Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

General

Derby Runners Fail in the Middle

Half of the field lined up in the Middle Stake contained runners who ran in the Bluegrass Derby.  Expectations ran high that one of these runners would take the Middle, with much hope that we could possibly have a Triple Crown winner in Carl’s Shameless, the winner of the Bluegrass.

As it turned out none of the Derby runners would take any of the top three spots.   The three top positions all went to horses that ran in Derby prep races and failed to get the lock.  They each skipped the Derby and entered into the Middle.

Opticated, who finished third in the California Derby behind Bluegrass winner Carl’s Shameless, came out on top and won the Middle Stakes.

Second to cross the wire was Empire Logo Ted who also finished third in a derby lock race, the Arkansas Juvenile, losing out to Worldclass Funny.

Marine Warrior was also in the Arkansas Juvenile, but finished further back in the 7th spot.   He concluded the Middle Stakes in third place.

Worldclass Funny finished fourth in the Middle Stakes, the highest placed finisher of all the Bluegrass Derby entrants.  This was an improvement from the sixth place finish he had in the Bluegrass.

The Middle Stakes also had a filly in the race, Treacherously II.  She was the winner of the Bluegrass Oaks (for the ladies) and she rallied late to take fifth.  She had an equal amount of rest as the Bluegrass Derby runners and she outran 6 of the 7 boys that entered into the Middle Stakes.  This girl has something to believe in.

 

The remainder of all the Bluegrass Derby entrants finished in the rear of the Middle Stakes field:

Stormin Curlin Cat improved the most of all the Bluegrass runners as he came in 8th, much better than the 17th finish in the Derby and also finished a dozen lengths closer to the winner.

Caribbean Ghost was 7th in the Bluegrass but could not improve off that finish in the Middle where he crossed the line in 9th.

Better At Midnight who ran 3rd in the Derby and 5 off the winner finished further back in the Middle, 11 back and back in 11th.

Derby winner Carl’s Shameless, who won by two strides, could not replicate the results finishing 12th and about 14 strides off the winner.

Thirteenth place was borne to Monstous Cause.  He finished 9th, which was a mid-field finish in the 20 horse Bluegrass race, but this time was next to last in the Middle.

Lock The Doors hasn’t found the key yet.  He finished last in the Bluegrass and also last in the Middle.  I don’t know if any horse has finished last in each of the Triple Crown races, but Lock the Doors has a shot at it.

 

So why did the Derby horses fair so poorly?   It could be related to the fact that the Bluegrass runners only had two weeks rest between races and not enough time to fully recover from the exertion that was demanded in the Bluegrass race (which is my guess).   The top three finishers all ran in Derby prep races and had the benefit of a nice rest break between races, which further supports my guess.   Race conditions were different between the two events, with the Bluegrass being Good and the Middle being Fast which may have had an effect, but seeing that all of the Bluegrass runners have done well on Fast tracks in the past, I tend to throw this out.   The race distance was shorter, which should also be considered.  This was only by 1/2-furlong.  For most of the Bluegrass runners, the 10 furlong distance was the longest they had run.  Scaling back by a half-furlong should not have been a big deal, in my opinion.

It will be interesting to see what views our readers have on this topic.

 

 

 

 

 

 

12 thoughts on “Derby Runners Fail in the Middle”

  • waremblem5

    The race will drive you crazy trying to analyze it. The 2nd and 3rd place finishers have not even won a graded race. To finish better than all but one horse in a field that contains 11 graded winners? In fact there were only 3 non-graded winners in this race and they finished 2nd, 3rd and 6th an extremely strong showing. The 4th place finisher, Worldclass Funny appears to have a legitimate Derby excuse on the off track. His run in both the Preakness and the AK Derby were far better than what he did Derby day. His connections can rightly wonder what might have been on a fast track at Churchill. Of course the other possibility is that 9f is his limit for graded company.

    While many hoped Carl’s Shameless would break the trend, thanks to Trotter’s research, we all likely knew it was a long shot. The 2 week turn around in G1 company seems too much in the SIM. And likely for good reason, while the Triple Crown is a special set of races, imagine if those restrictions were not in place. We would have some horses running in G1s every couple weeks and I don’t think anyone wants to see that. Of course the other thing just might be that we haven’t seen a great horse win the Bluegrass Derby in a while and if we do see say a 5/5 or 6/6 horse win the Bluegrass maybe he will be able to carry on and win the Preakness on short rest.

  • I always thought a horse who didn’t run in the Derby would win , I put it down to a fast turnaround, not enough rest , which turned out correct

  • dixiedotco

    The game just isn’t designed to allow horses to run at or near the peak of their ability off only 2 weeks rest. Were these runners entered straight away and therefore “trained” to the date of the race? And if so, were they sharp from that training? I’m guessing no. That alone puts any horse at a huge disadvantage, but even moreso when running in a G1 race where there are no pushovers.

    • The runner-up in the Derby missed the Middle Jewel specifically because of what you mention.

    • canyongate

      Can only speak for mine Steve, she came out of the Oaks on rtg which left open the option of the Middle Jewel. I waited a bit enter her, weighing other options in the coming weeks, but felt the spot was worth taking a shot in as she was headed to the farm regardless of where her next was. She did come up sharp but either doesn’t like it past 9 or was short coming off a tough early campaign. Hopefully she bounces back well after a much needed rest 🙂

  • Does anyone care to share their feelings on two Turf sires winning the first two legs of the Triple Crown? I get that they both had dirt backends, but at the same time this is something we would not see In real life….I have mixed feelings on it, while I want the sim to be as close to real life as posissible, part of what makes the sim great is you get to try and do things with breeding in the sim that you probably wouldn’t seen done in real life.

    • waremblem5

      I care a great deal but I already voiced my opinions on this last year. Too many turf horses win dirt G1s. Turf Stallions have a massive advantage over dirt stallions in this game. Look, that’s the way the game has went, it is no longer a simulation of American racing it is a simulation of Overseas turf racing with some dirt races thrown in. I’m not sure what the Australian Classic Races are, but of the American and European (and Japanese) Classics for colts this year:

      Kentucky Derby – Shamardal
      Preakness Stakes – Frankel
      2000 Guineas – Deep Impact
      French 2000 Guineas – Dubawi
      Irish 2000 Guineas – Lawman
      Japanese 2000 Guineas – Dubawi

      Since I won one of these races you can see I have adapted my breeding. I no longer consider dirt sires even close to the value of turf sires in this game. I mean look who won the real Derby and Preakness – Bodemeister and MacLean’s Music. In his 469 SIM horses Bodemeister has 3 graded winners (all G3s). That is 0.6%. I mean you just can’t get a graded level Bodemeister. MacLean’s Music actually has some SIM value and is underused.

      • For what its worth as a total novice with US based racing…

        In Australia (in real life) we see so many US sires having an impact with our Turf Racing..

        Medaglia Doro – has given us a Golden Slipper winner (2yo 6f turf G1 – richest 2yo race in the world)
        Other sires we see have seen having success down under;
        Bernadini, More than Ready, Hard Spun, Uncle Mo, Elusive Quality.. the list goes on..

        Now i wonder how many Aus, Eu and Japanese sires we see being used for US dirt runners??

        I think the sim is showing us what could happen in reality if Turf sires actually got used in the US for dirt racing…i know this is very easy to say, but id be interested to see how many turf sired runners actually get a go on dirt?

        And as for the sim… I feel we see a few dirt bred runners having success on Turf also…the Derby and MJ winner were both from dirt running mares with total dirt backend breeding…..And maybe we just see more Turf bred runners because there are simply more sires available?? I know when i go to breed a dirt runner the sires are usually a lot more expensive and harder to find…

        Just my 2 cents worth…

        • waremblem5

          I agree, dirt sires are more expensive and harder to find because so many of them come into the SIM and are poorly rated so those that can actually get graded winners are in high demand. 469 people tried to get a good Bodemeister and 466 failed. And Bodemeister has a stellar pedigree. I’m not going to debate if Galileo sons had chances to run on dirt they would dominate dirt racing again. When we do see American Stallions face Euros/Japanese on the dirt they smash them just like we saw in the recent Dubai World Cup. The Pegasus Cup likely will start drawing more Euros as well for the massive purse so we will have more evidence.

          In the SIM it’s not really a point of who was bred to whom. I am sure there are loads of dirt stallions bred to G1 turf mares. Yet in the current classic season we have not seen one win on the turf. Of course that is a small sample size. Anyway, as I said, it doesn’t matter what one person thinks or doesn’t think this is the way the game is now and you can either go with the value or bang your head against the wall. The sires of the horses I liked in the KY Derby and Oaks (Bodemeister and Union Rags) this year I didn’t even bother using because I already know the odds are severely stacked against those stallions.

          • There is some historical precedent for turf sires on dirt with the Tessio horses but that was a long time ago. I agree that many of the dirt sires are under performing and many turf sires over perform in the sim. I can’t get my head wrapped around it honestly. Frankly it annoys me to the point where I just refuse to spend any money on the game anymore.

  • Its an interesting set of questions and i think its most likely a combination of all factors.

    – The rest between the Cal Derby Prep and the MJ has to have assisted the MJ winner. It also have to have impacted those who backed up.. no doubt about it, the game does not favour runners as 3yo having 2 weeks break.

    – The winner of the MJ missed the Derby based on not getting a run based on points – it should also be mentioned that he could have possibly won the Derby if he ran? He finished 3rd in the lock over 9F making up some 7L in the final 2f – if it were a 10F trial, chances are he beats Carls first time.. but then would he win the MJ? That we shall never know!

    – The off track has to impact the result also. We have seen on numerous occasions some horses on the sim love the wet track… some do not.. Again – considering all things to be equal. A wet Derby into a dry MJ would take its toll.

    – The breeding… He is by a Turf sire with a total dirt back-end and his mare did win the Bluegrass Oaks. But i have no issues with the sire winning a big Dirt race at all… all around the world in real life we see dirt sires giving us a number of champ Turf runners. We dont see many Turf Sires give us dirt runners simply because there is no opportunity.. I think the sim gives an opportunity to see the opposite of real life, and for what its worth i think if US based breeders used international Turf sires and ran them on dirt that over time there would be success… no doubts in my mind.

    Anyhow…. now ive gone through all of this this jury is totally out on whether or not i back up Opticated (MJ Winners) in the grueling 12F 75% off track New Yorker…..

  • ddbargainbin

    Sim world and real world, LOL They’re not even close. Don’t get me started.

    Congrats to the winners of the TC races.

Leave a Reply