Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

PICTURE THAT 2

PICTURE THAT 2

conformation

Presented to you by Racing HQ

What is the key element of the mating, the Sire or the Dam ? In the Sim and IRL I would definitely say the Sire in most cases. But the Dam is of utmost importance in both realms. In a lot of cases the right sire can upgrade the mares foal but at times it doesn’t matter what sire is used, if the mare is no good the foal generally is no good. One caveat, if your mare is by a high quality sire the odds increase exponentially of upgrading the mare. In the Sim, more so. There are many hidden elements attached to fillies and mares as to why they fail on the track we may not be aware of but if they have the right blood it may be wise to give them a shot in the breeding barn. I was new to a stud years ago and I inspected all the mares, 300 or so, and all the pedigrees with a view to matching them to our 6 stallions and some outside stallions. Her name eludes me but she was a stunner by a gun sire and good family. She had no track performance and her first 2 foals never made it to the track. On further inspection I noticed she had shocking feet, she had 4 white socks and experience tells me white feet can bring feet problems, the hoof (cuticle) isn’t as strong. I rang her trainer and he told me she was never pain free and had a myriad of feet issues. I then rang the trainers of the 2 previous foals, you guessed it , same deal. Both those foals were by a Vice Regent stallion, yep, he had 2 front white socks and quite flat feet. The owners gave up and hadn’t bred her for a few years, they used her as a foster for orphaned foals. I convinced them to let me try with her. I did my research and found a sire that invariably stamped his stock plain bay, even with pretty mares like her. Bred her successfully to Zephyr Bay, near black. I left before any results were in but I received a call from the vet a couple of years later and he informed me the 2 year old won a barrier trial at Flemington by 6 lengths in very fast time. I was pretty chuffed. I think we all have had mares that were legless on the track in the Sim but at stud it turns out a different matter. We are also lucky to be able to he-mare so let’s take a look at the 1st 33 on the Dam Sire list. I will give a short overview of each and you will notice some familiar names appear, remember our Sires list from the previous post. There are also a few things we will touch on later.

KINGMAMBO    NORTHERN DANCER

KINGMAMBO     MR PROSPECTOR LINE

DIRT 34%/66% TURF     SPRINT 31%/69% ROUTE Type Rating 8

 

sadlerswells    NORTHERN DANCER

SADLER’S WELLS     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 31%/69% TURF     SPRINT 73%/27% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

MR P     Raise_a_Native

MR PROSPECTOR     RAISE A NATIVE LINE

DIRT 63%/37% TURF     SPRINT 48%/52% ROUTE Type Rating 5

 

STORM CAT    NORTHERN DANCER

STORM CAT     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 64%/36% TURF     SPRINT 50%/50% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

apindy     Nasrullah

A.P. INDY     NASRULLAH LINE

DIRT 61%/39% TURF     SPRINT 39%/61% ROUTE Type Rating 9.5

 

danzig     NORTHERN DANCER

DANZIG     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 54%/46% TURF     SPRINT 44%/56% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

SEATTLE SLEW    Nasrullah

SEATTLE SLEW     NASRULLAH LINE

DIRT 59%41% TURF     SPRINT 38%/62% ROUTE Type Rating 6

 

DANEHILL     NORTHERN DANCER

DANEHILL     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 28%/72% TURF     SPRINT 38%/62% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

SEEKING THE GOLD     Mr Prospector

SEEKING THE GOLD     MR PROSPECTOR LINE

DIRT 60%/40% TURF     SPRINT 47%/53% ROUTE Type Rating 5

 

deputy minister    NORTHERN DANCER

DEPUTY MINISTER     NORTHERN DANCER LINE DIRT

69%/31% TURF     SPRINT 36%/64% ROUTE Type Rating 7

 

nureyev     NORTHERN DANCER

NUREYEV     NORTHERN DANCER LINE DIRT

46%/54% TURF     SPRINT 34%/66% ROUTE Type Rating 8

 

GIANTS CAUSEWAY     NORTHERN DANCER

GIANT’S CAUSEWAY     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 44%/56% TURF     SPRINT 40%/60% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

DYNAFORMER    HailToReason

DYNAFORMER     HAIL TO REASON LINE

DIRT 33%/67% TURF     SPRINT 29%/71% ROUTE Type Rating 7

 

FORTY NINER     Mr Prospector

FORTY NINER     MR PROSPECTOR LINE

DIRT 69%/31% TURF     SPRINT 50%/50% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

Kris S    HailToReason

KRIS S.     HAIL TO REASON LINE

DIRT 34%/66% TURF     SPRINT 26%/74% ROUTE Type Rating 6.5

 

Montjeu     NORTHERN DANCER

MONTJEU     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 73%/27% TURF     SPRINT 25%/75% ROUTE Type Rating 7

 

Gone West      Mr Prospector

GONE WEST     MR PROSPECTOR LINE

DIRT 55%/45% TURF     SPRINT 51%/49% ROUTE Type Rating 6

 

UNBRIDLED      Mr Prospector

UNBRIDLED     MR PROSPECTOR LINE

DIRT 70%/30% TURF     SPRINT 35%/65% ROUTE Type Rating 6

 

DISTORTED HUMOR      Mr Prospector

DISTORTED HUMOR     MR PROSPECTOR LINE

DIRT 60%/40% TURF     SPRINT 49%/51% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

GALILEO      NORTHERN DANCER

GALILEO (IRE)     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 21%/79% TURF     SPRINT 34%/66% ROUTE Type Rating 10

 

Caerleon     NORTHERN DANCER

CAERLEON     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 29%/71% TURF     SPRINT 24%/76% ROUTE Type Rating 7

 

AWESOME AGAIN     NORTHERN DANCER

AWESOME AGAIN     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 62%/38% TURF     SPRINT 44%/56% ROUTE Type Rating 7

 

STREET CRY     Mr Prospector

STREET CRY     MR PROSPECTOR LINE

DIRT 49%/51% TURF     SPRINT 42%/58% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

pivotal     NORTHERN DANCER

PIVOTAL     NORTHERN DANCER LINE

DIRT 25%/75% TURF     SPRINT 40%/60% ROUTE Type Rating 9

 

OK, well that covers the 1st 33 Sires and Dam Sires, one observation for me and hopefully for you is the 2 prominent lines, Northern Dancer and Mr Prospector. The Northern Dancer line shows out with quite correct legs and generally handsome types where as the Mr Prospect line obviously, to me, comes with leg issues in most cases and varied shape/attractiveness. So, again to me, this explains one aspect of the great success with the cross of the two, one compliments the other or ND assists with Mr P short comings. Also did you notice the difference in surface/distance ratings (Sire to Dam Sire), due in part to our breeding, interesting. Next issue we will cover 34 – 67 on the sire list. Good luck.

conformation 2

gcliffo (Greg)

6 thoughts on “PICTURE THAT 2”

  • waremblem5

    This is where the SIM diverges quite a bit from real life. Everyone will notice that this list is virtually identical to the sire list, except of course for the horses who are dead but all of them are the big names. DS are very difficult to rate because it takes even longer for a horse to get a number of mares out there producing runners than it does a stallion. So how do you rate them? It seems many just use the sire ranking would be my guess which is why the lists match up. IRL if you look at the top 35 Broodmares in the Northern Hemisphere you get the likes of…

    Sunday Silence #2
    Unbridled’s Song #5
    French Deputy #7
    Machiavellian #8
    Elusive Quality #11
    In Excess #15 (though aided by Always Dreaming)
    Grand Slam #16
    Forest Wildcat #17
    Brian’s Time #18
    Mr. Greeley, Rahy, Dixie Union, Gilded Time, Malibu Moon, Pulpit and so on.

    There were announced changes in the SIM where it was said the DS and DDS would require even more ‘juice’ for a horse to be good. Does this mean more of Northern Dancer/Mr. P sons and Indy/Storm Cats? Where does the diversity of the gene pool come from? It is possible to break out of the rather narrow focus of the majority of expensive SIM horses? It is my experience that the majority of expensive bred SIM horses were put together with rather little imagination. This is one of the reasons where Knightmare’s Bargin Bred Series fascinates me – you can tell that people put a lot of thought into some of those breedings trying to find some gold dust.

    I don’t know how much experimentation the SIM actually allows. Breeding a horse with a non-traditional DS is a blueprint on how to get a debut of a 47 SF. To shake things up let’s look at the DS of recent Epsom Derby winners…

    Kendor
    Xaar
    Dubai Destination
    Cape Cross
    Kingmambo
    Kingmambo
    Darshaan
    Sadler’s Wells
    Miswaki
    Ahonoora
    Saumarez

    That’s the last decade so we see the SIM has Kingmambo pretty much nailed but what about the rest? Now I’m not saying that Saumarez should get a high rating just because he was the DS of a Classic winner but we need to have options which have a reasonable chance for success other than the 40 or so big name Stallions don’t we? I’m in the same boat as everyone else, I have a whole bunch of Storm Cat, Indy, Kingmambo, Sadler’s Wells mares to use every year and I tell you, it gets rather redundant. There is also the deflating feeling of mass replication as in congrats, you are the 12th person to breed Curlin to a Storm Cat mare this year.

    • gcliffoPost author

      I hear you Waremblem and also tend to agree but If you take a look at SWr, SW%, GWr and GW% on the DAM SIRE page it tells a different story, seems they all get the chance and are capable of getting top horses. Granted there are big differences from top to bottom but the game is very condensed in comparison to RL. If you have a big time mare you can get to any top sire you wish at the push of a button. Also of note, the top sires, like Giants Causeway had 277 foals in 2016, and most are super breeds and from great mares, a complex issue that Mike seems to have handled pretty good under the circumstances. I have had numerous blue bloods not worth a crumpet as we all have and take a look at Dark Mandu, Rapid Grey, King Tachyon, Joe Cayenne, Horseshoe Bay, all big HOF horses and others. I believe Mike has tinkered with the breeding already, not convinced that more needs to change but an interesting debate all the same.

  • Great work Greg.

    I tend to agree with WarEmblem5, been playing this sim a lot of years now, and it is worrying that the route to success (as in group/graded success) does seem to be narrower nowadays. Not sure what the solution would be however.

    • gcliffoPost author

      Hey Scout, further to my Waremblem comments, I came to late to get in on the Storm Cat, Kingmambo, A.P. Indy, Distorted Humor, Unbridled’s Song mares, a stellar group that seems impossible to match which will last for 10 years or more, must have an impact. Generally speaking I have nothing but admiration for the job Mike has done, boggles my mind to think how I could improve on it.

      • Oh I certainly agree with that Greg. The job Mike has done over the life of the sim has been amazing.

Leave a Reply