Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

General

Scratch Bred Horses, Mare Bred Horses and the Bluegrass Derby

Those of you that have read my previous article, The 2017 Bluegrass Derby…An Early Look, saw a list of trends and criteria that make up a Bluegrass Derby winner.  I have been compiling these statistics for several years now and one of the more compelling trends is that since the incorporation of mare breeding and their eligibility to race in the Derby in 2002 only one scratch-bred horse has ever won the Bluegrass Derby and that was GRANHEE in 2004.  On the surface this is a very glaring statistic and for purposes of my articles, but simply stated it creates the dramatic effect that I want for my articles. The fact is that we do not know just how significant that statement is unless we look deeper into the numbers.

Are scratch-bred horses really at a disadvantage? 

Since 2002, three hundred (300) horses have entered the starting gate for the Bluegrass Derby.  One hundred and eight (108) were bred from scratch, that is 36%, certainly less than the number of mare bred horses that have raced in the Derby, but surely a large enough sample size for you to draw your own conclusion.  One scratch-bred Derby winner from those 108 that have raced in the Derby in the last 15 is dismal .009 % success rate, and a dreary .003% success rate of all the starters.

To further stress the significance of this trend I would like for you to consider this…Since 2007, when location tags were attached to all horses bred, forty-eight (48) horses bred outside of Kentucky raced in the Bluegrass Derby, that is 24% of the Derby starters, much lower than the 36% scratch-bred starters, yet four (4) non-KY bred starters have won the Bluegrass Derby or 8% of all non-KY bred starters and 2% of all the starters.

Below is the breakdown of scratch-bred vs. mare-bred starters in the Bluegrass since 2002:

2002 – 12 scratch-bred 8 mare-bred

2003 – 12 scratch-bred 8 mare-bred

2004 – 9 scratch-bred 11 mare-bred

2005 – 6 scratch-bred 14 mare-bred

2006 – 7 scratch-bred 13 mare-bred

2007 – 7 scratch-bred 13 mare-bred

2008 – 3 scratch-bred 17 mare-bred

2009 – 8 scratch-bred 12 mare-bred

2010 – 4 scratch-bred 16 mare-bred

2011 – 10 scratch-bred 10 mare-bred

2012 – 4 scratch-bred 16 mare-bred

2013 – 2 scratch-bred 18 mare-bred

2014 – 7 scratch-bred 13 mare-bred

2015 – 8 scratch-bred 12 mare-bred

2016 – 9 scratch-bred 11 mare-bred

Based on the numbers it would fair to say that the likelihood of a mare-bred horse winning the Bluegrass Derby is greater than the chances of a scratch-bred horse, but it also seems that from 36% scratch-bred starters and the comparisons drawn from non-KY bred horses that scratch-bred horses would fair far better than the one Derby win in the past 15 years.

11 thoughts on “Scratch Bred Horses, Mare Bred Horses and the Bluegrass Derby”

  • waremblem5

    Excellent research. I am always leery of Derby trends because of sample size. For example, people said no Storm Cat line DS ever had a Derby winner. Well except for the last two now. And how many chances did he have previously? You hear the same thing with total starts (we have several horses with only 3 career starts in this years KY Derby now) or never starting as a 2yo (which was never a factor in years past but is now because horses run less). My point is even with say a same size of 20 years that only 20 races which statistically speaking is a microscopic sample size.

    However, I think you have dug into something here. I agree with you that with over 1/3 of all entrants scratch bred they probably should have more than one win. Especially when you compare it with the non KY bred stat. I don’t think scratch breds have a glass barrier to winning the race and likely it is just bad luck but I’m pretty sure everyone who has a scratch bred in the Derby this Saturday who has read this is thinking oh….@##@.

    The other trend this points out is that, aside from the first two years, the Derby always has more mare breds. In the first two years I would imagine that is because people didn’t have as many mares to use in the early days of the SIM. Today it looks like you have a much better chance of getting an elite horse from a mare, which makes sense because once you identity your best broodmares you know that you’ll get runners from them. It is always a random draw on a scratch bred whether or not the horse will work no matter how good the breeding.

    • trotter1Post author

      thanks for prompting the research with your reply in the previous article…it was something I always wanted to examine but didn’t really want to put in the tedious labor…wasn’t as bad as I thought…I 100% agree with your chances of getting an elite horse from a mare, which surprises me that there were 24 scratch-bred horses entered in the last 3 Derby’s…

      • A while back i looked up how many 10 million winners in Hall of Fame were scratch bred vs mare bred …The 14 i looked at 10 were scratch bred and 4 were mare bred..but like waremblem says a lot of them were bred years ago..before players had all theses elite mares..

  • Can’t believe the amount of research that you put into your derby coverage. Stuff like this is what makes this game so great and you my friend are at the top of the list.

  • Just out of curiosity, did you happen to notice any stats in regards to “He” mares when doing your research.

    I am particularly interested as I have just returned to this amazing game after being away for 8 years, and used my best 2 horses from 2006 and 2007 as he mares as the basis of a restart in this game

    They are Newfound Cyclone (4th in 2006 Bluegrass, winner of 2006 Middle Jewel and Travellers)
    and Sea King Cyclone (multiple graded turf sprint winner),

    Its also great to see so many names I recognize from way back still here enjoying this great game, names like you Trotter as well others like Roys Squirrel my fave BTB writer CVBear Nextbonus and so many others.

    • trotter1Post author

      welcome back dingo…unfortunately I did not distinguish he-mares from mares in my search, which would have been easy to do, but I will put it on my to do list…from my own personal experience breeding to good on track performers generally results in good racing offspring be it from mares or he-mares…good luck on your return

  • Trotter, amazing research and time taken. Thanks for all the info, definitly great to read!

  • handshobby

    Good stuff trotter. Quick question: were those mare bred entrants all from conventional mares or have there been any he-mares?

    • handshobby

      Sorry, please ignore. Had pulled up the article right after it was posted, but just read it tonight, so the comments didn’t show up. Once I posted, they all loaded up and I saw this was a redundant question.

  • lebowski00

    Great article trotter as usual. Thanks for your work. Also a lot of great responses from everybody. Good luck to everyone this week no matter what races you are in.

Leave a Reply