Classic Season is over, Breeding Analysis
Well another season of Classic races has come and gone and it is time to assess what we saw in the races. The Triple Crown was fragmented into 3 different parts by Nyquist (Uncle Mo), Exaggerator (Curlin) and Creator (Tapit). One could (and I guess I am) make the argument that these sires are the future of American racing. Tapit had horses all over the Derby trail and this is now his 2nd Belmont winner in 3 years (Tonalist the other). He is a titanic influence on American racing right now and looks to be headed toward yet another sire title. This is the third straight year Curlin has sired a classic winner (I’m including the Travers here with Keen Ice) and one could (I am) argue that he is the most important sire in American racing now because he represents the last legitimate sire line branch of Mr. Prospector who gets classic horses. That’s a shocking statement but think about it – none of Distorted Humor’s sons have worked out, FuPeg was a flop, Woodman and Seeking the Gold are dead thru the sire line. Forty Niner is heading that way and Gone West is only represented by Speightstown who throws primarily sprinters as does City Zip, Carson City’s lone premium stallion. If you look at the top 15 NA Sires, only 3 come from Mr. Prospector, Curlin, City Zip and the deceased Smart Strike. Conversely A.P. Indy (Seattle Slew) is responsible for a staggering 7 of the top 15 US sires (Tapit, Lucky Pulpit, Congrats, Bernardini, Flatter, Malibu Moon, Mineshaft). Curlin could very well be the only one to carry on Mr. P thru the sire line and luckily he is off to a stellar start. Uncle Mo obviously is off to a terrific start in his first crop.
If we break down the classic winning pedigrees, Nyquist is the second straight Derby winner out of a Storm Cat line mare (Forestry) Sons of Storm Cat provide 5×5 inbreeding to Northern Dancer for Uncle Mo so it is a nick worth working with in the SIM. Another attractive quality in Uncle Mo is that he is free of Mr. Prospector, Nyquist’s DDS is Seeking the Gold (much more successful in the female line than the sire line) so he is open to any Mr. P options in the DS or DDS spots. You could also use Storm Cat himself as the DDS and get the 5×5 to ND cross with a son of Mr. P in the DS slot. Another intriguing option is using sons of A.P. Indy who have Mr. Prospector (like Mineshaft for example) in the DS spot.
Exaggerator is bred to a mare from the tragically deceased A.P. Indy son Vindication. He too is inbred 5×5 to Northern Dancer while also being inbred to Raise a Native and Boldnesian. Curlin has had good success in the SIM with Storm Cat but it doesn’t take much insight to say that, lol. I like Alydar in the DDS spot with Curlin as he gives a 4×4 inbreeding to Raise a Native. Curlin affords many options with Northern Dancer line mares.
Creator has the least SIM friendly pedigree though he is, again, inbred 5×5 to Northern Dancer. He is out of a mare by Privately Held who is a son of Private Account. From my experience in the SIM I really haven’t gotten good results using Private Account. Tapit of course is a major sire and you really don’t need any tips from me on what makes him work.
On the European front Sea the Stars, a lackluster sire thus far, got an English Derby winner and a Galileo again won the English Oaks. 12 of the runners in the English Derby had Urban Sea in their pedigree which begs the question, is she really that big of an influence or is European Racing quality suffering in races longer than a mile? Are these Galileo’s running against anything? If you look at the European sires list it is covered with sprinters (other than Dubawi and tossing Sea the Stars who wasn’t even a top 25 sire before his English Derby winner) like Dark Angel, Kodiac, Pivotal, Invincible Spirit and Lope de Vega. Cape Cross also appears but he has always been a sire that tends to get a couple big horses and lacks consistency. Who exactly is Galileo beating in these races? I don’t know how he fairs overseas, I know the Galileo’s did not do well at the World Cup this year and while they do well in America, look at Flintshire, he is a world crusher in America so it’s not exactly like the Kitten’s Joys of the world are on the same level as the Euros. I don’t have an answer to this but the question is intriguing to me.
What should these ramifications have on the SIM? Well, in my opinion Tapit and Galileo tower over their respective regions and should be on another level from all the other sires in the SIM. Yes, both are currently top 10 sires, but they should the elite of the elite, very good sires like Giant’s Causeway and Dubawi just aren’t on their level. Sea the Stars should be nerfed. Yes, he just sired an English Derby winner but his on track offspring simply have not warranted his elite ranking in the SIM. Sea the Stars should be rated on the level of Cape Cross, a sire who can get you a great horse, but only on occasion. Uncle Mo should receive his first upgrade and Curlin deserves the elite top 10 sire treatment.
This article is full of strange conclusions contradictions but was interesting to read. The title classic season over, No it is not outside the USA! it might be in the USA but then considering The Travis Stakes a classic in you opinion that has not been run.
Last year the Media were singing the praises of the Fappiano and his decedents (Mr P) have they all of a sudden turned bad? I doubt it.
Sea The Stars a flop? Really maybe you should read Andrew Caulfield’s work very interesting article the other week. If he is a flop anyone who’s name is not Galileo is useless. Maybe you forgot his other classic winner who then went and won an open age open sex grade 1 next up. How often do 3yo fillies do that?
To compare him against Curlin well just look at the cumulative stats of both sires and it is obvious one is best and Curlin is at an advantage with 4 crops 3yo when named foals are used as the percentage basis as at present neither has any 2yo stakes horses.
To use the World Cup as a basis as Galileo did not do well shows a naïve total lack of understanding of Global racing politics. If we do then Dubawi is the best sire in the world by a mile he had the winner of the main turf race and runner up in the dirt race (of course he sired the winner last year). Though to say Tapit is miles ahead of him is just stupid see 2015 Dubawi 9 grade 1 winner worldwide to Tapit 5.
Also the European list is covered by sprinters i.e. Dark Angel, quiz question how many American sire in 2016 have a higher average winning distance than him? Curlin that sprint sire is not one. Note Mike gave Uncle Mo an upgrade last year and will have to again especially as he is going to be the highest priced sire standing at Ashford Stud.
I am glad you found it interesting. To your feedback:
Fappiano is in the 4th generation of Pioneerof the Nile and 5th of American Pharoah which is where you are getting the media singing the praises. That’s pretty far back. Empire Maker in general was considered a failure at stud which is why he was sent to Japan. Empire Maker throws a LOT of named horses who never make it to the track. He also has one notable son at stud the above mentioned Pioneerof the Nile (the results are unknown with Bodemeister as of yet).
I stand by my Sea the Stars analysis and your example proves my point – he gets occasional top horses like I said, much like Cape Cross, but he is rated far better than Cape Cross in the SIM. A nerf is well deserved for Sea the Stars who has not even been a top 20 Euro sire. Curlin has only one more crop than Sea the Stars so it is certainly fair to compare them.
My Galileo reference to the World was a for example, not a be all end all of evidence. You will note I pose a question, how does Galileo fare world wide because I don’t feel he is running against all that much competition from route sires in Europe at the moment. I don’t know how he is doing worldwide and I very well might be wrong. It is more of theory questions with no effect on the SIM as I acknowledge Galileo should be better in the SIM than he is now. But 12 runners with Urban Sea in their pedigree in the English Derby? I don’t buy that Urban Sea is just that good, I feel it is a competitive issue.
Leading lists so far this year in earnings
TOP TEN
STALLION £ TOTAL PRIZE
Galileo £2,630,106
Sea The Stars £1,198,967
Invincible Spirit £881,764
Dubawi £871,294
Paco Boy £848,072
Dark Angel £819,240
Kodiac £759,994
Lope De Vega £739,936
Shamardal £688,648
Pivotal £687,903
Full Leading Lists page
Seasonal Stats
Overseas that is in Europe
Yes, that’s the Euro sire list I was referencing. Sea the Stars was not even in the top 25 before the English Derby so his earnings are almost solely off of one horse, this is like saying Lucky Pulpit is a top sire when California Chrome is responsible for 90% of his earnings. It then surprised me that other than Dubawi the whole list is made up of sprinters, so who really is Galileo competing against other than other Galileos in classic distance races?
You sure your just not a hater of sea the stars, his get just won the King Edward vII at Royal Ascot Lol
That was a mile lol
Beat 2 Galileos and I bet him lol thanks tvg
http://www.thoroughbreddailynews.com/race-replays/3/62027/
Love seeing articles covering breeding of the great thoroughbred animal. Keep them coming because the game needs passionate people who give time and effort when building their articles.
Now after pumping you up I need to insert a little opinion on my part when it comes to Urban Sea… Have you seen how many classic distance races her off-spring have produced. You can’t speak of the Arc without mentioning her name and her sons that have become sires.Everyone in Europe would love an Arch winner… Just like american racing 20 years ago when nearly every sire on the dirt had Mr. P somewhere in his line, and before that Northern Dancer…. 10 years ago it was Storm Cat … All speed horses that could get runners on dirt or turf. So seeing Urban Sea in several Euro classic starters is not unusual… People send their most talent well bred mares to the sires who are hot and sport proven bloodlines. Danzig and his father Northern Dancer are two american sires who have dominated both sides of the pond to the point that it’s hard to not find their influence in the pedigree of a Gr1 turf winner anywhere. Does that mean that turf racing is in trouble? Far from it in my opinion…. The past half dozen years more and more Mr. P and Storm Cat lines have done well all over Europe. It just takes a little while for them to filter in…I would love to think that breeders in the US and Europe would one day be more receptive of Sunday Silence lines. He’s been so successful in Asia his lines may add another Avenue for breeders. If the breeders could overlook the female side and give him a chance.