The 2017 Bluegrass Derby…An Early Look
I have been covering the Bluegrass Derby since as far back as 2006 tracking winning trends and presenting them through the Derby Watch format or through written publication. Trends, loosely defined, are a general course or direction of things. While not necessarily of my own opinion, I do consider it is an interesting way of looking at the Derby while fueling the imagination of breeders longing to someday display the garland of roses.
Many of you by now are familiar with these trends that I have compiled over the years, but I will list, in order of importance, the top trends as the relate to the 2017 Bluegrass Derby.
1. No Bluegrass Derby winners had Dosage Index of over 4.00
- This trend could be severely tested this year as four of the seven Derby Lock Race winners have a Dosage Index of 4.00 or higher
2. Sixteen (16) of the eighteen (18) Bluegrass Derby winners have won a race of one mile and an eighth (9 furlongs) or longer prior to winning the Derby
3. Every Derby winner, with the exceptions being LUCKY’S HOWIE (2010) and last year’s winner PAPA’S GHOST TED, has won a Graded race as a three-year old prior to winning the Derby
4. Sixteen (16) of the eighteen (18) Bluegrass Derby winners won a Graded race in one of their two final preps before the Derby. Eleven (11) won a graded race in their final prep
5. Over the last 10 years five (5) of the Lock Race winners have gone on to win the Bluegrass Derby.
- You might think this should be ranked higher in the order of importance, but you must remember 35% of the field is made up of Lock Race winners.
6. Only BUDA WITH THE SLEW (2001) and TOWER STORM (2002) have won the Breeders Bowl Juvenile, Eclipse Award and Bluegrass Derby.
7. Only one horse has ever finished ITM (In the Money) in the Movieland and gone on to win the Bluegrass Derby
8. Since 2002 only one (1)) Bluegrass Derby winner has been bred from scratch.
- I don’t have the percentages of scratch bred Derby entrants compared to mare bred Derby entrants, but a compelling statistic just the same
9. Only 6 of the 17 Bluegrass Derby winners were bred outside of Kentucky
10. Fourteen (14) of the (18) Bluegrass Derby winners broke their maiden in either their first or second career start; 15 of the 17 have done so within the first 2 starts on dirt.
THE MAIN CONTENDERS
There are only two horses that meet all the criteria of a Bluegrass Derby winner, stoner’s BOMBAATA and fernando’s LAWRENCE DURRELL. The latter prefers to do his running from 8 lengths or further back off the pace, as evidenced in his strong second place finish in the G1 Florida Derby LTO, however it is a running style that has produced only four (4) previous Bluegrass Derby winners. BOMBAATA gets the edge here based on his strong finish on an off track in the G1 Corkscrew Stakes LTO.
THE LOCK WINNERS
Lock winners naturally have a distinct advantage over the rest of the field generally because they meet the more meaningful criteria of a Derby champion winning Graded Races in their final prep, usually coming at 9 furlongs. This year’s “Lock Seven” are particularly interesting because four of the seven, IMNOTGONNACRACK, SATURATION POINT, CARIBBEAN GHOST, and STORMIN CURLIN CAT all have a Dosage Index of 4.00 or higher. Tenpoint ‘s Kentucky Bred WORLDCLASS FUNNY, a winner over an off-track as a 2yo, gets the edge over the “Lock Seven” group while punter34’s IRE Bred CARL’S SHAMELESS and the planoaxius trained FL Bred LONG LEGS KING are grudgingly penalized for being bred outside of Kentucky, fill out the upper half of the list. The bottom half of “Lock Seven” list is headed by kingab’s CARIBBEAN GHOST whose only mark against him is his 4.09 Dosage Index. Tenpoint ‘s IMNOTGONNACRACK and stockswami’s STORMIN CURLIN CAT not only have to overcome an inflated Dosage Index, but are also cursed with the scratch bred phenomenon. Mtk’s SATURATION POINT will not only have to do something no Derby winner has ever done before with his 4.00 DI, he in the only Lock winner yet to win a race at 9-furlong’s or greater, an enormously important milestone to winning the Derby.
BEST OF THE REST
This list of five (5), while captioned as “Best of the Rest”, merit serious consideration having fallen short in only one major or two minor categories. The only knock on KF Racings BETTER AT MIDNIGHT is the absence of a win at 9-furlongs or longer, but the winner of 6 of 9 career starts turned in a solid effort in the G1 Corkscrew Stakes in the off going earning him high marks entering the Derby. Silversun’s FIGO gets penalized for being a scratch bred and taking 3 starts before breaking his maiden, obviously weak votes against the winner of the G1 VT IS 4 LOVERS. Pleasnttap’s LOW FIDELITY, and dixiedotco’s FINALLY THE ONE are also plagued with the scratch bred dilemma, but the lack of a 9-furlong win in their past performances is more likely to hamper their Derby chances. Jms stables RAPID FINISHER might have found himself on the longshots list being a scratch bred and a maiden winner in his 4th start, but despite the absence of a 9-furlong win, a strong second place finish in the G1 Wooden Indian earns him this respect.
THE LONGSHOTS
The field is rounded out by “The Longshots”, the final six entrees that fail to meet three or more of the essential Bluegrass Derby criteria. WARRIORS DANZ TED has all the voodoo that goes along with the Breeders Bowl Juvenile, Eclipse Award winner and then some. The woodenjock trained 2yo Champion showed his first sign of life in the 2017 season LTO when just missing in the G3 Bluegrass Derby Trial Stakes. MORE CREATIVE, F N READY, MONSTROUS CAUSE, LOCK THE DOORS, and SHINSUKE are all winless at the Graded level as a three-year old. the2mavericks LOCK THE DOORS gets the highest marks finishing second and third respectively in the G2 Fountain Of Ute and G1 Florida Derby. SHINSUKE is a late arriver to the Derby scene and holds the bottom spot with a second-place finish in the G1 California Derby for theoc’s racing stables. Amirs MONSTROUS CAUSE did well to finish second in the G1 All Saints Derby. Jayvee’s F N READY hasn’t proved he can compete at this level as a three-year old earning all his eligibility as a 2yo. ajhamm4 ‘s MORE CREATIVE’s low marks are compounded by his win in the G1 Movieland Futurity last year, a race that has compromised the chances of winning the Derby for all but one Derby winner.
There you have it, a look at the top 20 Bluegrass Derby entries and how they stack up against the criteria of past Derby winners. Take comfort in knowing that even if your horse doesn’t fair well against the criteria presented here, recent Derby winners have defied the trends.
NOTE: You will note that there are no fillies entered in 2017 Derby, however if one should emerge, she would fall to the bottom of the list as no Filly has ever won the Derby.
Terrific reporting.
For me the most surprising statistic is that only one scratch bred has won. Although, in fairness, I’d like to know how many scratch breds have competed in the 18 races.
One day I will sort that out…it is a tedious task and I suspect a high percentage of Derby starters are mare bred horses…but only 1 scratch bred, that surprises me also
Very well done!
One thing to consider in future years (both here and in real-life racing) is the fact the Dale Romans has retired his chefs-de-race Dosage website (as of the end of last year’s Triple Crown races), and I do not know if anyone else has picked up the responsibility of actually finding and naming new chef-de-race stallions.
If new chefs-de-race are no longer added to the database for Dosage, that index will become non-useful in a few years.
I was wondering the very same thing kidd…I hope so…
In his announcement about his ending his association with Thoroughbred racing, and ceasing his site, Steve Roman does say that “…Dosage followers can rest assured that the subject has been left in the more than capable hands of Mr. Steve Miller, my long-standing UK associate whose expertise extends well beyond pedigree evaluation. He has been instrumental in the development of Dosage theory and its application and has been involved in the chef-de-race selection process for almost 20 years. He will assume the responsibility for future chef-de-race assignments.”
All recent chef additions over the last several years have been either solely or jointly researched and instigated by Steve Miller (see the new-chef articles), yet there seems no evidence of his actually having taken on board his new sole responsibility for Dosage and its web presence — he is conspicuously nowhere to be seen. So maybe Dosage has had its day.
The majority of Steve Roman’s site is preserved at the Wayback Machine, and there is a link to it on my denovo.co.nr homepage.
Good stuff! Always enjoy your Derby coverage.
Good read Pete..
I like to look at dosage but not sure how much you can depend on it for all horses..
If look at the TAPIT horse IMNOTGONNACRACK with DI :4.14 …I Question this ..
If you would look at Tapit’s DI in SIM it’s 4.00 and if look at Tapit’s DI on pedigree on line
(Thoroughbred Database) it is 2.75 and none of Tapit’s sons DI match up SIM vs Pedigree on Line..
Tapit is the only sire i have found that does match up..
I meant Tapit is the only sire i found that does NOT match up..
see that’s the thing about Dosage, in a few years Tapit might be declared a chef de race and that would change the Dosage Index of all his horses past and present…as fascinating as Dosage is, it can be quite flawed.
Yes — there is a problem with Mike’s calculation an the Tapit dosage — thanks for bringing that up.
I’ll see if we can sort out the problem and get it corrected.
Yes — it appears Mike has Pulpit recorded as Intermediate rather Intermediate/Classic for Dosage purposes — I have emailed him on the matter.
Outstanding write up Pete. Very informative some what eye-opening.
I have a question which should not be too tedious for someone who knows where to look for stuff. How many SIM horses have won at least one triple crown race AND finished 1-2-3 in both of the others?
look for my next article to answer that question
I love stats! These analyses make BTB so special. All the articles are great.
Personally, I hope my small unexpected miracle and my first appearance in THE RACE will run well despite the adverse stats :).
plano I wish you the best of luck…if it is any consolation, 3 of the last 5 Derby winners were bred outside of Kentucky…