Success Walks Hand in Hand with Failure in the Movieland Futurity…
December 17, 2017 marks the eighteenth running of the Movieland Stakes Futurity. The California Grade I is the last big race of the year for Two-Year Old’s, and often determines the Juvenile EOY Award recipient. The race was first run in in 2009, skipped a year in 2010, and has been a significant race for Juveniles ever since. The rich history of the race has produced Hall of Famer’s AWESOME FORCE, and SWAPSCO KITTY, as well as End-of-the-Year Award winner’s ERUPTION, DEGOLDENSTORM, DISTORTED DRAGON, BOLTON VALLEY, RACING CALENDAR, and DEADMONET CADET as well as thirty-five of the top three finishers running in the Bluegrass Derby. Clearly, the Movieland is a major prep for Two-Year Old’s with Derby aspirations, but while it is a giant stepping stone to the Kentucky Classic, a top three Movieland finish often spells disaster for a horse’s Derby performance. Only two of the thirty-five horses that finished in the top three of the Movieland have ever finished on the board in the Bluegrass Derby, 2005 VIRTUOSO, who finished 1st and 2010 CONFEDENTLY WRONG who finished 3rd. The rest finished up as Also-Rans with alarming results.
These are the Derby results of all the top three Movieland finishers that went on to race in the Derby:
1999
PRINCESS’S BALLOT – 9th
2001
RIVENDELL – 10th
RADAR – 14th
2002
ERUPTION -14th
2003
BRABAWELLS – 17th
SEEKING RANSOM – 18th
2004
CHEAP WINE- 18th
2005
SAN PELLIGRINO – 11th
VIRTUOSO – 1st
2006
AWESOME FORCE – 10th
TAXI DRIVER – 19th
DEGOLDENSTORM – 14th
2007
GRATEST – 14th
SHETAN – 5th
2008
DISTORTED DRAGON – 17th
TAPTRICAL TED – 18th
ULTIMATE DIAMOND – 10th
2009
FLAME OF APOLLO – 9th
PERFECT GAME TED – 20th
2010
FIFTY TWO PICKUP – 15th
CONFIDENTLY WRONG – 3rd
2011
BOLTON VALLEY – 19th
LETMEGOCRAZYONYOU – 12th
2012
SIMBESTO – 13th
HAACK’s DUKE – 14th
2013
RACING CALENDAR – 8th
OFFICIAL BULB – 9th
2014
UNION RAILS – 20th
PAGLIACCI’STEARS – 11th
SLEWGAN AWE – 6th
2015
SWAPSCO KITTY – 5th
DEADMONEY CADET – 19th
SYMBOLI BIRD – 14th
2016
MORE CREATIVE – 12th
IMNOTGONNACRACK – 5th
The average 12th place finish for a Movieland qualifier in the Derby is quite an astounding result for the top three-year old’s in their class, in fact some of the very best horses to step foot on the simulated racetrack. Does a race with all its’ prestige set your horse up with immortality at the cost winning the Derby? Do you skip the Movieland in your prep for the Derby? Do you skip the Derby and aim for one of the other Classics? Does a Grade I race that late in the 2yo season have an adverse effect on horses over the next five months of racing?
There is no doubt in my mind that the stress of the Movieland, or any Grade I that late in the 2yo season, wreaks havoc with the wear and tear on a horse for several months to come. There is no denying those results. This makes what VIRTUOSO did even more amazing and brings up the question of whether he belongs in the HOF, but that’s for another topic.
Personally, winning the Bluegrass has always been my number one goal in this game. Unfortunately, but for a talented New York bred that has been dominant in Local Company, I have no other hope at even getting as horse into the Bluegrass. While the chances of this Colt ever making the field are slim to none doesn’t keep me from trying to achieve that goal. My persistence led me to searching for races for this New York Bred outside the Local ranks hoping to test him for class in open company. Having forehand knowledge of the disasters of prepping in the Movieland, followers of the Derby Watch would have an inkling of my opinion of horses coming out of the Movieland, I opted for the Grade III Pleasure Stakes.
Got a top Two-Year Old? What will you do? What’s your priority? Are these Derby results just a coincidence or is there a direct correlation between the two races?
One thing is for sure…The top three Movieland finishers will qualify for the Derby and likely run…will they turn those sour notes into music to our ears….
Morning Pete…Maybe this is your year to win the Blue Grass…Personally I don’t think it’s to late to breed one today for the Blue Grass…I wished i could find all the statistics like you do but the one horse in the sim (that i found to win the triple crown) He only had 2 races as a two year old and his first race was in November…
What is the easy way to find Blue Grass Derby winners ??
I don’t believe is a easy way to breed a great horse or a horse for ultimate goal The Blue Grass. Just a dream, a little of luck and the right placement. We look for fancy and beautiful names, but those won’t even win a race. Patient will be the key…
nycowboy…Maybe i worded my question wrong…Searching the SIM for previous Blue Grass Derby winners is a hard for me…I’m not looking for an easy way to breed one…
It has always been hard for me to find Previous races that i want to look at…
Yay! So happy to see Rivendell’s name in the BTB. FWIW his 10th in the Bluegrass had less to do with winning this race and more to do with stamina issues. Anyhow thanks for the memories!
Pete, as always a great and refreshing article, thank you.
Enjoyed this piece! Well done.
Inspired by it … so today i welcome into the sim a KY bred 2yo colt by Blame. Named him after this article:
SUCCESS WALKS.
good luck to everybody!!