Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

General

The Bluegrass Derby, the Triple Crown and a History Lesson

Those of you that follow my Bluegrass Derby coverage know that my articles deal primarily with the attributes of a Bluegrass Derby winner.  A question was presented in my previous article inquiring about how many SIM horses have won at least one triple crown race AND finished 1-2-3 in Middle Jewel and New Yorker.

The History:

The first running of the Derby back in 1999 was not carded as a Grade I event although it did carry a $1,000,000 Purse.  There have been eighteen (18) previous Bluegrass Derby winners.  In 2003, the great I SEEK U became the first and only horse to win the Triple Crown. How difficult is that to accomplish, well let’s look inside the numbers.

First off, every Derby winner went on to race in the Middle Jewel with the aspirations of winning the Triple Crown, however only eleven Derby winners went on to compete in all three legs of the Triple Crown. Before I SEEK U distinguished himself as perhaps the greatest three-year old in Sim Racing history, two horses prior to his great feat knocked on the door of Sim immortality by winning after first two legs of the Triple Crown before being refused admission after failing to fulfill the demanding requirements of the 12-furlong New Yorker,  DOWN THE JAZZ in 2000, and BUDA WITH THE SLEW in 2001. No other Derby Winner, beside aforementioned, ever went on to win the first two legs of the Triple Crown.

The New Yorker has proven equally as elusive for the Bluegrass Derby winners with only I SEEK U, the 2006 winner VIRTUOSO, and the 2008 winner KISSIN STREETCRY capable of overcoming the challenges of the 12-furlong New Yorker. KISSIN STREETCRY was closest to completing the sweep when he just missed in the Middle Jewel, with just a half-length separating him from immortality.

Only three (3) horses have gone on to finish ITM (in the money) in all three legs of the Triple Crown, I SEEK U, KISSIN STREETCRY and 2007 winner ATAUN.

The Numbers: 

18 Bluegrass Derby winners

18 Derby winners raced in the Middle Jewel

3 Derby winners won the Middle Jewel

7 Derby winners finished ITM in the Middle Jewel

11 Derby winners raced in the New Yorker

3 Derby winners won the New Yorker

4 Derby winners finished ITM in the New Yorker

4 Derby winners did not hit the board in the final two legs of the Triple Crown

6 Derby winners passed on the New Yorker after failing to finish ITM in the Middle Jewel

1 Derby winners passed on the New Yorker despite finishing ITM in the Middle Jewel

12 thoughts on “The Bluegrass Derby, the Triple Crown and a History Lesson”

  • What jumps out is all 3 of the Derby/Middle Jewel winners come from the early days of the SIM. After those 3 only 4 of the remaining 15 even were ITM. So in today’s SIM the Derby winner has just over a 25% chance of even being in the money. Using that 18 year timeline IRL 7 of the 18 pulled off a Derby/Preakness exacta (War Emblem, Funny Cide, Smarty Jones, Big Brown, I’ll Have Another, California Chrome, American Pharoah). Considering the SIM is on a 0-14 streak of the Derby/Jewel combo I would conclude that the Derby horse IRL is much better than the SIM Derby winner.

    However – if we go back the previous 20 years 80-99, there are 6 who pulled it off (Charismatic, Real Quiet, Silver Charm, Sunday Silence, Alysheba, Pleasant Colony) pretty consistent with our recent 7. If we go back 60-79 we get robust 10 (Spectacular Bid, Affirmed, Seattle Slew, Secretariat, Canonero II, Majestic Prince, Forward Pass, Kauai King, Northern Dancer, Carry Back).

    Conclusion – the Bluegrass Derby winner does not perform nearly as well as real life horses. In fact it is so far off that it might merit a look at the coding where the Derby winner gets a ‘boost’ for the Preakness.

    • Yeah I came to the same conclusion

      I don’t like the chances of the Derby winner whoever it mite be in the last 2 legs of finishing ITM , let alone winning

      I don’t mind the idea of giving the Derby winner a small boost for the Preakness

    • trotter1Post author

      I have to agree with you on the disparity of the Real Life to Sim Derby/Jewel combo results and perhaps the answer can be found in the wear and tear of SIM three year old horses winning Graded races in the first half of the racing season. Your point is not without merit.

      I want it to be clear that it is not my intention to expose possible flaws in the games coding but merely to provide an entertainment level of information on perhaps the most popular races in the SIM. It is quite possible that all of this lopsided information presented in my articles is just coincidental, or possibly there may be several other reasons for such shortfalls, such as the trail of races leading up to the Middle Jewel.

      My hope is the reader draws his or her own conclusions from the facts presented and perhaps finds it helpful when breeding/racing their future Derby hopefuls.

      • I concur that it likely is the wear and tear of the Derby trail which knocks out the horses and I think this is actually modeled quite well. Each year we never hear from half the Derby horses again IRL. Part of it also no doubt is the 2 week turn around. I suspect in the coding that simply doesn’t fly with a lot of the SIM horses. It is highly unlikely that I’m ever going to win the Bluegrass Derby so I’m observing from a more or less neutral viewpoint. With that said I don’t think giving the Derby winner a small boost is unbalancing or unfair to the other Preakness horses. Preakness horses should fear the Derby winner just a bit.

        • trotter1Post author

          welcome to the highly unlikely that I’m ever going to win the Bluegrass Derby club. I was thinking more in the line of a tweak in the wear and tear factor…the fact that the only 3 runners to win both races came before a serious tweak in the wear and tear factor might point to the underlying issue.

  • Pretty good Pete, that’s a great data. Thank you once again….

  • Pete, Is there any trainer who won the triple crown with different horses?

    • trotter1Post author

      there was only 1 triple crown winner…if you mean is there any trainer who won a single triple crown with different horses, I could not tell you that off the top of my head and even with research trainers could have stables that are not linked that could hide multiple winners.

  • An elite number of only 18 over the thousands of horses bred every year have won the most prestigious DF 3yo race of the year. Congrats to all to OT’s!

    BTW; do you remember when the SIM Starting Gate expanded from 14 to 20 horses?

    • trotter1Post author

      it appears that the 1999 and 2000 Derby’s had a field of 12, what appears to be the max for any race during that era…The 2001 Derby was the first time the field was expanded to 20 horses while other race fields expanded to the current day 14.

  • This is all very interesting. And will be of more interest to more people than the question I actually meant to ask. What I actually wanted to know is how many horses have won ANY triple crown race and finished ITM in the other two legs.

    My reason for asking is purely selfish. My mare, You See L A, finished 2nd in the Derby, won the M J and finished a very tired but game 3rd in the NYer. I thought that was pretty damn good. Just wondering how many others have done as well.

  • I don’t think it’s wear and tear causing this, as said in the early years of the sim is was routine to race horses of any age every 2 weeks and they could do it time and time again even sometimes every week.recovery times where adjusted and all of a sudden the 2 week turn around was out the door. 3 to 4 weeks for 3yo and up and 5 to 8 weeks for 2yo’s.

Leave a Reply