Freshman Sire Profile 2018 – Practical Joke
Practical Joke
Into Mischief – Halo Humor, Distorted Humor
Enters Stud 2018 at Ashford Stud for a fee of $30,000
Race Record
Practical Joke was one of the best runners of his generation although he often was the Rodney Dangerfield of the group. Much of that was because he was not a classic type horse but a sprinter/miler. Nevertheless his connections pressed him into longer races hoping for that big score. As a two year old he did very well winning three of four starts including two grade ones. Practical Joke broke his maiden at Saratoga by five lengths while turning heads. He jumped straight from that race into the Hopeful Stakes, the most prestigious two year old race of the meet. The field that day included several other lightly raced babies including the highly regarded favorite Classic Empire who dumped his jockey shortly after the start allowing Pracitcal Joke to cruise easily to victory. His next start, the Champagne was anything but easy. This time it was Practical Joke’s turn to break awkwardly, spotting the field a couple of lengths while the lightning quick Syndergaard battled for the early lead. Syndegaard threw down blazing fractions, entering the stretch with an open lead after six furlongs in 1:08.76 but Practical Joke was focused on him like a laser. He set down for the drive and slowly but surely reeled in Syndegaard to win in the shadow of the wire. Practical Joke was set for a trip west for the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile where he was among the favorites. He would have to face Gormley, who won the major West Coast prep for the race and Classic Empire who did the same in Kentucky. Of those three Practical Joke was the only one making his first start around two turns and it would prove his weakness as he finished third behind Classic Empire who would go on to be named Champion Two Year Old Colt. At three Practical Joke was put on the Triple Crown trail. He ran well in his preps – second in the Fountain of Youth and the Blue Grass Stakes but he lacked the dominance he showed as a two year old. He ran a creditable fifth in the Kentucky Derby after a messy trip. Practical Joke skipped the rest of the Triple Crown and rebounded with a win in the Dwyer Stakes at Belmont, another one turn mile. That set him up for a run in the Haskell at a mile and one eighth where he battled to the wire with Girvin and McCraken but settled for third. He returned to sprinting back at Saratoga and won the H. Allen Jerkens Stakes (formerly the King’s Bishop) a grade one over seven furlongs. He defeated fellow three year old Takaful that day who would later go on to win the Vosburgh against older runners. Practical Joke used that run as a prep for the Breeders’ Cup Dirt Mile where he finished off the board. He finished his career with a third place finish behind Sharp Azteca and Mind Your Biscuits in the Cigar Mile. Perhaps Practical Joke was a good miler where he was 4-2-0-1 in his career. Maybe his connections were right to try him beyond a mile where he was 5-0-2-2. But when a horse is 3-3-0-0 with two grade one wins in sprint races you have to wonder if his career was perfectly managed.
Pedigree
Practical Joke is a son of Into Mischief, a sire in the midst of a meteoric rise. When he retired to stud for the 2009 season leading publication The Blood Horse released a brief, somewhat generic announcement. It noted that he won the Grade One Cash Call Futurity and had recently finished second in the Grade One Malibu among his six starts. He earned just shy of $600,000 and was by Harlan’s Holiday out of the mare Leslie’s Lady. Oh how fortunes have changed! Were he to retire today Into Mischief might be hailed as a son of leading sire of sires Harlan’s Holiday out of Broodmare Of the Year Leslie’s Lady – one of her three grade one winning offspring. Certainly he might command a stud fee higher than the $12,500 he started at in 2009 or the $7,500 where his fee dropped before he had foals of racing age. Certainly breeders would have flocked to him early on – he produced 42 named foals from his first crop (including multiple graded stakes winners Goldencents and Vyjack) but hit a low of just 27 in his second year at stud. By 2017 Into Mischief’s fortunes had changed. His stud fee was $75,000 and he was bred to 235 mares! His fee has jumped again to $100,000 for 2018 although Spendthrift Farm has reported his book as being full. He descends from a branch of the Storm Cat family that has had some success of late. He is generally known for getting quick early two year olds but has proven those foals can hold up over time – Goldencents won the Breeders’ Cup Dirt Mile in consecutive runnings. He has sired two champions and does well with runners on both surfaces. Practical Joke is out of the Distorted Humor mare Halo Humor who was stakes placed on the racetrack. He is her only stakes winning offspring to date. Her family has not been particularly active of late but she was an attractive mare and a debut winner as a two year old at Saratoga. She was purchased for $130,000 at the 2008 Keeneland January Sale. She was unlucky with her first three foals, only one of which made it to the races and became a winner ( a second died before entering training). Practical Joke was such a smart looking horse that he commanded a price of $135,000 as a short yearling in 2015’s Keeneland January Sale.
In the Sim
Into Mischief falls into a frustrating category in the sim – a young sire who was not rated highly when he entered stud and whose rating has likely not been raised enough to recognize how well he is doing in real life. He did receive an announced upgrade in 2015 and his status has improved since then. Overall he has sired only four graded stakes winners in his sim career and only one came in a foal crop before 2015. In addition fourteen of his twenty three stakes winners came from horses foaled over the last three years. Still he has never sired a grade one winner in the game. His four graded winners were produced from mares by Kingmambo, Tiznow, Elusive Quality and Tapit, so a pretty broad range of options. Harlan’s Holiday sired six grade one winners in the game. Three of them were produced by sons of Seattle Slew and two others were produced by sires descended from Mr. Prospector (the last was by Darshaan).
Breeding Recommendations
Practical Joke is inbred 5×5 to Halo. Four of Into Mischief’s real life graded stakes winners are inbred to Storm Cat. Storm Cat would appear in the fifth generation of a Practical Joke foal so there should be no real concerns about inbreeding. Considering how well Into Mischief does with speedy two year olds and that that descriptor could be used for Practical Joke a sim breeder might look to increase those tendencies in a foal irrespective of pedigree. Some sires that might fit that mold are Ghostzapper, More Than Ready, Uncle Mo and Sepoy. Johannesburg and Speightstown also produce fast two year olds and also carry a cross of Storm Cat in their pedigrees (as does Giant’s Causeway who is currently the leading sire in the 2017 crop). It might also be interesting to try Oasis Dream who leads all sires of two year olds of 2017 by number of graded winners and Frankel who ties with Giant’s Causeway for second with three graded winners.

One horse that was definitely retired too early. Never got that big score and might of had a chance in some mile races to actually build a resume
Practical Joke is one I can get behind!
He would have been a star at CC!