Blacktype Blitz
What makes a good sire? The answer to this question will vary depending on who you ask. For some people it is the stallion himself, there is an emotional connection to the horse so they will use him. Along the same lines some people prefer certain Stud Farms or Breeding locations. I like to use Coolmore Stallions because they give a lot of information about their horses on their web site including breeding suggestions. I also like to use French based sires because I am a Francophile. I am sure others have like preferences that cannot be easily categorized. Some people want to just get a winner. Others want cheap sires who can produce productive and lucrative BP earning claimers. Then there are all of us who aspire to be in the winner’s circle at the end of Blacktype events. We want the shiny hardware and the blankets of flowers.
Luckily for you I have assembled the mother of all Sire lists in regards to Blacktype Runners in the SIM. This list addresses all horses born in 2016 so all the current 3yos. There will be late bloomers from some of these horses but since we have passed through the majority of the Classic season (and those that are good enough are likely already good enough) this is who produced the best horses. The first list is the general sire list based on Stakes Winning % of all horses with over 50 runners. I list the number of runners they have, the Stallion and his SW %.
- 159 Oasis Dream 11.3%
- 167 Dansili 10.2%
- 190 Dubawi 10%
- 173 Curlin 9.3%
- 197 Tapit 9.1%
- 133 Sepoy 9%
- 153 City Zip 8.5%
- 109 Golden Horn 8.3%
- 170 Bernardini 8.2%
- 144 Speightstown 7.6%
- 251 Awesome Again 7.6%
- 174 War Front 7.5%
- 69 The Factor 7.3%
- 83 Trippi 7.2%
- 113 Mineshaft 7.1%
- 100 Drosselmeyer 7%
- 190 Distorted Humor 6.8%
- 134 Darci Brahma 6.7%
- 199 Frankel 6.5%
- 210 Sea the Stars 6.2%
Before we analyze this let’s look at the six worst stallions with over 175 runners, I will also include their Graded winning % here to avoid redundancy when I list the top Stallions by GW% as this group is equally lower in that regard.
- 206 American Pharoah 5.8%/1.5%
- 177 Galileo 5.7%/1.7%
- 178 Deep Impact 5.6%/1.1%
- 277 Giant’s Causeway 5.4%/1.4%
- 190 Pioneerof the Nile 5.3%/2.1%
- 176 Medaglia d’Oro 3.4%/0.6%
This list is rather illuminating is it not? Dubawi, Curlin and Tapit all look like they are performing how Breeders would expect and represent top value to stakes aspirants. It does appear that Awesome Again and Distorted Humor are slipping. Golden Horn is both under-used and clearly the best first year sire. The Factor and Trippi represent tremendous value. Giant’s Causeway is a money pit, I would rate him as the worst value in the game. He has the most runners and one of the worst stakes winning % among top stallions and his GW% is cover your eyes awful. Medaglia d’Oro is a close second. He simply cannot get you a black type horse. He has one graded winner out of 176 runners. Galileo seems to be suffering from slippage and breeders have caught onto this as his 177 breedings are quite low for one of the top Stallions in the world. Next we will look at the top twenty Stallion in terms of Graded Winning % with over 50 runners. Many of the same stallions appear although there are others who look like they can get a big horse.
- Dubawi 4.2%
- City Zip 3.3%
- Mission Impazible 3.3%
- Oasis Dream 3.1%
- Tapit 3.1%
- Frankel 3%
- Drosselmeyer 3%
- Sepoy 3%
- Dansili 3%
- Curlin 2.9%
- War Chant 2.8%
- Lonhro 2.7%
- Mineshaft 2.7%
- Malibu Moon 2.6%
- Empire Maker 2.6%
- Shamardal 2.5%
- Pour Moi 2.5%
- Camelot 2.5%
- Lea 2.5%
- Siyouni/Sea the Stars/Le Havre/Dutch Art 2.4%
Based on these numbers the best sires in the SIM at the moment are Dubawi, Oasis Dream, Tapit, Dansili and Curlin. There is a set of stallions like Empire Maker, Malibu Moon, Shamardal, Camelot and so on who can get you a big horse but can also throw you a bunch of plodders yet still represent a gamblers proposition and might be considered good value if you are looking for that monster horse but are willing to accept an allowance horse(or worse) if you miss. There is also quite a bit of value out there as well. This next list looks at the best SW% of Stallions with under 50 breedings (but over 20 to give us some sort of sample size). Many of these stallions are cheap. I haven’t used many of these and I believe, based on these numbers, they deserve a closer look. I again list number of runners first in this list.
- 35 Mr. Sidney 8.6%
- 36 Abbeyside 8.3%
- 32 The Lumber Guy 6.3%
- 32 Tiz Wonderful 6.1%
- 49 Gold Allure 6.1%
- 34 Hat Trick 5.9%
- 34 Falco 5.9%
- 35 Rip Van Winkle 5.7%
- 38 Soaring Empire 5.3%
- 38 Wanted 5.3%
- 38 Monterosso 5.3%
- 40 Authorized 5%
- 41 Governor Charlie 4.9%
- 42 Town Prize 4.8%
- 42 Twice Over 4.8%
- 43 Most Improved 4.7%
- 44 Lord of England 4.6%
- 47 Include 4.3%
- 24 Boston Harbor 4.2%
- 49 George Vancouver 4.1%
Lots of cheap options here to take a risk free shot on. It seems that the SIM has rated Include correctly (he has a recent New Yorker winner as well), seems like Authorized is doing fairly well despite slight support. Mr. Sidney, Gold Allure and Hat Trick look like outstanding values. This next list is ranked by GW% of Stallions with less than 50 runners but more than 20.
- Gold Allure 4.1%
- Successful Appeal 3.2%
- Powerscourt 3%
- Hat Trick 2.9%
- Daddy Long Legs 2.8%
- Born to Sea 2.9%
- Rip Van Winkle 2.9%
- Mr. Sidney 2.9%
- El Roca 2.9%
- Sidney’s Candy 2.7%
- Shocking 2.7%
- Power Broker 2.6%
- Fort Larned 2.4%
- Rattlesnake Bridge 2.4%
- Governor Charlie 2.4%
- Pleasantly Perfect 2.3%
- Invasor 2.3%
- Include 2.1%
- George Vancouver 2%
- None left….
These 19 Stallions represent real value as they likely have not seen the ‘big’ name DS so they would in theory react well with them as the same breedings have not been hammered dozens of times. This list also has to give a little hope to California Chrome fans as both Invasor and Pleasantly Perfect, very good older horses who had modest pedigrees are still able to produce the occasional graded horse. Finally let’s take a look at the group of broken dreams – these stallions all have over 90 runners with only 1 graded winner. These horses are terrible value for their cost in relation to the number, or in this case, only graded runner they produced.
Exceed and Excel, Speightstown, More Than Ready, Medaglia d’Oro, Big Blue Kitten, Muhaarar, I’ll Have Another, I am Invincible, English Channel, Fed Biz, Union Rags, War Command, Noble Mission, Kodiac, Lion Heart, Farhh, Gio Ponti, Zensational, Novellist, Mastercraftsman, Acclamation, Tiznow, Magician, Eskendereye, Take Charge Indy, Declaration of War, Hard Spun, Street Sense, Zoffany, Pivotal, Point of Entry, Darci Brahma and Arch.
There are a lot of big names here. Some of them have what you might deem acceptable SW % but their GW % is non-existent. I would say use all of them at your own risk, the numbers are telling you that you won’t be getting a graded winner especially as many of these stallions are what you would consider precocious who should have produced their best runners now – ie you wouldn’t expect them to suddenly get better as 4yos. I hope these numbers will be useful to you as a guide as to which Stallions are producing right now. You will no doubt be able to draw your own conclusions from these data sets.
Nice work Waremblem, breeders take note
this is some powerful analysis. thanks for taking the time to break it down
testbarn
Thanks – I really learned some things when pulling this data. I was wrong about Sea the Stars who appears to be rated exactly how he should. There certainly seems to be an age factor taking place here. It seems like too large of a coincidence that Awesome Again, Distorted Humor, Galileo, More the Ready and Giant’s Causeway are all in decline. I mean the common denominator is they are all getting up there in age. Also all nerfs are not the same. For example, Mineshaft was nerfed last year but he is still a top 20 Stallion.