Arrogate is Overrated
Arrogate is also underrated.
How could that be? The changing landscape of thoroughbred racing effectively taints the now and accentuates history.
The exploits are well documented and his brilliance is (or at least should be) unquestioned. I’m not going to revisit them here or perform an arbitrary comparison to American Pharoah. What I want to do is discuss how racing today is unlike racing 20 years ago or 50 years ago, and try to shift the discourse on how we should be evaluating our stars.
- Horse (3yo year) Earnings Initial Stud Fee 5th year stud income Total 2017 Value
Secretariat 1973 $1,316,808 $125,000 $35,000,000 $36,441,808 $194,000,000
Alysheba 1987 $6,679,242 $75,000 $21,000,000 $27,754,242 $57,900,000
Skip Away 1996 $9,616,360 $50,000 $20,000,000 $29,666,360 $44,800,000
Medaglia D’Oro 2002 $5,754,720 $35,000 $14,000,000 $19,789,720 $26,100,000
American Pharoah 2015 $8,650,300 $200,000 $78,000,000 $86,850,300 $86,850,300
Arrogate 2016 $17,084,600 ?? ?? ?? A LOT
Lots of footnotes on these numbers… obviously stud fees fluctuate as well as number of live foals from mares bred, but for the majority of new stallions, their highest earning potential is in the first 4 years at stud. As dual hemisphere breeding became the norm, # of mares covered per year increased, so American Pharoah’s income is estimated based upon 150 live foals ($200k fee in the US, $60k in Australia). The totals may be skewed on the high end for stallions whose foals did not sell well even before hitting the track, so I’ve tried to compare only high earning, high stud fee types. The 2017 value adjusts for the relative worth of US dollars in the given year.
The obvious trend is that since roughly the ‘00s, racetrack earnings are becoming a smaller fraction of the stallions’ revenue stream. Medaglia D’Oro and Skip Away both had less than ideal pedigrees for ‘the market’, and stud fees went in opposite directions based upon their offspring’s results. When you have both the pedigree and the on-track success, the sky is the limit as to what you can charge for those first few crucial years at stud. If California Chrome had won the Triple Crown before American Pharoah, I’m quite sure we would not have seen a 200k stud fee, solely based on the pedigree.
Why does this matter to Arrogate? Arrogate had issues and was not ready to embark on a Triple Crown campaign, which is almost essential in building a portfolio for a top-flight American based dirt stallion. The sales market does not want late developers, they want fast horses who could be the next 2yo champion or Derby winner. Not too many deep pockets out there dreaming of winning the Breeder’s Bowl Marathon. Subsequently, we now overemphasize the importance of 3yo racing, with many 2yos on a ‘make-or-break’ track to become Derby contenders and if they don’t hack it, they often don’t have anything left for a career as an older horse. Overbrook Farm used to sell off its D. Wayne Lukas rejects who couldn’t withstand his training regimen; you’d see them running at Turfway Park or River Downs for a little while, and then gone. If you’re going to spend $500k on a prospect, I suppose it makes fiscal sense to go for the gusto and push them to reach their highest potential, both financial and performance wise… which is success at 2 and 3. These are essentially high dollar lottery tickets… you get a chance at glory, or are prepared to eat the whole cost and not worry about ROI on a horse that isn’t going to cover it’s training expenses 90% of the time.
Arrogate’s success can rightly be labeled ‘overrated’ by this measure, as he by definition is competing against a depleted talent pool. All the great ones would have retired to stud after their 3yo year, unless they were geldings or had a ghastly pedigree that would seriously inhibit their stud fees (see: ratio between on track earnings vs. stud income). I believe that Arrogate’s “late” career success can be attributed to his ownership: Juddmonte Farms, the flagship of some guy named Khalid Bin Abdullah al Saud.
Why is this relevant? KBA’s full name is Khalid ibn Abdullah ibn Abdul Rahman ibn Faisal ibn Turki ibn Abdullah ibn Muhammad ibn Saud ibn Muhammad ibn Muqrin Al Saud (Wikipedia).
I don’t have a clue what that means, but the value of his assets are directly proportional to the number of names in his name. He’s a Saudi Prince. His horses alone (before Arrogate) are valued at over $400 million, and his total holdings are “at least $1 Billion” (Bloomberg), probably because how are you really going to tally up the holdings of a royal family? It’s safe to say that the bottom line is not the bottom line for KBA, and subsequently Arrogate (one of the first yearling purchases made by an operation that breeds and races his own) did not have to fall into the ‘prove yourself’ trap that so many others embark upon. What we’re left with is an awesome horse who is now racing for historical greatness and not cashing out early – others of his kind would have been retired after the 2016 Breeder’s Cup (I’m looking at you, Zayat family).
And so by this token, Arrogate is also underrated, because we can’t use current models to identify how well he’s performing as a 4yo. He’ll go on to earn more than any other non-Japanese runner in history, but we all understand that is a tainted measuring stick. So far he’s destroyed all comers, with no real rival outside the declining California Chrome. His performance in the Dubai World Cup was as visually arresting as you’ll see in any race, let alone one of the highest quality… He should be considered an all-time great, top 5 talent… but he’ll be forever penalized for doing it ‘too late’ in the game.
A stud fee of $125k would not be unimaginable for a son of Unbridled’s Song; not a proven sire-of-sires, but certainly from a tail-male line in demand (see Pharoah and his progenitors Pioneerof Thenile, Empire Maker) in an era where everyone’s got an abundance of Northern Dancer in the family. The money is coming, the Prince ain’t living paycheck to paycheck, and the newly installed $16 million Pegasus Handicap pushes back on that racetrack to stud earnings ratio a little. Retirement can wait.
Long live Arrogate, champion race horse!
So wish American Pharoah raced as a 4yo. A matchup between him, Arro, and CC in the BCC would have been amazing to watch!
agree 100%
So, this article is about taint?
I think I only used taint or taint-derived words twice jn this piece.
No taint goes unitched?
I still do not think the Pegasus should count as money won. It’s fake money. Everyone gets some money back, so it’s not really 12 or 16 million. The true purse is the amount given out minus the payouts form 6-12, which is far less than 12 million. This is totally different than say the world cup where he puts up the money himself and only those who run well get paid. What’s to stop other races from saying this is a $30 million race, ten horses, all horses pay 3$ million, but all horses get back at min $2.9 million of it.
Correction…Should read they should adjust the money won from Pegasus. Ofcourse it should count, but should be adjusted
If there’s a $30M race and all horse get back a min of $2.9M, what would be the point of that race? LOL BTW – I think there would be an asterisk besides that races earnings..
Here is the pay structure from the Pegasus:
1st: $7M
2nd: $1.750M
3rd: $1M
4th-12th: $250K
If you would want a earnings adjustment then ALL Graded races would need to have an adjustment, not just races like the Pegasus. Unless the horse got in on a ‘win and you’re in race’ Then owners pay a small entry fee in Graded races from 1 to 2% of the purse pool and the track pays the rest, in ex: A $1M race would cost owners to pay either $10k or $20K depending on the size of the field. If the horse places in that race, a win for example and wins $600k (60%) on the horses earnings it still reads $600k not $580k or $590k. The same goes for the Pegasus but since the track DIDN’T put up any of the $12M purse but rather all the owners did. There was a guaranteed return for all horses of $250K from their $1M entry fee. I don’t think this race would have been able to go if there was no return for owners when risking $1M. Aside from the min return for entering the race, owners also go a small 1/12 share for all revenues earned by the track.
From the information I read it said all owners got back 650k after handle was paid.
And no the 250k should not count towards earningsbfor a 12th place finisher
In my mind it is impossible to compare horses, unless they run head to head. for me the best horses and the most durable horses ran in the 20’s 30’s, and 40’s. these horses ran on 7-10 days rest, carrying 130+ pounds against the best horses of their generation and no owner/breeder had a better run than Calumet farms in rhe 30’s and 40’s
You also have to take into consideration that before 1988, there was no drug testing the horses. In the 1930’s, there was rampant drug use, including narcotics, in horses. why they were able to run on 7-10 days rest without affecting them one bit. By the late 1940’s, the use of narcotics was surreptitiously replaced with amphetamine-type drugs and other related compounds that mimic the stimulation of the sympathetic nervous system – in other words the part of the central nervous system that activates what is often termed the fight or flight response. Not long after, local anesthetics such as procaine became evident followed by anti-inflammatory drugs and anabolic steroids.
As soon as drug testing came into affect, you started seeing the changes in horse racing, slower times, extended rest days etc etc.. This is why I never compare horse racing now to other horses who ran pre drug testing era..
jm you are mistaken, drug testing has been going on since the late 50’s. Dancers Image was disqualified for bute in 1968.. although not as scientific and refined as today, drug testing still was in the back of everyones mind long ago.
I disagree with your assessment that Arrogate isn’t running against anything. On the contrary, we give far too much credit to horses on the Derby trail for beating a bunch of ‘name’ horses and the only reason you know their name is because Steve Haskin talked about them on the Derby Dozen. Even a relatively famous horse like Bodemeister won only 2 races in his career. Arrogate meanwhile is beating proven G1 winners. He beat an in his prime California Chrome in the Breeder’s Cup Classic. He beat the best of his generation in the summer Derby in the Travers. He beat G1 winners in the Pegasus Cup and conquered the world in the World Cup.
While I agree that emphasis is placed upon 2yo and 3yo racing through the Travers, Arrogate is in no way ‘tainted’ by not excelling there. No one thinks less of Ghostzapper do they? Arrogate’s story is not yet finished which is why I have refrained from comparing him. I find it funny though that some people here were pretty quick to elevate Songbird to elite status for beating 5 horse fields (and she still hasn’t raced as a 4yo) comparing her to Zenyatta and so forth but there is a concentrated effort to down grade what Arrogate is in the process of doing. I am not sure if it is American Pharoah fan’s worried that the glow is being stolen from that horse or some other agenda. What if Arrogate wins out through next year’s Pegasus Cup? He’s going to have 30+ million in earnings! Unheard of.
If Arrogate wins out, he will most likely be voted HOY. That would give him one less HOY than John Henry. You only think Arrogate is so special due to recency bias.
Your smoking crack or your just trolling
you nailed it with the title of this article donny, ARROGATE IS OVERRATED, end of story…..
a few years from now..they will have the “super duper pegasus race”with a purse of 100 million to the winner….and earnings will be meaningless….its called inflation, just like with the stud fees
overrated or not, who is beating him? clearly the best at the moment
He is Tiznow, Ghostzapper, Holy Bull and similar. All great horses that failed or skipped TC races. I’d be hard pressed to pick a horse through history that I could 100% say was going to beat him on a given day. I hope to at least see him in the Pacific Classic and BC Classic both at Del Mar. Not sure what races he will hit this summer but I need to see more to place him in my top 10. He’s right there though.