Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

GeneralHorses

Discarded Derby Wagers

I’m usually fairly self conscious about litter. I never throw trash out my Jeep’s window. I don’t toss cans into lakes. I even throw my grocery list away in the trash can outside the store. However, when making bets at the track I have been known to crumple them up and toss them on the floor in disgust. Today, when Almost Dreaming won the Kentucky Derby I realized this the first winner I had picked since 2002. That’s a lot of losing tickets. I decided to look back at all those lost Derby wagers I had in the past, memories of the horses who never got their name called in the stretch.

I wasn’t a born horse racing fan. While I was aware of the Kentucky Derby of course, I was a casual fan who followed the Triple Crown and that’s about it. I must admit I got pulled into the sport through an old Play Station game called Gallop Racer. That really hooked me as did the study of pedigrees and bloodlines which I devoured in reading and research. I would say 2000 was my first really informed Derby and that year I picked Fusaichi Pegasus because he was a son of Mr. Prospector and had an awesome name. I won that Derby with FuPeg and thought, alright, alright I might be good at this. The next year I picked Monarchos because he was a grey bomber. This was one of the more thrilling Derbys and the call “here comes Monarchos” still gives me chills when I watch the replays. In 2002 I really fell in love with War Emblem because of his front runner style and his almost black color. As you might notice I was 3/3 in Derby picks and felt I either had a knack for this or was getting really lucky.

Lady Luck it was as I would not pick another winner until 2017. 15 years of bums and busted picks. What went wrong? Let’s take a look. In 2003 I was all about Empire Maker. I thought he was a god horse of royal breeding who was going to be a legend. Needless to say he underperformed in his career in relation to my expectations. I really hated Funny Cide. Look, I didn’t even bold him. He was a no name gelding who ruined the party for what I felt was the genetically superior horse. I was a bit of a snob back then.

In 2004 I was at a Derby Party at Northville Downs watching the race with my girlfriend at the time Rebecca. We were there with some friends and I kept talking up my horse Lion Heart. I was already hooked on Storm Cat and A.P. Indy so Lion Heart was my guy, a son of Tale of the Cat with a great name. Rebecca was going for Smarty Jones. Well we know how it turned out, I did cash a winning ticket on the W/P/S Lion Heart bet but all night Rebecca kept saying “I’m so Smart” drawing out Smart like Smaaaaaaaaart. I was against Smarty in the Preakness too but I admit I got a little choked up when he was triple teamed in the Belmont yet still turned for home on the lead then the anguish in the call as Birdstone passes him in the stretch. BTW I can’t believe that was 13 years ago.

I liked Afleet Alex more than any other Derby horse so far. I was all over this one because I still maintain that he would have won the Triple Crown had Rose not blown the finish and let Giacomo sneak past him. Alex would of course go onto win the Preakness and Belmont but his career was cut far too short. Even though I had not made a correct Derby pick in a while I was still getting 2nds.

2006 was the first Derby I attended. I made $400 on Oaks day then gave back $350 on Derby day. For the whole Derby trail I was very high on Bluegrass Cat who I was certain would become Storm Cat’s Derby winner. However, after his brutal Bluegrass I bailed on him and went with A.P. Warrior. Brian and I even had a chant on the Derby infield…A.P. Warrior (clap clap clap) A.P. Warrior. Good God I think we even told Chris Rock in the Gault House elevator to take A.P. Warrior. Well he finished 16th or 17th but we did get to see the tragic Barbaro win the Derby.  Oh, I just looked, AP actually finished 18th. There are only 20 horses in the field.

I was conflicted in 2007, I couldn’t really decide between Any Given Saturday and Curlin. I ended up going with Any Given Saturday but it was really close. Neither won, but Curlin would have at least given me yet another 2nd. Any Given Saturday was a distant 8th. Curlin turned out to be an odd horse for me. I was for him in the Preakness because I thought Street Sense got lucky in the Derby but I was a HUGE Rags to Riches fan so I was strongly against him in the Belmont. I then really liked Curlin as an older horse culminating in me cheering him on to victory at Saratoga from the roof of the track clubhouse.

Back in Kentucky for the 2008 Derby, I did it in style this time as we had a suite at the Gault House with a balcony over the river and were in the Grandstand. I think everyone should try the Derby both ways, the infield and the Grandstand it’s really two different experiences. My horse this year was the son of Tiznow, Colonel John. Colonel John finished 6th which was decent but still a bit disappointing. Eight Belles ran 2nd but she broke down and had to be euthanized. It was a bit unsettling that the two Derbys I attended saw a major deaths (Barbaro though in the Preakness).

I don’t think anyone was pleased with the 2009 Derby. I guess it did give us a decent horse racing movie in 50:1 and I kind of like how they make Baffert the villian in the movie. I didn’t much like any of the horses this year and ended up going with Friesan Fire because he was an A.P. Indy and had a cool name. Like Colonel John he finished 6th. There was some consolation in the fact no one had Mine that Bird. In retrospect I’m not sure why I didn’t like Pioneerof the Nile. 

Afleet Alex had his first son in the Derby in 2010 so that pretty much assured I was going to take Dublin. When you get older you look back and are astonished about some things, like how did I ever think a horse who had not won a race in 2010 was going to win the Derby? Sure he had won the G1 Hopeful as a 2yo but he was 2nd in the Southwest, 3rd in the Rebel and 3rd in the Arkansas Derby. I mean this horse had no chance. 20/1 wasn’t good enough odds to get. He finished 7th and it looked like I was no longer able to even find a horse who could hit the board.

I went with Stay Thirsty in 2011 and he ran up the track finishing 12rh or 13th. I can’t really remember much about this Derby. This is the most bland Derby of my life since I just more or less repeated the last sentence here and this is just some filler. More filler. Seriously I don’t have anything on this, looking it up I see Uncle Mo was scratched.

2012 had me switching back and forth between 3 horses, Take Charge Indy, Union Rags and Dullahan. Indy was an Indy who won the Florida Derby so he had a ton going for him. The Florida Derby is my favorite prep race and I place a lot of weight on it. However Dullahan has one of the coolest names ever as it is some sort of mythological Irish Headless horseman. Like that’s ultra cool. Plus he won the Bluegrass. Union Rags was a Dixie Union who I always liked the looks of and he had won the Champagne, Fountain of Youth and ran 3rd in the Florida Derby. Union Rags was my horse pre-FL Derby and Take Charge was my edging ahead of him after with the awesome sauce of Dullahan’s name tugging at me. I didn’t end up making my final pick till Derby Day and went with Take Charge Indy. None of them won, but at least you heard the names of the other two. Indy finished 19th, which in this case was last because one horse didn’t finish the race. Everyone has to pick one last place finisher I suppose. Union Rags ran 7th and Dullahan hit the board running 3rd.

Verrazano sucked me in during 2013, I felt he was More Than Ready’s best horse. I thought Verrazano was wickedly fast and felt really, really good about this one. He won the Tampa Bay Derby and crushed the Wood. I was getting him at 9/1 and it seemed like I could make quite a bit of money on this wager. Of course he finished 14th. This was getting ridiculous how was I going to break this miserable streak of losing?

I’m going to be honest with you, and it’s rather embarrassing because it was only 3 years ago. I cannot recall who I picked in 2014. I’m looking over the field right now and I simply can’t remember who was my Derby horse. I know it wasn’t the winner California Chrome but none of the horses look familiar. BTW what an awful Derby. I haven’t used a single sire from this field. Commanding Curve and Danza finished 2nd and 3rd. Maybe I liked Wicked Strong at 4? I just don’t know. I think the awfulness of this field made my brain erase it from memory. Have you seen the movie Inside Out? This Derby must have been flushed from my memory bank.

I would be late to the American Pharoah bandwagon not cheering for him until the Belmont. Dortmund was my horse this year and I felt he was a potential great horse. He moved like a machine and did end up running 3rd which had me finally hitting the board once again. I don’t know why things fell apart for Dortmund I think he should have had a better career after how great he started out. Last year I was all over Mohaymen early then I went over to Exaggerator late then switched back to Mohaymen. I was pretty close on these with Exaggerator finishing 2nd and Mohaymen 4th.

This then was the long path going from 2002 to 2017 between picking a Derby winner. Looking back the obvious ones were Nyquist, Barbaro, Smarty Jones and American Pharoah. In a way that is the philosophy I used this year – it was rather obvious Always Dreaming was the best horse and sometimes you just can’t overthink it. Clearly people pick horses for all sorts of reason – Patch got bet down to 13/1 today because he had a great story that far outweighed his talent. My take away from all this reflection is that A) it’s ok to make an emotional choice as long as you don’t mind losing and B) The best horse usually wins

 

2 thoughts on “Discarded Derby Wagers”

  • Oh that’s a cool article , I quite enjoyed reading that

    TBH I didn’t think I was going to read it all , next thing u know I was at the end

    Nice work

Leave a Reply