Breeders’ Bowl Pedigree Analysis
When the new sim rolled out a few years ago, game creator Mike suggested that the ability of sires to get really good horses would become more egalitarian when it came to choosing sires. That is to say, the ‘little guy’ sires would have a greater chance of getting the big horse. Analyzing the 2015 Breeders’ Bowl pedigrees suggests that spreading the talent level around has been a success. There are 202 horses running in Breeders’ Bowl races this year (that’s up from 196 in recent years because the Classic field has been expanded from fourteen entrants to twenty). With more horses you would expect more sires to be represented and that is true, more sires are represented by Breeders’ Bowl runners in 2015 than there were in 2014. But the extra six runners can’t account for the disparity – in 2014 there were 97 sires with runners in the Breeders Bowl; in 2015 it is up to 111. Sires from such localities as Louisiana, Ohio and South Korea are represented by runners but as is typical the races are dominated by Kentucky and Irish-breds.
In 2014 there were five sires represented by more than five runners. Distorted Humor, Monsun and Street Cry were represented by eight runners a piece while Bernardini had seven and Awesome Again had six. This year the number of sires represented by more than five runners has gone up a tick to six sires. They are Street Cry with nine, Distorted Humor with seven, Dubawi with seven and More Than Ready, Tapit and Unbridled’s Song with six each.
Also changing in 2015 are the decisions to use mares, hemares or scratch breedings. The number of scratch breedings has gone up slightly from 72 in 2011 to 80 in 2015 but the number of hemare breedings has plummeted from 27 to 13 in the same time period. The influx of new players surely accounts for the increase in scratch breedings and a number of the more prominent new players are represented in the Breeders’ Bowl. In recent years the cost of using a hemare has increased dramatically and is tied to a horse’s racing performance with stakes winners costing less than allowance winners, etc. But even the cost to breed a stakes winning hemare is higher now than it was prior to the new game rollover. Five of the thirteen hemares used were grade one winners during their racing careers and another two won lower grades. Three hemares were stakes winners and the remaining three were maiden and allowance winners. The cost changes for hemares certainly makes the increase in quality of male horses understandable but the racing quality of the mares represented this year is higher as well. In 2011 nine mares and hemares were rated B or higher. For those not familiar with the old grading system, when a horse was retired they were rated based upon their racing results. Grade one winners were rated at a minimum B with multiple grade one winners being rated A. Listed stakes winners were rated at a minimum an E and so on. This year the number of grade one winning mares or hemares represented by offspring in the Breeders Bowl is 22. Now of course mare ratings are based on the quality of offspring they produce, not their race records which is an important distinction. In 2011 this point was made as 44% of the mares represented by runners were stakes winners or better but 52% of the mares had produced multiple stakes winners. This year 61 of the 78 mares represented have produced multiple stakes winners (a whopping 78%). Of the remaining 17, 7 of them have only produced one foal so they have not had the opportunity to produce multiple stakes winners. It is interesting that as sire power has become more egalitarian, mare production power has become more concentrated. Certainly the new mare ranking system makes taking advantage of a good mare more obvious to breeders who may have overlooked their mares in the past.
Three mares appear in the pedigrees of more than one Breeders’ Bowl runner lead by the mighty Oil On Top who was featured in a column over the summer. Oil On Top’s three foals are all grade one winners this year and all three are running in Breeders’ Bowl races – Oil Forever in the Distaff, Oil On Display in the Dirt Mile and The Joy Never Ends in the Juvenile Fillies. Across the Sunrise has produced nine foals, with six stakes winners and four graded winners. Fake Honeymoon in the Classic and Today We Fight in the Sprint. Pravda is the dam of Zyr in the Marathon and the great-granddam of Filly Juvy Turf runner House of Romanov. The diversity of the entrants for these mares contradicts the common feeling that a mare will throw runners with similar styles and preferences. Or perhaps these mares are the exceptional few for whom that is not the case.
Following is a breakdown of the Breeders’ Bowl runners followed by their sire, damsire and damsdamsire and the name of the mare they were bred from or a label of scratch or hemare.
| Out of Shape | Distorted Humor | Storm Cat | Unbridled’s Song | Scratch |
| Moonlightandmusic | Midnight Lute | Malibu Moon | Allen’s Prospect | Steady Sprinter |
| Pi In the Palace | Dansili | Seattle Slew | Unbridled’s Song | Scratch |
| Il Mulino | Golden Missile | Forty Niner | Storm Cat | Smokin Tyres |
| Orinoquia | Unbridled’s Song | Storm Cat | Mr. Prospector | Miss Universo |
| Frosty Mae | Unbridled’s Song | Seattle Slew | Danzig | Scratch |
| Alberta Front | War Front | Forty Niner | Seattle Slew | Alberta Gold |
| Autumn Beauty | Unbridled’s Song | A.P. Indy | Storm Cat | Scratch |
| Partizan Belgrade | Passion For Gold | Seattle Slew | Northern Dancer | Curious Dancer |
| Daenerys of Arabia | More Than Ready | A.P. Indy | Carson City | hemare |
| Desert Cowgirl | Dubawi | Storm Cat | Bering | Pale Green Rider |
| Falcorn | Sepoy | Tale of the Cat | Danzig | hemare |
| Eleven Nineties | Lion Heart | Forty Niner | Summer Squall | Stormofthedecade |
| Benchian Fingers | Awesome Again | Seattle Slew | Forty Niner | Scratch |
| Loco Colony | Montjeu | Storm Bird | Pleasant Colony | Scratch |
| Tosh | Distorted Humor | Nijinsky II | Deputy Minister | Scratch |
| Little Column B | Admire Moon | Seattle Slew | Silent Screen | Cankersou Sea |
| Zyr | Dubawi | Kingmambo | Pleasant Colony | Pravda |
| Tap Lessons | Tapit | Kingmambo | Nureyev | Private Lessons |
| Outback Boron | Smart Strike | Unbridled’s Song | Encosta De Lago | Scratch |
| Danbawi | Dubawi | Dansili | A.P. Indy | The Underwriter |
| Haack’s Rocket | Awesome Again | Unbridled | Nijinsky II | Scratch |
| Fitzchivalry | Bernardini | Unbridled | Nureyev | Scratch |
| Ideal View | Ghostzapper | A.P. Indy | Sadler’s Wells | Stilettos |
| Lord of Blades | Street Cry | A.P. Indy | Touch Gold | hemare |
| Factor X | The Factor | Unbridled’s Song | Seeking the Gold | Xtra Beep Beep |
| K’s Cassius Clay | Giant’s Causeway | A.P. Indy | Dynaformer | Scratch |
| Shaken Gimlet | Tanino Gimlet | Dubawi | Seattle Slew | Bad Stella |
| Money All Day | Midas Touch | Woodman | Fit to Fight | Scratch |
| Primetime Dansil | Dansili | Daylami | Kingmambo | Royal Runner |
| Rae’s Creek | Giant’s Causeway | Kingmambo | Sadler’s Wells | Botwisted |
| Quick As They Come | Dawn Approach | Acclamation | Arch | Scratch |
| The Hawk Is Here | Hawk Wing | Falbrav | Nureyev | Faleyev |
| Greeley’s Kingdom | Animal Kingdom | Mr. Greeley | Indian Ridge | Green Ridge |
| House Of Romanov | Sepoy | Giant’s Causeway | Dynaformer | Anastasia Romanov |
| The Commands | Midshipman | Lawman | Rainbow Quest | Sightseeing |
| Hivernal | Take Charge Indy | Kitten’s Joy | Caerleon | Trotting Famous |
| Storm Quality | Pivotal | Elusive Quality | Storm Cat | Lotsa Quality |
| Dizzari | Dubawi | Danzig | A.P. Indy | Ziginsky |
| My Dream Queen | King Kamehameha | Danehill Dancer | Oasis Dream | Scratch |
| Queen Kam | King Kamehameha | Dubawi | Giant’s Causeway | Scratch |
| Chanting Lady | War Chant | Seattle Slew | Halo | Scratch |
| Washington Huskies | Speacial Week | Storm Cat | Kingmambo | Otto Jones |
| Packin The Heat | Pulpit | Unbridled | Halo | Scratch |
| Speight Knight | Speightstown | Seattle Slew | Secretariat | Scratch |
| Gang Related | Distorted Humor | A.P. Indy | Alydar | Takhisis |
| Broken Boulevard | Street Cry | Seattle Slew | Secretariat | Scratch |
| Oil On Display | Star Witness | Unbridled’s Song | A.P. Indy | Oil On Top |
| Nightmare Scenario | Oasis Dream | Deep Impact | Giant’s Causeway | Scratch |
| The Hound | Distorted Humor | Seattle Slew | Secretariat | Scratch |
| K’s Gorgo | Distorted Humor | Storm Cat | Alydar | Scratch |
| Kyger Station | Broken Vow | Deputy Minister | Graustark | Grauminister |
| Dutch Henry | Curlin | Storm Cat | Mr. Prospector | Queen’s Cats |
| Union Rails | Union Rags | Wild Again | Bold Forbes | Scratch |
| Going Medieval | Dynaformer | Distorted Humor | Sadler’s Wells | Marina Del Ray |
| Not On the Agenda | Street Cry | Storm Cat | Alydar | Scratch |
| Showcase Lowdown | Invincible Spirit | Giant’s Causeway | Smart Strike | Hilary Step |
| Hilarity Ensues | Medaglia D’oro | Distorted Humor | Storm Cat | Funny Cat |
| Whizzing By | Fast Bullet | Unbridled’s Song | Dynaformer | Composer’s Touch |
| Nothing Is Sound | Cape Cross | Deputy Minister | Blushing Groom | Scratch |
| Control Government | Sepoy | Forestry | Mr. Prospector | Fear Government |
| Quarter Water | Unbridled’s Song | Storm Cat | Capote | Scratch |
| Here Comes Goodbye | Harlan’s Holiday | Smart Strike | Broad Brush | Brushback Pitch |
| Kings of Winter | Commands | Mr. Prospector | Pleasant Colony | Scratch |
| Outback Virage II | Monsun | Dynaformer | Street Cry | Scratch |
| Movie Starl Looks | Shamardal | Affirmed | Northern Dancer | Scratch |
| Zabrathan | Excelebration | Kingmambo | Galileo | Scratch |
| VT Light | More Than Ready | Sadler’s Wells | Storm Cat | Jeb’s Baby Storm |
| Defense Wins Races | Snitzel | Mr. Prospector | Northern Dancer | Scratch |
| Soleduck Steelhead | Danehill Dancer | Fusaichi Pegasus | Forestry | hemare |
| Declare Loyalty | Declaration of War | Nureyev | Gone West | Loyal Harmony |
| Trick Me Once | Courageous Cat | Dynaformer | Phone Trick | Dyna Trick |
| Seattlelemondrop | Lemon Drop Kid | Seattle Slew | Nijinsky II | Scratch |
| Red’s Raven | Raven’s Pass | Redoute’s Choice | Storm Cat | Northern Red |
| Ripping Star | Sea the Stars | Redoute’s Choice | Galileo | hemare |
| Sansfoy | Soldier Hollow | Oasis Dream | Fappiano | Skunk’s Retreat |
| Chi Town Sausage | Lonhro | Deputy Minister | Seeking the Gold | Scratch |
| Houdini Love | Dubawi | Galileo | Blushing Groom | In Deep Space |
| Just Before Dawn | Dawn Approach | Mr. Prospector | Nijinsky II | Scratch |
| Redoute’s Dawn | Dawn Approach | Redoute’s Choice | Fappiano | Scratch |
| Bron Y Aur | Sepoy | Awesome Again | Dynaformer | Rama Again |
| Orpheus Cadet | Redoute’s Choice | Forty Niner | Seattle Slew | Mama Forty |
| Lear And Stare | Mr. Sidney | Lear Fan | Vigors | Scratch |
| Blue Lago Em | Acclamation | Encosta De Lago | A.P. Indy | NH Lake Bed |
| Letter Home | Speightstown | Malibu Moon | Northern Dancer | Malibu Dancer |
| Hold My Python | Unbridled’s Song | Storm Cat | Halo | Scratch |
| Misapportioned | Majesticperfection | Redoute’s Choice | Miswaki | Misappropriate |
| The Smackdown | Street Cry | Storm Cat | A.P. Indy | hemare |
| Hit Man LA | Liquidity | Storm Cat | Forty Niner | Salubrious |
| Unusual Destiny | Unusual Heat | Benchmark | More Than Ready | hemare |
| Liquid Luck | Liquidity | Capote | Storm Cat | Nine Sixty Six |
| Indian Trader | Elusive Quality | Indian Charlie | Deputy Minister | Scratch |
| The Kragle | War Front | Smart Strike | Seattle Slew | Scratch |
| Sacro | Holy Bull | Silver Deputy | Affirmed | Scratch |
| Shades Of Shimmer | Kitten’s Joy | Smart Strike | Nijinsky II | Shimmerstrike |
| Zigsational | Zensational | Seeking the Gold | Danzig | Scratch |
| Finally Ready | More Than Ready | Mr. Prospector | Seattle Slew | Scratch |
| Today We Fight | Tapit | Sadler’s Wells | Alydar | Across the Sunrise |
| Cape Cadet | Cape Cross | Giant’s Causeway | Mr. Prospector | Unkas Ruckus |
| The Eight Cuts | Dubawi | Danehill Dancer | Lyphard | Scratch |
| Ninianne | Sea the Stars | Zabeel | Summer Squall | hemare |
| Eat ‘Em Up Yum Yum | New Approach | Redoute’s Choice | Seattle Slew | Nom Omnom Nomnom |
| Tearing Down Walls | Monsun | Kris S. | Danehill | Scratch |
| Dragos | War Front | Ghostzapper | Kingmambo | Moldavia |
| Crosstown Flight | City Zip | A.P. Jet | Habitat | hemare |
| Cliffs of Dooneen | Henrythenavigator | Red Ransom | Mr. Prospector | Regal Ransom |
| Queen Named Barb | Lemon Drop Kid | Pivotal | Sadler’s Wells | hemare |
| Strut The Floor | Rip Van Winkle | Gone West | Northern Dancer | Stupidly Dance |
| Pye In Motion | Dream Ahead | Flying Spur | Storm Cat | Oil In Flight |
| Stillwatersrundeep | Dansili | Kingmambo | Kris S. | Scratch |
| Pivotal Action | Pivotal | Lyphard | Street Cry | Scratch |
| Franjola | Frankel | Kingmambo | Summer Squall | hemare |
| Hadrosaur | Hansen | Alysheba | Danzig | Sour Golf |
| Lingering Smoke | Drosselmeyer | Dehere | Alydar | Scratch |
| Blank Space | Tapit | Distorted Humor | Hennessy | Taylor’s Study |
| Lightning Strife | Awesome Again | Storm Cat | Danzig | Magpies Cat |
| Pulpasnitz | Snitzel | Dehere | Pulpit | Wheel Night |
| Deadmoney Cadet | More Than Ready | Unbridled’s Song | A.P. Indy | Scratch |
| Vyrantium | More Than Ready | Storm Cat | Mr. Prospector | Breakneck |
| Storm Cat Humor | Distorted Humor | Storm Cat | Unbridled’s Song | Scratch |
| Make Em Believe | Macho Uno | Green Desert | Seattle Slew | Jupiter The Sea |
| Kamden | Blame | A.P. Indy | Storm Cat | Scratch |
| Lion’s Slew | Lion Heart | Seattle Slew | Giant’s Causeway | Scratch |
| Mach Three Launch | Macho Uno | Forty Niner | Red Ransom | Redhead Nicole |
| Nureyev’s Ghost | Ghostzapper | Nureyev | Seattle Slew | Scratch |
| Giant Storm Brewing | Gio Ponti | Giant’s Causeway | Kingmambo | Northwest Passage II |
| Redd Rocks | Curlin | Red Ransom | Alysheba | Alyredhead |
| Swapsco Kitty | Scat Daddy | Saint Ballado | Broad Brush | Scratch |
| Billie Holiday | Dubawi | Bernardini | Storm Cat | Lena Horne |
| Sophia Loren | Ghostzapper | Bernardini | Street Cry | Ava Gardner |
| Destiny Wings | Distorted Humor | A.P. Indy | Broad Brush | Scratch |
| Damasquerade | Creative Cause | Spectacular Bid | Indian Ridge | Scratch |
| A Prize She Makes | Pure Prize | Broad Brush | Raise A Native | Scratch |
| Plage De Tahiti | Majestic Warrior | Storm Cat | Unbridled | White Sand |
| Cape Road | Cape Blanco | Quality Road | Storm Cat | Quality Cat |
| Cajun Custom | Custom For Carlos | Curlin | Broad Brush | Wavy |
| Kicking Queen | Kingman | Kingmambo | Seattle Slew | Injection |
| Arc Weld | Arch | Seattle Slew | Storm Cat | Enough Till Storm |
| The Joy Never Ends | Kitten’s Joy | Unbridled’s Song | A.P. Indy | Oil On Top |
| How’d That Happen | Kodiac | Forty Niner | Blushing John | Blushing Niner |
| Barden Bella | Street Cry | Storm Cat | Seattle Slew | Kitty Katz |
| Silver Shot K | Trappe Shot | Silver Deputy | Galileo | Kens Mystery |
| Miss Mo | Uncle Mo | Unbridled’s Song | A.P. Indy | Act Quickly |
| Meztli Moon | Malibu Moon | Deputy Minister | Alydar | Scratch |
| Archezata | Arch | Deputy Minister | Mr. Prospector | Kamikaze |
| Oil Forever | Canford Cliffs | Unbridled’s Song | A.P. Indy | Oil On Top |
| Super Good | Super Saver | Unbridled | Roberto | Scratch |
| Megastorm | Medaglia D’oro | Storm | Forty Niner | Alberta Storm |
| Sebastopol | Union Rags | Malibu Moon | Sadler’s Wells | Sonoma Coast |
| Mr. P’s Meds | Medaglia D’oro | Bernardini | Mr. Prospector | Scratch |
| What Is Obedience | Malibu Moon | Kris S. | Raise A Native | Scratch |
| Kukaa Salama | Street Cry | A.P. Indy | Deputy Minister | Lala Salama |
| In the System | Tiznow | Broad Brush | Nijinsky II | Scratch |
| Outback Leeton | Smart Strike | Storm Cat | Broad Brush | Scratch |
| Fake Honeymoon | Bernardini | Sadler’s Wells | Alydar | Across the Sunrise |
| Fire Of Drogon | Street Cry | Dynaformer | Nijinsky II | Scratch |
| Swinging Big Shaft | Mineshaft | Distorted Humor | Giant’s Causeway | Distorted Revenge |
| Bayou Bullet | Bernardini | Seeking the Gold | Nijinsky II | Scratch |
| Rhaegar’s Fury | Daiwa Major | Ghostzapper | Gone West | The Trident |
| Inculpate | Blame | A.P. Indy | Forty Niner | Whisper Venus |
| Barb’s Evil Laugh | Graydar | Forty Niner | Storm Cat | Barb’s Stormcat |
| The Town I Loved | Tapit | Seeking the Gold | Hoist the Flag | Flagger |
| Ready To Travel | More Than Ready | Gone West | Monsun | Scratch |
| Summer Rocker | Summer Bird | A.P. Indy | Theatrical | Indy Rock |
| I Won’t Look Back | Malibu Moon | Street Cry | Deputy Minister | Scratch |
| Hopewell Blues | Gio Ponti | Halo | Grey Dawn II | Scratch |
| Vega Rises | Lope De Vega | Fastnet Rock | Summer Squall | Decree of Justice |
| Sophies Apple Tree | Tapit | Awesome Again | Mr. Prospector | Queen For a Knight |
| Obnoxiously | Frankel | Storm Cat | Kingmambo | Scratch |
| Andrew’s Impact | Deep Impact | A.P. Indy | Northern Dancer | Scratch |
| Diadumenian | Invincible Spirit | Kingmambo | Seattle Slew | Luna Park |
| Chakalakalka Boom | Empire Maker | Distorted Humor | Storm Cat | A Ha Cha Cha |
| Spinnin And Grinnin | Tapit | Thunder Gulch | Danzig | hemare |
| Going Strong | Unbridled’s Song | Private Account | Danzig | Scratch |
| The Biggest Impact | Deep Impact | Giant’s Causeway | Kingmambo | The Biggest Hit |
| Always’s Amazing | Montjeu | Rainbow Quest | Kingmambo | Scratch |
| London Guildhall | Street Cry | Sadler’s Wells | Monsun | Scratch |
| Kris Rock | Rock of Gibraltar | Kris S. | Montjeu | Scratch |
| River Slaney | Sea the Stars | Sadler’s Wells | Roberto | Wexford County |
| Baaad Kitty | Kitten’s Joy | Lyphard | Sharpen Up | Scratch |
| Junmai Daiginjo | Medaglia D’oro | Dynaformer | Danzig | Sake |
| Smart Impactor | Deep Impact | Montjeu | Street Cry | Jilly |
| The End of Time | Teofilo | Empire Maker | Mill Reef | Sound of Da Police |
| El Nina | Monsun | Sadler’s Wells | Mill Reef | Scratch |
| Jessa | Galileo | Kingmambo | Storm Bird | Fourth Spice Filly |
| Cobb’s Hill | Dylan Thomas | Street Cry | Sadler’s Wells | hemare |
| Dawnguard | Medaglia D’oro | Theatrical | Mill Reef | hemare |
| Street Akna | Street Cry | A.P. Indy | Sadler’s Wells | Dynawells |
| Chap’s Groom | High Chaparral | Kingmambo | Blushing Groom | Scratch |
| Shameful | Shamardal | Deep Impact | Unbridled | Deep Cascade |
| Fasting And Prayer | Fastnet Rock | Nureyev | Kris S. | Scratch |
| Macundo Profundo | Deep Impact | Danehill | A.P. Indy | Scratch |
| Ketaring Point | Point of Entry | El Prado | Fappiano | Ketaring |
| Wilhelm Schmeck | Pivotal | Diesis | Caerleon | Scratch |
| Cardiff Castle | Street Cry | Giant’s Causeway | Sadler’s Wells | Esterhazy Castle |
| Montjeuelry | Montjeu | Kris S. | Key to the Mint | Scratch |
| Seacastle Call | Sea the Stars | Caerleon | Street Cry | Scratch |
| Maybe Not Today | Galileo | Dynaformer | Nijinsky II | Out of Spite |
| Got This On Locke | English Channel | Danehill | Roberto | Scratch |
| Bleeding Gums | Dalakhani | Zabeel | Nijinsky II | Scratch |
| Superdrago | Dynaformer | Sadler’s Wells | Seattle Slew | Scratch |
| Terrible Tad | Stately Victor | Pleasant Colony | Topsider | Scratch |
Great article a hell of a lot of hard work. Thanks for your efforts!
Yeah, liked this a lot. Thank you for putting it together. Gonna save this one!
Good stuff, good analysis!
Great work Spin. Didn’t realize this was up, or we could have discussed!
Great job putting this together. Thanks for all the hard work.
Top shelf reporting, thanks a heap for your expertise
A wealth of information, thank you for putting so much effort into this.
Thanks — good stuff !!!