Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

General

Travelogue: Keeneland Part 5 (the final day)

<Donny’s got two horses in his sights, but there can be only one.  Last day of the sale!>

It’s the night before the final session of the Keeneland September sale. But it’s not September 22nd, it’s October 12th as I write this, because this travelogue is not a diary. Instead it’s a reconstruction of events as I recollect them, with reflection and selective memory and (mostly) unconscious bias. I haven’t cranked these out in one setting – this is the fifth installment, and each one has truly been a stand-alone piece, written on different days. With that in mind, I’ve been struggling to envision exactly how I want to tell my story of September 23rd. So many things happened (of interest, to me) that I could keep writing and reflecting and interpreting in an endless loop of self-referential madness. Since that is more like an unwanted glimpse into my cluttered mind, I’ll try to tell a factual story with as little editorializing as possible.

Considering the source, of course.

Since I intend this to be the last of five chapters, I’ll open the floor for questions afterwards.

So there are two horses I can see myself bidding on – catalogue pages listed below.

Temple City colt http://apps.keeneland.com/sales/Sep17/pdfs/3934.pdf
Paddy O’Prado filly http://apps.keeneland.com/sales/Sep17/pdfs/3996.pdf

The goal on Friday evening was to do a deeper dive into publicly available info, and see if I could come up with a reason to go with one over the other, or  Plan B – set a maximum price I was willing to spend for each. This came into play after dinner discussions with Mark, as I learned he now has a farm where they board horses on layoffs, and where his wife breaks the babies that he eventually trains. We discussed possible partnerships (he and I and perhaps a few others) and his rates were quite reasonable – with daily fees pro-rated to the proportion of ownership. This is in the back of my mind as a Plan C, but only for the Paddy O’ Prado filly, for reasons I’ll get into later. First, let me tell you about 3934.

http://www.bloodhorse.com/stallion-register/stallions/136098/temple-city

I have to admit, maybe a month ago I didn’t know much about Temple City, other than that he was by Dynaformer. When you dig into the details, he’s a really interesting stallion. He was a Grade 3 winner at 5, going 12 furlongs on the dirt. His best race might have been his last, where he led every step of the way in the G1 Hollywood Turf Cup…until the last few strides. He also broke his maiden at first asking, going 6 ½ furlongs on the dirt at Santa Anita… in December of his 3yo season. Turf, dirt, sprint and long, this is my kind of versatile guy. His pedigree is turfy but with a significant wrinkle – his dam (by Danzig) is a half-sister to super stud Malibu Moon. The stud fee climbed to $15,000 in 2017 but sales results are all over the place – including a $475,000 filly earlier in the sale. I focused on the median sales price for colts (to eliminate bias for broodmare potential), which was $8,500 in 2016 and (at the time) $18,000 for 2017.

The colt’s family is not flashy, but upon closer inspection of PP’s they were gritty, sound, and fast. The mom won MdSpWt on Polytrack at Turfway (before they switched back to dirt), Alw N1X at Colonial on dirt (off the turf) and was a close second for Alw N2x at Fair Grounds, going 5 1/2f on the turf. That pattern continued through her foals, who all had speed and won on dirt, turf, and synthetics from 5 1/2f to a mile. I love that she has 5 winners from 5 to race of 7 foals… and #6 is a current 2yo who has already hit the board twice in three starts. Without exception, all the foals won their best races at 4, some moving up the class ladder as they matured.  This guy is the first ever Temple City / Crafty Prospector cross, but has a TrueNicks rating of “B” for crosses with granddaughters of Mr. Prospector (6% stakes winners vs. 4% for all Temple City babies). The two stars are Annals of Time (G1 winner out of a Distant View mare) and Startup Nation (G2, Wagon Limit).

I had my reservations about what a son of Dynaformer would produce with a sprinter- throwing dam, but was heartened by the pedigree of Miss Temple City, his most famous offspring.

http://www.pedigreequery.com/miss+temple+city

Her dam Glittering Tax is by Artax, the BC Sprint winner and multiple track record holder at Belmont and Aqueduct. Artax also traces tail-male to Mr. Prospector, like the colt in question’s damsire Crafty Prospector. The 2nd dam is Nancy’s Glitter by Glitterman, another speed demon. I saw an obvious parallel with the yearling’s 3rd dam, La Chaposa, who produced Grade 1 sprinters Chaposa Springs and the stallion You and I.

That could work!

The horse I inspected first, however, was the Paddy O’ Prado filly.

http://www.bloodhorse.com/stallion-register/stallions/133193/paddy-oprado

The stallion doesn’t get much respect with only 1% blacktype winners and a lifetime yearling sales median price of $7,500. He was recently shipped off to stand in Turkey after finishing 2017 here for $3,500…he stood for $9,500 in this filly’s cover season of 2015. That’s ok with me, as I am looking precisely for one of those non-commercial types who might still produce a nice runner. His good ones seem to like a mile on the dirt (average winning distance 7.55 furlongs) despite his personal proclivity for the turf. I always forget that he won the G1 Secretariat (10f on turf at my beloved Arlington Park) but most of us remember him for his 3rd in Super Saver’s Kentucky Derby.

Ah, more of that versatility I am looking for!

The more I dug into her catalogue page, the more I fell in love with her. 1st dam Say Amen (Pulpit) was only a $20k 2yo purchase, so she probably didn’t wow them physically. She won two decent races at a mile on dirt (MdSpWt at Lone Star, AlwN1X at Mountaineer) and actually finished first in another that she was subsequently DQ’d from. The chart indicated she was placed last, yet there was no mention of a foul, so perhaps there was a bad test of some sort. No matter, her offspring who made it to the winner’s circle proved to be consistently better than she was. That under-the-radar South Korean standout I once mentioned?  That’s her son Baksuchyeo, a 17k yearling by Bob and John; he won 6 times and earned $233,000 US. His full brother sold for only $3,000 and has earned $69k and still going strong after two wins at Pimlico. I like when they outperform their sales price – that’s what I have in mind with $10,000 to play with.

Another half-sis Perfect Praise (Pleasantly Perfect) seemed to be made of hickory – she won on turf, dirt, and poly and was claimed at least five times before earning $137,000. In what looked like the tail end of her career, she was claimed for $5,000 at Turfway and immediately shipped to Mexico, where she promptly won 3 more races and was (also invisible to the catalogue) an amazing 4th in a Grade 2 race at 100-1 odds. She made 47 starts in a 4-year career, which is the kind of throwback I’d love to have in my barn.

Even the foals who didn’t race from the mare were providing value. Say Afleet (Northern Afleet) has a stakes winner of 200k in Louisiana, and an unmentioned 2yo full brother who sold for $5,300 and has already won MdSpWt at Lone Star. The only runner from the dam who did not win a race was a $46k yearling by Stormy Atlantic (a dirt sprinter, against the grain of which sires worked here), so I found it interesting that he attracted attention at the sale, unlike his successful siblings.

I haven’t even mentioned the secondary stuff. The third dam Shopping is by one of my all-time favorites, Private Account (Damascus). She was a ridiculously prodigious broodmare, with standouts Trappe Shot (G2) and Power Broker(G1) in her direct lineage. TrueNicks lost its damn mind over the El Prado / Pulpit mare crossing, scoring an A++ rating on the strength of 17% stakes winners versus starters with that pedigree, compared to 5% for other sires from Pulpit mares. I’ll grant you, I had to use Medaglia D’Oro as the sample stallion, and the Graded winners were by Kitten’s Joy or El Prado himself, but that is why it’s called speculation. Still, it confirmed in my mind that Paddy O’Prado was a masterful choice for the mare if you wanted to produce a nice route horse at a discount price.

I looked at both prospects on Friday afternoon, and after pouring over stats all night… I kind of wanted them both. What I haven’t mentioned is what I saw upon physical inspection – the weakest part of my yearling buying game. I saw the filly first, then the colt, then revisited them both on Saturday morning.

There was nothing spectacular about her at first glance, save for her coat. Who doesn’t like a gray? She seemed bright-eyed and definitely built for two-turns, with baby fat where muscle might eventually take root.  The frame was definitely there, and I could imagine an imposing looking grinder.

sayamen

 

I liked her more and more as I scoped her walk, but I worried a little about her pasterns.  I got this sense that they were a little long and a little upright, meaning the angle from the ankle to the hoof was a little too vertical.  I have no experience in the regard, but from what I read, this is less than desirable due to additional strain on the ligaments. It wasn’t enough to scare me off, but as I tried to quantify what I was looking at I noticed something odd about her right front leg.

To my eye, it was perfectly aligned from the knee down through cannon bone, ankle, pastern and the foot.  Since I’m trying to screen for soundness, I love when things are arranged in straight lines so that there isn’t unnecessary torsion on the joints.  The knee, however, seemed to be attached to the upper leg (radius bone) at a rotated angle… so that when you look at the leg it looks straight, but if you look from the knees up, one is turned out.

IMG_0280             IMG_0281

The ‘knee thing’ was almost imperceptible, as I had probably looked at her for several minutes before noticing it – maybe her hair color provided some natural chiaroscuro effect that made it harder to distinguish from shadows.  I didn’t know if it mattered, and in fact have heard several stories of much more ‘crooked’ horses having great careers.  Still, I had looked under every metaphorical rock and didn’t want to make a mistake.  I called in my friend Mark who confirmed that he was seeing the same thing I was, and was not quite as concerned but still found it noteworthy.  We had the stable hand walk her again, and when I stuck my head down to be eye-level with her knee, you could see the right leg bend not straight back, but winging off to the side with each stride.  When her foot hit the ground, the leg looked perfectly straight again.  How much of a risk is this… and how much of a discount is that worth to me?

The colt was another story altogether.  First of all, his consignor was assigned to barn 47, which was all by itself on a ridge that required some creative navigation to reach, and literally the furthest sales barn from the pavilion.  I was the only prospective buyer there during my visit on Friday, and in the frenetic hour before the sale started on Saturday I saw only one other visitor to their five-horse contingent.  I didn’t know what I expected to see, except that the other Temple City’s I’d seen were lanky with high withers.  Immediately I was struck with how smooth this horse looked.  His movements were calm and rounded, he walked without wasted motion, and he stood perfectly without any concern for the circumstances, as if he’d done this quite a few times before.  Physically there was nothing that jumped out which would distinguish him from the crowd – he’s sort of compact front to back, without being short, and he was definitely not big hipped or overly muscular.

IMG_0260 (1)

 

When viewed from the front he was very correct, but on the smaller side and definitely not wide-bodied.  But when viewed from the side, the word that kept popping into my head was “balanced”.  Everything seemed perfectly proportioned, which matched with his walk that looked unstrained and efficient.  He has this sort of boxy torso from chest to hip that really grabbed me, and made me wonder what he would look like when he grew up.  I thought the bone structure was fantastic, a nice chassis but an underdeveloped engine. He’s an April foal, and I’d established on pedigree that he should be a late developer, so why should I be discouraged now that he does not look pumped up like Hans or Franz?  His vet report was totally clean, and the stable gal who walked him for me volunteered that he was known in their group for his ‘great mind’.  I was not expecting what I found, and he was starting to grow on me.  I see a tough little turf sprinter in the making, not unlike the one that got away on Thursday.

Mark checked him out on Saturday morning, and without giving an endorsement or a rebuttal to my assessment, he suggested that I might have a chance at buying him because he lacked a certain flashiness.  I thought I could live with that, so long as my overall judgement was correct.  But there’s little time to deliberate as the sale starts at 10.  The crowds of potential buyers in the back ring were much thinner today, and there were over 100 outs from less than 300 in the catalogue, which meant this sale was going to end quickly. Mark had two remaining Ohio-breds earmarked, which he valued at  8k and 6k, respectively.  We watched the first 10 or so go through the ring and finally!  Finally.  Finally the prices seem to have dropped to levels we’ve been expecting.

Mark finally gets on the board for 2017 when he is the high bidder on the 8k filly for $6,000, a strong looking Cowtown Cat.  The Temple City colt enters the back walking ring shortly after, and I try to lay low while monitoring how many people take interest.  It’s not easy to do!  I decide I’m going to bid from inside the arena as opposed to behind the ring, thinking that I’ll be more conspicuous by not revealing my presence to the consignors or the casual shoppers who might be seeing him for the first time.  I have no idea if this makes any difference, but I feel like this is one I really want and might finally have a shot.

Before I leave, I congratulate Mark for finally getting one, and he asks how high I’ll go on the colt, knowing that the Paddy O’Prado filly is coming up shortly after.  Plan C was to go half or quarters on her with Mark and his partners, and have him train her in Ohio. I think she’d love the deep surface at Mahoning Valley and perhaps the synthetic at Presque Isle.  We both know the Temple City sprinter is not a good fit for his circuit (no turf courses) or style (he does quite well with route horses), so the idea of sending him there never comes up.  I’ve got Kentucky or Mid-Atlantic on the brain, with an abundance of turf sprint offerings throughout the year to choose from.  I still haven’t answered his question.  For reasons I honestly can’t remember – although I’m sure I anguished over it – I decide that I’ll go up to $8,000 for the colt and $6,500 for the filly.

As the anxiety level starts to creep up on me, I find a chair in full view of a bid spotter and plop myself down, about 4 horses remaining before 3934 goes into the ring.  I make eye contact to make sure he sees me, as if these guys need my help… bad move.  Despite having a plan after watching hundreds of horses sell over three days, I make a classic blunder and an ill-timed arm movement turns into an opening $1,000 bid on a horse I didn’t even look up at.  I experienced a solid three or four seconds of sheer terror before someone else made a higher bid, thank your God of choice – it might have been hip 3930 (a Birdstone filly) but I was just glad to move on, and I purposefully stared at the floor to avoid a screwup until 3934 was on deck.  I wish I were exaggerating.

The Temple City walks in and I am focused only on the bid spotter. We get the usual unrealistic opening offer from the auctioneer and it quickly drops down until I get a bid in at $2,000.  The following bids come quickly and I find myself the high bidder at $5,000 before the first hint of a pause in the action.  Eventually there’s a bid of $6,000 and now I’m not happy with myself – how did I land on the ODD number when I said I was going to bid up to $8,000?  No one else bids after 6k so I get the sense it is down to myself and another entity, but I can’t sense where the other bid is coming from as I see nothing peripherally.  I’m surprised how quickly it went from nothing to 6 and just stopped dead in its tracks – too quick for me to identify a competitor (or the consignor running up the score?)  I had done my homework on the breeder- they sell a handful at this sale every year and rarely if ever take one back, even at $2,000 bids. I didn’t suspect a reserve price and was not thinking “private sale option” for him at any point in the process.

I pause long enough to see if someone will bid $7,000 so I can bid and stop at $8,000 with a clear conscience, but that never happens.  I bid 7 before the auctioneer can string out his closing cadence, and another pregnant pause ensues before the bid of 8 comes in.  I get the sense I’m being strung along (but how would one know?) and the feeling of time stopping while I’m thinking….I said I’d stop at 8, but my last bid was 7… I doubt there’s a reserve so it’s either a real bidder at $8,000 or the consignor trying to boost the price…can they really risk that and have the horse go unsold if I don’t keep going and I’m the only real bidder?…more poker scenarios, what a country…ok, still no more bids coming…decision time.

It felt like minutes but couldn’t have been more than 8 seconds, and at the end I felt clear headed and resolute about making absolutely only one more bid, $9,000.  I only had $10,000 credit and would have to pay in full immediately if I bid higher than that, regardless of what arbitrary ceiling I set for the sale.  If he gets a bid for 10 he’s automatically out of my preferred range, so no regrets.  If I let him go for $8,000 and I don’t get the filly later, I might forever regret the “what if” of another $1,000 increment.  The risk / reward ratio seemed reasonably skewed towards taking a shot now, so I bid $9,000 – the absolute highest amount I would offer in this scenario – and waited for the next shoe to drop.  Instead, I got to sign a ticket.  Maybe not a lottery ticket, but one that will certainly provide another exciting ride.

<<< EPILOGUE >>>

I take a few moments to savor my ‘victory’ or let the endorphins subside before heading back to check on Mark.  He’s in on 3953 (a Magna Graduate filly from a nice Ohio powerhouse family) and with the ‘savings’ he got on his first purchase, he can afford to go over on this one and buys her for $8,500.  He valued the combo at $14,000 and ended up spending $14,500, but their price tags were essentially flipped.  He watched the bidding but didn’t realize I got my colt for 9, and upon the news he promptly and rightfully declared “Donny, you’re back in the game.”

New problem – it’s the last day of the sale, and one of the conditions is that owners are responsible for taking possession of the horses “immediately”, or at least that’s what’s printed on the ticket. It’s around noon and the sale will end before 2pm;  my flight is at 6:30pm and I haven’t arranged for transportation OR a final destination for my new horse.  I had been in contact with Margaux Farm throughout the past two weeks, having settled on them as the place I’d send a yearling for initial instruction.  I was unable to get a live person on the phone and despite alerting them that I -might- buy a horse and send it to them, there was nothing set in stone. 

Another twenty minutes goes by and I am starting to worry a bit when Amanda from Margaux calls me back.  I’m still in the back walking area as there’s one more Ohio bred Mark wants to see, so I step a good 20 yards outside to get away from the noise and find some shade under a tree.  I’m making final arrangements with Amanda when two handlers divert a horse from the walking ring,  stroll across the grass and plant their long, grey filly directly in front of me to wipe down her legs, muddied from the trek.

It would be of no consequence except that I recognize the filly and scan for her hip sticker – it’s 3994, Paddy O’ Prado – Say Amen, by Pulpit.

C’mon, seriously?  Is this some kind of omen?  I’m not that kind of guy but it has been an emotional day, week, month, and year for a multitude of reasons. I am not putting anything past ‘the universe’ today, the tricky bastard.  I run and find Mark and ask if he’s interested in the filly if she doesn’t bring much – I’d worry about paying for her later, and 50% of his day rate is not going to hurt me.  He’s cautious about that knee but agrees she’d be worth the risk for 4 or 5k.

She’s in the ring and we’re in the back – no one has talked to her consignor with the vet report notebook, that I’ve seen.  There’s no bid on her until it plummets to $1,000, and even then it’s slow enough for the auctioneer to offer $500 increments.  Half in shock, we bid 2, and then 3… another long pause… am I getting two horses, really?… but this time the bids slowly continue.  We’re out, but the ‘what if’ game is playing in my head again.  I’m now rooting for her price to creep out of what was my price range, and as if more intrigue were absolutely needed, she’s sold for exactly $10,000.  Relief?  I’ll get back to you with the verdict in two or three years!

In the next 2 hours I was able to eat a celebratory lunch in the Keeneland cafeteria, help load Mark’s sharp fillies (watch out for Magna Money) onto his trailer for the ride back to Northeast Ohio, and visit the colt who’d already been delivered to the nearby farm and turned out even before I’d jumped back into the Impala.

theguy

http://www.margauxfarm.com/team.html

It ain’t cheap, but the facility is fabulous and the staff come highly recommended throughout the industry.  Depending upon their observations and assessment of his talent level, I’ll spend the winter researching the racetracks and scouting for the right trainer.  I’m not averse to reducing my monthly expenses by selling fractional ownership to some friends, but I like him too much to just own a piece!

We reach 3:30 pm and there’s two hours until I need to be at the airport.

I’ve got just enough time for some of that ‘local cuisine’.

ways

 

21 thoughts on “Travelogue: Keeneland Part 5 (the final day)”

  • CONGRATS

    These articles deserve a butt load of credits (whoever gives them out , just empty the BTB account)

    I was pretty invested in this story all the way lol .. Each new part was like waiting for the next GOT episode to come out … I was thinking oh no after all this time he won’t get a horse

    Hands down the best articles I’ve read for a long long time , thanks for the story

    • beisbolPost author

      Thank-you, I’m glad people enjoyed them. There’s definitely a cathartic and addictive element to this whole process of scouting for the next bargain blue chipper!

    • beisbolPost author

      Thanks, that’s great! Quick.City is actually one of the names I had on the short list for my little retirement fund.

  • Great stuff Donny and congrats. Looking forward to the follow-up stories.

  • stockswami

    Congrats beisbol….and the ride begins! I have owned and still own a piece of a number of horses in partnership with West Point Thoroughbreds and there is nothing like the experience. Still I have never been through the experience you described of being the person making all the decisions. The satisfaction must be amazing to spend the time and find one of these amazing athletes to be in a barn you call your own. Good luck and I hope you will keep us advised of how his growth and march towards the races transpires.

  • duanecrisp

    You lived out my dream….. My heart would not hold up well to that kind of stress.. May all your dreams come true with this colt.

    Question: I know that the Keeneland is the premiere yearling sales of the year but are they all Kentucky breds. The reason I ask is because the sire of your horse you have has had a lot of NY breds by that sire I believe..

    Please correct me if I’m wrong

    • beisbolPost author

      Thanks for the well wishes! This sale was open to horses bred anywhere. Temple City covered a whole bunch of mares, so I’m not surprised you find foals of his throughout the country.

  • fastnfirm

    May your analytics not be crap!

    Personally, I never liked that chili over spaghetti noodles….

    • beisbolPost author

      LOL yeah that place has only sentimental value for me… could not really understand why people go crazy over that stuff. I ate the black bean variation with ‘habanero cheese’.

  • testbarn

    well it sounds like you got your moneys worth already(the rush). i truly hope it works out, because you got the one i liked on paper and the knee tweek can only end in disaster. So congrats and keep us posted buddy.

    steve

  • tseals1

    You lived the dream many of us have. So cool that you have the determination/ability to make it happen. Really hope you found a runner, but no matter what you found an adventure, and that’s worth something in itself.

    And next time, Netflix this series. I wanted to binge-watch it, not wait days in between….

  • beisbolPost author

    Thanks everyone, so many replies so I am just going to respond here at the end. I’m hoping to go back sometime in November if anyone wants to tag along 🙂

  • bbudgies

    Congratulations Donny,he’s a nice horse and he looks like has that confident look good horses have,takes it all in and say’s look at me

    Good luck with him

  • dixiedotco

    Thoroughly enjoyed reading this type of experience in detail, Donny. Found myself chuckling at a lot of little things that I could relate to. And I actually learned quite a bit, too! Will definitely be following along as he grows up.

  • kashbarn

    Great job with the series!!! lots of cliff hangers at the end of each article to keep us ‘tuned in’!!!

  • awkwardandchai

    Thank you so much for sharing your experience at Keeneland. Your storytelling abilities are fantastic. Though my journey to Kentucky may be just a dream, in your pages the dream is realized and I am grateful. Best of luck w/ your colt. Any ideas as what to name him?

Leave a Reply