are deeper than the obvious. His percentage of runners is almost 85% which is high these horses are obviously sound. His winners to foals ratio is over 50% again a great sign. Then we can add in an AWD 7.71f which is about as high as it gets for North American stallions. There is no surprise he sired a grade 1 winner over 10f it is the only horse that was likely to stay the trip. If you are watching racing and see a horse sired by him race at 9.5f or above in the US back
it WPS. He is a dirt sprint sire in the game this is wrong and his attributes need to reflect a high stamina index for a dirt sire. He is obviously better than his game rating and deserves some sort of upgrade. If given the opportunity in real life that for instance Maclean’s Music is getting he would sire horse that appear in graded races over a trip on a regular basis.
The overall conclusion is we can place great reliance on stallion values being close to what we should expect. The exceptions being that sire who perform’ really well from an obscure background and the star that fails to shine. These will get adjusted to hit alignment even if they are not included on the upgrade and downgrade list. If you believe a sire has been doing well use it especially next year. In general when playing be a goat not a sheep the rewards will be richer pastures. Is the use of shading on stallion characteristics of benefit to aid horse placement development within the game? The last point to make is chase the value Creative Cause and Maclean’s Music should have pretty much the attributes next year one can be obtained for less than 200 the other 1,000. You can breed 5 CC’s to 1 MM your chances of hitting the jackpot are far better with the former than the later for the same expenditure.