American Pharoah vs Arrogate
As many of you know, Arrogate sure has been making a name for himself lately. With stunning wins in the G1 Travers, Breeders Cup Classic, Pegasus World Cup, and Dubai World Cup, he easily vaulted to the top of the active horses leader board. He has been called the greatest racehorse of the twenty-first century, and even the best racehorse ever. People have also been comparing him to the other Bob Baffert trained superstar, American Pharoah, only the twelfth Triple Crown winner ever.
Here’s my view on the two:
American Pharoah was an outstanding two and three-year-old, and he captured many horse racing fans hearts after his breathtaking win in the Belmont, which made him the first Triple Crown winner in 37 years. If you cross out his MSW loss, all of his other races were breathtaking, even his loss to Keen Ice in the Travers. He may have loss, but he sure showed heart all the way. In the 2015 Breeders Cup Classic, he won with his ears pricked by 6 1/2 lengths in record time. Nobody ever thought we’d ever see another like him.
Then there’s Arrogate. He was a late maturer, who never raced as a two year old. He finished 3rd in his first race as a three-year-old in a MSW, but then won the next time out. After two more Allowance wins, Baffert decided to test his skills in the G1 Travers Stakes. After beating his rivals by 13 lengths, he won by 3/4 of a length over two-time Horse of the Year California Chrome in the Breeders Cup Classic. That was followed by wins in the inaugural running of the 2017 Pegasus World Cup, and the Dubai World Cup at four. He really turned eyes after his win in the DWC after breaking badly but then overcoming all odds to win by 2 1/2 lengths over Gun Runner.
Now, I can see both views on how one is better than the other. But I say you can’t really compare them. American Pharoah was outstanding as a younger horse, but never got to show what he could do as an older horse as he was retired after his romp in the BCC. Folks, he was the first Triple Crown winner in 37 years, you have to appreciate that. Plus, he was also the first ever Grand Slam winner. That’s something to be proud of. Now there’s Arrogate. He did nothing as a two year old, and wasn’t all that impressive in his first few starts at three. But then there was the Travers. He sure turned a lot of heads after his scintillating performance. Then, after beating Chrome in the BCC, people really started looking. But look here. AP really only raced as a younger horse, and Arrogate was a late maturer. Arrogate never raced as a two year old, and AP never got to show what he could do as an older horse. Sure, some of Arro’s times may have been better, but he was older, and had been training longer than AP.
Two totally different horses, who had their turn to shine at different times in their lives. You can’t really compare them. Let’s just be thankful for these two racing greats who have blessed us all with their amazing performances and left us in awe of their ease with how they have won.
I’m sorry – this is a bad article. Take a side. Say something. You just recap the careers of two great horses without taking a side or offering anything but…we can’t compare them? Of course we can compare them they just ran a year apart. I enjoy articles about horses that say something but this was a waste of time.
I hate when I agree with war emblem.
And i agree with you both……the write up has no point otherwise
Know one will ever know, but both are legends with their own glory’s past and present 🙂 all the best threechimneys
It’s funny because, on few ocassions have been easier to compare two horses. Keen Ice is the key parameter, the unit of measure. Keen Ice has ran 3 times against Arrogate, 5 against American P. Any smart handicapper could make the calculations. No super hard.
Pharoah…no questions asked. Arrogate is the “hot ticket” right now, and deservedly so. But, 10 years from now, his name wont even be relevant.. That Triple Crown guarantees Pharoah’s place in racing history…Thats the facts, not an opinion.
Oh, and BTW…great article.
This is an easy one. You just have to get an answer from Jimmy Barnes.
I disagree with the comment that this is a bad article. The author probably got 300 credits for writing it!
I agree the topic is a good one. And one that will certainly inspire passions on both sides. My issue was with the presentation – again you gotta pick one if you’re going to bring up the topic. Note – I am not willing to pick one yet as Arrogate’s career is not over (which is also why I won’t compare Michael Jordan and LeBron James).
Thank you for writing this article. It certainly has generated a lot of interest! I think the comparison is irrelevant – Ghostzapper would’ve smoked them both!!!!!!
After reading this article, I’m not going to pick a side but i think Amerpharoah is right that you can’t compare AP and Arrogate. They are both superb athletes and I will never forget watching AP turning for home in both the Belmont and BCC; nobody could touch him. Some horses mature faster than others when it comes to Thoroughbreds and we can’t take nothing away from these two horses. This isn’t a bad article either; I loved it.
The very title of the article – American Pharoah vs Arrogate is a comparison. As was pointed out below, we even have a common horse in Keen Ice to use as a point of comparison. One can write an article such as Great Race Horses of the 2000s and praise the various accomplishments of Ghostzapper, American Pharoah, Arrogate, Curlin and California Chrome. However, once you pit an entity against an entity, such as the Patriots vs Cowboys dynasties you are compelled to take a side. I can’t just say oh Aikman, Irving and Emmitt were great but so was Brady. I must decide which is better if I am comparing them.
It should also be noted that comparing horses does not take away from the accomplishments of a horse. I also agree with the statement below that says American Pharoah will forever be immortalized because of the Triple Crown, but I disagree that Arrogate will be forgotten, especially in 10 years. Again, let’s see how Arrogate’s career plays out. But that Dubai World Cup will be immortal – there is no way he should have won that race. That’s legendary stuff. There is no way he should have beat California Chrome in the BC Classic. How do you go from allowance company to whipping the best of your generation in the Travers? I don’t think any of these races will be forgotten in 10 years.
My final comment. Do you remember a horse called Cigar? At the time, all the pundits were saying he was “the greatest racehorse of all-time”. A few years later, if you said the word “cigar”, people thought you were talking about Bill Clinton. The same fate awaits Arrogate. Only time will prove me right, but one thing for sure, you cant stop time.
Cigar is ranked 18th on the Bloodhorse Top 100 of all time (though it has not been updated to reflect recent horses and I would assume Rachel Alexandra, Zenyatta, Curlin, Ghostzapper, and American Pharoah make the list now) so I would hardly say he is forgotten. I know in today’s Twitter world we like to immediately call someone the greatest ever and forget anything that didn’t happen two weeks ago. I would bet that only horse most millennials can name is American Pharoah so by your logic even Secretariat is forgotten.
Holy Mackeral waremblem, can you read? This is Arrogate vs American Pharoah….the only reason i used Cigar as a reference was the similarities to whats being said now about Arrogate…that he is in the same league with American Pharoah. Just like the saying Cigar was the greatest of all time ahead of Secretariat….and now saying Arrogate is greater than American Pharoah…both are just too ignorant to try explaining any further,
YES history will always rate Secretariat over American Pharoah. But i will wager you anything, history will rate Pharoah over both Arrogate and
Cigar and almost every other non Triple Crown Winner…..Wait 10 years and then check your Bloodhorse Top 100. I am talking racing credentials, not breeding prowess.
I would back Winx to smoke them both
I appreciate the article and it is not the writers job to take sides. he/she was presenting the argument and the facts. it is the readers job to decide for themselves and considering the writer was named AP, i think it was fair.
thanks
the real shame here is that these great horses only come one at a time(no more Affirmed/Alydar rivalries) and their careers are so short
This is a bit of a stretch. Everyone says Alydar/Affirmed but can anyone name another rivalry? Are you going to go back to Buckpasser, Bold Ruler and Damascus? Seabiscuit and War Admiral? The rivalry idea feels like something of a myth when you start to break it down. Most great horses did not have a rival.
And didn’t Arrogate and California Chrome just face each other twice in a row? Agreed on careers being far too short.
Can anyone name another rivalry? Really!?! That’s an easy one, a little more than a quarter century ago, Easy Goer and Sunday Silence. Hard to say, if not impossible, one without the other….
Arts And Letters and Majestic Prince
I have no issue at all with the author’s presentation. Well done, Amerpharoah! Like the author, I reserve the right to decide which horses I choose to compare and contrast. I love and admire Rachel and Zenyatta equally. Both were remarkable race mares and as charismatic as any mare since Ruffian.
Secretariat was a truly great horse. Top 10 all time for sure. And I’ll give all you Big Red fans that on Belmont day, his performance defied belief. No horse could have beaten him that particular day. But I’d bet that Dr. Fager would have beaten Secretariat more than the other way around if they had been contemporaries.
I choose to believe that Dr. Fager was the greatest horse ever to look through a bridle. I contend that he could have and would have beaten Secretariat at any and every distance from two furlongs to two miles turf, dirt, mud or sand.
I won’t go into all the accomplishments of Dr. Fager. Suffice to say he won four Eclipses in 1968 (HOY, sprinter, older horse, turf horse). The proof, to me, that he was superior to Red was in the races each failed to win. Both horses were DQ’d once. Eliminating those races, Red was 16 for 20 while The good Doctor was 18 for 21. Dr Fager’s three losses were to Eclipse winner Damascus (twice) and the Eclipse winning 2 YO at age two (I forgot his name, sorry). And both losses to Damascus were “tainted” because Damascus had a rabbit in each. When they raced with no rabbit, Dr. Fager won both times.
Secretariat’s losses were to Prove Out, Onion, Angle Light and something called Herbull. Everyone is entitled to a bad day. Secretariat had 4. Dr. Fager had none.
Even the mighty waremblem5 isn’t perfect. Apparently he never heard of Dr Fager because if you read below, he thinks Damascus and Buckpasser raced against Bold Ruler.
To anyone interested in more on Dr. Fager, here is the best of the best.
http://cs.bloodhorse.com/blogs/horse-racing-steve-haskin/archive/2013/12/04/dr-fager-where-are-you.aspx
I was in the no fact checking zone! Dr. Fager is also on YouTube if you want to check out (some of)his races.
Historically, you have used alternative facts much less frequently than our fearless leader. I just couldn’t resist busting your chops since you are such a nice guy. Sort of. Maybe. Sometimes.
I have watched Dr.Fager on YouTube many times. I even watched Bold Ruler once.