Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

Black Type Bugler

eHorseracing.com’s Official Online News Source

American Pharoah Part 2 – Starting Strides

This is the second in my series on American Pharoah and his exploits in the SIM. If you missed part one it can be found in the General SIM Forums. Without further preamble, let’s see what the Pharoah has been up to the last month!

There are now 52 American Pharoah’s in the SIM. This is a bit slower pace than the initial surge. While he notched 31 in his initial review he has only added 21 new horses since then. Still, he has not dropped below 1000 BPs, so it is likely people are still buying up shares just not using them yet as AP has not been good at the start. I don’t put too much into this as I wouldn’t expect AP to excel at 5 furlong races. Thus far his numbers look like this:

13 Runner with 3 Winners for a 23.1% win rate. His average runner is making $6,602 and thus far all the APs have tried the dirt (they all have sprinted due to race limitations). This number is actually a bit worse since one of the winners is from a HOT race with a 49 SF. Let’s take a look at his current runners starting with top SF.

  1. Phone Trick x Strike the Gold(SW Mare): 71 SF @ 5f 2nd out of 10.
  2. Pivotal x Smart Strike (SP CLM 250K Mare): 66 SF@ 4.5f 1st out of 12
  3. Super Saver x Indian Charlie (250K CLM Mare): 66SF @5f 2nd out of 12
  4. Bernardini x Kingmambo (scratch): 65 SF @4.5f 5th out of 13
  5. A.P. Indy x Storm Cat (scratch): 64 SF @ 5f 1st out of 9
  6. Empire Maker x Giant’s Causeway (scratch): 60 SF @5f 4th out of 14
  7. Forty Niner x Fappiano (scratch): 58 SF @5f 5th out of 9
  8. Bernardini x Northern Dancer (100K ALW Mare): 58 SF @5.5f 9th out of 11
  9. Forty Niner x Dehere (scratch): 57 SF @5f 2nd out of 12 HOT
  10. Danzig x Forty Niner (CLM Mare): 54 SF @5f 7th out of 10
  11. Deputy Minister x Secretariat (scratch): 49 SF @5f 1st out of 4 HOT
  12. Super Saver x Unbridled’s Song (SW Mare): 49 SF @ 5f 10th out of 10
  13. Precise End x Festive (CLM Mare): 48 SF @ 5f 6th out of 7

Looking at these runners it is not surprising to see Forty Niner turn up multiple times, he is an excellent source of American dirt speed. The use of Super Saver multiple times is mildly surprising and is likely a reaction to Super Saver’s high profile monster Runhappy. Super Saver also has had his stud fee double this season and he has been trading fairly hotly (as opposed to last year) in the SIM. I am not going to spin AP’s initial numbers, they are not very good, but I don’t think anyone expects him to sire top class 5f horses. In fact running in the 60s at this distance could be a very good sign when some of these horses stretch out. AP’s highest SF is from the Phone Trick mare Stagecoach Dream who has sired two SW, including a GW1 winner from Cowtown Cat so the mare definitely is a producer.  I personally will be watching the Indy line. Indy and Bernardini both produced a mid 60s runner so far. Interestingly the ND line horses (Danzig, Deputy Minister) didn’t fare too well, though there is Pivotal who did very well with what looks like a turfy pedigree.

AP’s young firecrackers will likely benefit from stretching out. Personally I haven’t pulled the trigger on AP yet (instead taking advantage of some of the top 10 sires who are falling pretty low in BPs for them at the moment), but will be as soon as the races begin to stretch out. I likely would be targeting 6.5f or 7f races for my debuts, though 6f might be solid if you have used a sprint/speed backside with AP.  The numbers thus far tell us that 4.5/5 f is a bit too short (though from a small sample size).

Good luck everyone breeding to this great horse, I will see you again after St. Patricks Day!

 

3 thoughts on “American Pharoah Part 2 – Starting Strides”

  • mtk76

    Your sim forum article breaking down the quality of mares he got so far really had me interested in comparing that across different sires to show the strength of their crop. I don’t recall anyone having done that before so it is an interesting data point.

    • waremblem5Post author

      I’m going to take a look at Honor Code and Golden Horn in relation to American Pharoah as the year goes on. Just at first glance w/o digging into who the mares were or if they were scratch bred Golden Horn appears to be getting better mares. It is also interesting to note that AP now has 17 runners while Golden Horn and Honor Code each only have 4 runners each. I can understand people being excited to run an AP but I also tend to think 5f isn’t going to be the best distance for the APs. I would also note none of the APs bred to the G1 winners have debuted yet. I am not worried about APs results at 5f

      • mtk76

        Agreed if I have one I would not debut it until 7f races are an option in July. Will be interesting to see the end results on that comparison.

Leave a Reply