A Dozen Reasons Why You May or May Not Have a Potentail Derby Winner
The day was May 1, 1999 when PHARRUN PROSPECT won the first Bluegrass Derby, then a non-graded race distinguished only by its’ name and million-dollar purse. Saturday May 7, 2016 will mark the 17th running of the Bluegrass Derby, now one of the richest races in the world with a Grade I status and a purse of $6,000,000.
The Bluegrass Derby has always been known as one of the most sought after races to win for a 3yo, and trainers and owners have been trying for years to solve the puzzle of what it takes to win the Bluegrass Derby.
We are in the stretch run leading up to the Bluegrass Derby, and for the most part the field is set with the exception of the always controversial late entry, and it is always interesting to look at what it might take to become Bluegrass Derby winner, who has the best chance to win the 2016 Derby , and who is the most likely to buck the trend.
1. Can you recognize if you have a potential Bluegrass winner after only two starts? Every Bluegrass winner with the exception of 4 horses, broke their maiden in one of their first two starts. Two of the four that didn’t, made their debut on the Turf and won at first asking when switched to the dirt.
2016: Four horses failed to meet that criteria this year, DOUBLE DISSOLUTION whose first two starts were on the Turf and then won on the dirt at first asking, KING BOBBY, PAPA’S GHOST TED, and SYMBOLI BIRD.
2. Does Dosage matter? Many will argue the validity of the Dosage Index, and rightfully so, simply because of the fact that every Dosage Index changes for a horse every time a new chef-de-race is proclaimed; however, every Bluegrass winner, with the exception of one, had a Dosage index under 4.00.
2016: BLANK SPACE is the only horse in the field not to meet the criteria (4.60)
3. Do top 2yo’s feel the effects of that 2yo campaign and come up short on that first Saturday in May? This has been a matter of discussion among trainer’s for a long time, the majority believing the top 2yo’s don’t make great 3yo’s. Only BUDA WITH THE SLEW and TOWER STORM have won the Breeders Bowl Juvenile, the Eclipse Award and the Bluegrass Derby.
2016: SWAPSCO KITTY and DEADMONEY CADET will have to overcome the burdon of being the best two-year olds of 2015
4. Does a horse have to be bred in Kentucky to have a chance to win the derby? No but it sure helps. Only five non Kentucky breds’ have won the Bluegrass (it should be noted that in the early years of the Sim sire distinction was unavailable, but reasonable deduction suggests KY breds)
2016: DOUBLE DISSOLUTION, LION’S SLEW, POWER GRAB, PAPA’S GHOST TED, SYMBOLI BIRD, and YER YELLOW were all bred outside of Kentucky
5. What about an AUS bred? No AUS bred has ever won the Derby
2016: DOUBLE DISSOLUTION (AUS)
6. What about Fillies? No filly has ever won the Derby
2016: SWAPSCO KITTY (f) although it should be said this filly has two Grade I victories against the boys
7. Scratch Bred or Mare breeding? You might be surprised to know that since 2002 only one scratch-bred horse has ever won the Bluegrass.
2016: Scratch Bred entries SWAPSCO KITTY, OUTBACK BLOODHOUND, DEADMONEY CADET, LION’S SLEW, AWESOME KINGMAMBO, I LOVE LUCY’S KASH, SYMBOLI BIRD, and YER YELLOW
8. Are there any prep races to aim at or avoid along the Derby Trail? In 5 of the last 9 years a Derby Lock Prep winner has won the Bluegrass while only VIRTUOSO ever finished ITM in the Movieland and went on to win the Derby.
2016: Lock Winners SWAPSCO KITTY, DOUBLE DISSOLUTION, OUTBACK BLOODHOUND, BLOODBOILING, YELLOW FANGS, and SIPI FALLS
Movieland 2015 top three finishers SWAPSCO KITTY, DEADMONEY CADET, and SYMBOLI BIRD
9. How important is it to have proven stamina going into the Derby? Every Derby winner with the exception of two has won a race of nine furlongs or longer prior to winning the Derby. I have always felt this to be the most significant requirement for winning the Derby.
2016: failing to meet that criteria are OUTBACK BLOODHOUND, DEADMONEY CADET, VYRANTIUM, LIGHTNING STRIFE, POWER GRAB, I LOVE LUCY’S KASH, DARK STORM RISING, KING BOBBY, and YER YELLOW
10. How important is it to win a Graded race as a three-year old? Every Bluegrass winner with the exception of LUCKY’S HOWIE won a graded race as a three-year old prior to the Derby.
2016: DARK STORM RISING, KING BOBBY, and PAPA’S GHOST TED are still seeking their first graded victory.
11. How close to the pace should a horse be to win the Bluegrass? Only I SEEK U, Gimlet NEAT, and MOUNTNOIR have won the Derby in gate to wire fashion; however only three horses have ever won the Bluegrass coming from more than eight lengths back at the second and/or third race call, criteria that hinder quite a few horses’ chance in this 2016 Derby Field.
2016: Dead Closers… DOUBLE DISSOLUTION, BLOODBOILING, SIPI FALLS, VYRANTIUM, I LOVE LUCY’S KASH, DARK STORM RISING, PAPA’S GHOST TED, YER YELLOW
12. How important are the final two prep races for a derby winner? Sixteen of the seventeen Derby winners won a Graded race in one of their last two final prep races, eleven of them won a graded in their final prep.
2016: failing to meet that criteria are DEADMONEY CADET, BLANK SPACE, I LOVE LUCY’S KASH, DARK STORM RISING, KING BOBBY, and PAPA’S GHOST TED
How significant these trends are in predicting what it takes to be a Derby contender or to win the Derby is really up to the reader’s interpretation. Trends and streaks are broken every day while new ones start up just as quickly. I do find these stats interesting, some maybe more relevant than others, and present them to you to decipher as you wish.
Great stuff Pete!!
Great stuff
This is nice. Are there any in the field that qualify under all criteria?
If so, where can I place a bet?
thanks Donny, I am working on a way of translating these facts to numbers, the problem being quantifying objective criteria by order of importance. What I consider most important may seem trivial to someone else.
No I think you are pretty established as the expert on this right now! I especially buy into the “Graded Winner at 3”, “winner at 9f+”, and “winner in first or second start” when you draw a line though turf starts. I am working on a concept for a “Derby factory” plan of training these horses, which would follow some “Derby qualification rules”… my usual methods of desperation have not resulted in a single starter yet!
Great work Pete, as my number 1 goal is the Derby, any info is helpful as I am a lifetime turf man from Australia, thanks mate.
Pete – you really are the Bluegrass Derby doyen!
I thought I was a shot until I read this……..
Go Double Dissolution (even though he’s a deep closer, from Australia, a lock winner that didnt break his maiden in his first two starts)……… 🙁
thanks lado…you will be happy to hear that in previous years these trends were more ironclad, but recent years have seen many of the winners buck some of these trends. Who knows, maybe this year your horse will be the new trend setter…Good Luck
Probably the best article I’ve read for awhile , kudos to u
The most interesting fact to me is that only 1 scratch bred has won
Did u work out based on those stats who should win ?
Pete,
Great job and a good research, congrats!!! I’d like to point out you missed on Hidden Identity as one of the lock races winner.
Will be a nice race to watch with a killer speed….
I hope will be double sweet for SK.
Thanks cowboy, I knew there was one more Lock out there somewhere but up to this point HIDDEN IDENITY has not been entered into the Bluegrass. Hope it’s not injured.
Good article,, yet very depressing. My first ever entrant seems to be doomed before it ever enters the starting gate.
nah Ken your horse will be just fine…every year something adds or subtracts from these trends, and recent years have been more detraction’s…good luck
It’s all good. just getting into the race is an achievement. And there is no golden formula to winning, otherwise everyone would be a winner. Mine could always be the exception to the trend 😉
Wow, great research and article Trot, a lot of fun to read!
Great article Trot
My bloke gets a few ticks and a few crosses, but the scratchbred cross could be a real worry
Nice write-up Pete. Helped me with a few questions ive always wondered about. Thanks.