Bluegrass Derby: Report Card
Simply stating that PAPA’S GHOST TED, defied all the precedents to win of the 2016 Bluegrass Derby would be a gross understatement. The California bred failed on every criterion on the list; in fact, he was the second lowest rated horse in the field determined by previous derby statistics and trends.
Below were the criteria demonstrated by the majority of the past Bluegrass Derby winners, the points scored and ranked by the 2016 Bluegrass Derby field, and the order of finish.
10 points – The horse must win a graded race in one of his two final preps
9 points – The horse must have been within eight lengths back at the second and/or third race call
9 points – The horse must have a Dosage Index under 4.00
9 points – The horse must have won a graded win as a three-year od
8 points – The horse must be an offspring from a game mare (not a scratch-bred)
7 points – The horse must break its’ maiden in their first or second start
6 points – The horse must be a KY bred or colt
5 points – The horse must be a winner of a Lock Race
-2 points – The horse was a 2yo champion
Rankings and Final Results
YELLOW FANGS 73 -12th
BLOODBOILING 64 – 16th
SIPI FALLS 64 – 4th
AWESOME KINGMAMBO 60 – 17th
SWAPSCO KITTY 59 – 5th
LIGHTNING STRIFE 58 – 9th
POWER GRAB 58 – 7th
OUTBACK BLOODHOUND 55 – 8th
LION’S SLEW 54 -13th
DOUBLE DISSOLUTION 51 – 2nd
VYRANTIUM 49 – 18th
BLANK SPACE 49 – 3rd
SYMBOLI BIRD 47 -14th
YER YELLOW 44 – Scratched
DEADMONEY CADET 40 – 19th
I LOVE LUCY’S KASH 31 – 11th
DARK STORM RISING 30 -15th
PAPA’S GHOST TED 27 – 1st
KING BOBBY 23 – 10th
The first thing we notice is that the top 3 finishers were ranked at the bottom 10 of the list. The question is…Is the list flawed or are the trends changing over the past few years?
Trends that remained to be a strong characteristic of a Bluegrass Derby winner was a horse having to win a race of nine-furlongs or longer prior to the Derby. Eight horses in this field failed to win a race of 9 furlongs or greater and the best finish from that group was POWER GRAB’s 7th place.
Once again the winner of the derby was an offspring from a game mare (not a scratch-bred). Further examination of the ratio between the number of scratch bred and non-scratch bred may be necessary to validate the weight on this criteria, but regardless quite astonishing fact.
The Grade I Movieland Stakes, run late in December, continues to plague Two-Year Olds in their pursuit of the Derby, perhaps the race that pushes the limits of the 2yo campaign.
Sadly, the ‘Curse of the Two-Year Old Champions’ continues. SWAPSCO KITTY and DEADMONEY CADET finished off the board. Interestingly the first and second place finishers of the Movieland.
Notable changing trends dispel the myth that Derby winners must be bred in Kentucky. Four of the last six Bluegrass Derby winners were bred outside of Kentucky, two from California and two from Japan,
While Lock races are crucial to the Derby Trail, they are not the end all criteria to success in the Derby. Five of the last 10 Derby’s saw a Lock winner win the Bluegrass. When you consider 35% of the Bluegrass field is made up of lock winners, it might even be a disadvantage.
PAPA’S GHOST TED was only the fourth horse to come from more than eight lengths back at the second and/or third race call and became the first horse never to have won a Graded race prior to the Derby. He was also only the fifth horse not to break his maiden in either his first or second start.
Drawing away from a talented field in the Bluegrass, it was pretty clear that PAPA’S GHOST TED thumbed his nose to the statisticians, this writer, and all the non-believers who couldn’t see this coming. He will move on to the Middle Jewel with his sights set on the Triple Crown, once again emphasizing ‘that’s why they run the race’.
Final Thoughts
PAPA’S GHOST TED bucked almost every trend characteristic to a Bluegrass Derby winner, but none more eye-opening than the fact that he is the fourth non-Kentucky bred in the last six years to win the Derby. Now I am not suggesting that a Derby winner must hail from Kentucky, but it does seem significant that 4 of those 6 non-Kentucky-bred Derby winners have come in the last six years.
Only 28% of the Derby field over the last six years was made up of horses bred outside of Kentucky, yet a non-Kentucky bred has won the Bluegrass Derby 66% of the time in the last six years.
Do trainers and owners re-evaluate their breeding process? Will there be a decline in the purchase high sought after Kentucky sires going forward? Does Doris get her oats?
Time will tell, and I am already looking fo
that last line should read
Time will tell, and I am already looking forward to next year’s cast of characters.
sorry bout that
Was a great race and for a moment I thought the lady will get the boys again when she start driving, but that moment went off quickly. Congrats to the winner.
Maybe the Bluegrass Derby should be run in California.